Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Court of appeal reverses on interim relief applications in Russian courts: implications for claimants

Elizaveta Razina · October 2026 · 6 min read

Russian appellate court reversed interim relief on offshore assets. Key implications for foreign claimants and instructing counsel. Make an enquiry.

In the course of advising foreign law firms on Russian enforcement mandates, a recurrent assumption surfaces: that an interim relief order obtained at first instance provides a stable foundation on which to build a recovery strategy. A recent appellate decision in Russia has tested that assumption directly, and the outcome carries material consequences for foreign claimants and for the firms instructing Russian lawyers on their behalf. The appellate court reversed an interim relief order that had frozen assets linked to an offshore holding structure, finding that the evidentiary threshold for demonstrating a real risk of dissipation had not been met to the standard required at the appellate level. For instructing counsel, the ruling repays careful analysis.

If you are currently instructing Russian lawyers on an interim relief application or reviewing an existing order — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Background

The proceedings concerned a commercial dispute in which a foreign claimant sought to freeze assets held through an offshore vehicle with connections to Russia. At first instance, the Russian court granted the interim relief application on the basis of a broadly framed submission that the respondent's corporate structure created a risk of dissipation, supported by documentary evidence of asset movements. The first-instance decision appeared, on its face, to reflect the prevailing approach in Russian court practice: courts at that level have generally shown a degree of procedural generosity when a claimant's substantive claim is adequately supported. The appellate court took a materially different view. It did not dispute the underlying merits of the claimant's case. Instead, it focused on the evidentiary quality of the dissipation risk analysis. The appellate panel found that the documentary record established historical asset movements but did not, in the court's assessment, demonstrate a prospective and imminent risk of dissipation of a kind sufficient to justify the continued restraint of assets. The interim relief order was discharged. The decision is consistent with a discernible pattern in Russian appellate courts: a narrowing of the evidentiary standard that will sustain an interim order on appeal, particularly where offshore structures are involved.

The decision

The appellate court's reasoning rested on a distinction that practitioners advising foreign claimants in Russia will need to internalise. Evidence that an asset has moved, or that a corporate structure is capable of moving assets, does not automatically satisfy the prospective risk standard that appellate panels apply when reviewing interim relief in Russian courts. The court required positive evidence of a concrete and near-term intention to dissipate, or of specific triggering conditions that would cause dissipation in the event the interim order were lifted. This is a demanding standard, and it is one that first-instance courts have not consistently required. The consequence of that inconsistency is now visible: a class of interim relief orders that survive at first instance will be vulnerable on appeal, and foreign claimants who have structured their enforcement strategy around a first-instance order may find themselves without the protective mechanism they believed was in place. The court also commented, briefly, on the adequacy of the undertaking as to damages provided by the claimant. This element of the reasoning is less developed in the decision than the evidentiary point, but it signals that appellate panels are prepared to look beyond the threshold question of whether interim relief was justified and to examine the procedural preconditions that must accompany any such order. For firms instructing Russian lawyers on behalf of creditor clients, this aspect of the ruling warrants attention when drafting the application package.

"The appellate reversal here reflects a maturing standard: Russian courts are increasingly treating interim relief as a measure requiring prospective, not merely historical, evidence of dissipation risk — a distinction that shapes how applications must be framed from the outset." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

Firms advising foreign creditors with Russian-connected assets should review whether existing interim relief orders meet the appellate evidentiary standard — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For foreign law firms instructing local counsel Russia on asset tracing and recovery matters, the practical implications of this ruling fall into three areas. First, application design: the evidentiary package supporting an interim relief application in Russia should be built, from the outset, to withstand appellate scrutiny — not merely to satisfy the more accommodating first-instance threshold. This means the prospective dissipation risk analysis must be anchored to specific, contemporaneous evidence rather than to structural inference alone. Second, strategic sequencing: where interim relief is a load-bearing element of the enforcement strategy — as it typically is in matters involving offshore assets with Russian connections — the risk of appellate discharge should be priced into the strategy at the instruction stage. Contingency planning that assumes the order will survive appeal in all cases is, in the light of this Russia ruling for foreign parties, no longer adequate. Third, the undertaking as to damages: the appellate court's observations on this point suggest that Russian courts may apply closer scrutiny to the form and substance of the undertaking, including whether it is backed by identifiable assets within the jurisdiction. This is an area where the interface between Russian procedural requirements and the foreign client's practical capacity to provide a meaningful undertaking will require early coordination between instructing counsel and Russian lawyers. The Asset Tracing & Recovery practice at Vetrov & Partners regularly advises foreign law firms on the design and execution of interim relief applications in Russian courts, including the post-order management of challenges. The firm has also published a detailed analysis of shifting court practice on interim relief at Court practice shift on interim relief applications in Russian courts and a risk-oriented companion piece at Key risk points in interim relief applications before Russian courts.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign law firms instructing Russian lawyers on interim relief matters?

A: The ruling makes explicit a standard that has been developing in Russian appellate practice but was not consistently applied at first instance: that an interim relief order requires positive, forward-looking evidence of a real and near-term risk of asset dissipation. Historical evidence of asset movements, or evidence of a corporate structure that is capable of dissipating assets, will not automatically sustain an order on appeal. For foreign law firms instructing Russian lawyers, this means the evidentiary package must be designed for the appellate standard from the outset, rather than calibrated to the more permissive first-instance threshold. It also means that enforcement strategies built around an existing first-instance order should be reviewed for appellate vulnerability.

Q: What should foreign companies and their advisers do in light of this decision?

A: Three steps are advisable. First, any existing Russian interim relief order in a matter involving offshore assets should be assessed against the evidentiary standard articulated by the appellate court — specifically, whether the dissipation risk analysis rests on prospective evidence or primarily on historical or structural inference. Second, applications not yet filed should be redesigned, with the evidentiary framework and the undertaking as to damages both prepared to the appellate standard. Third, instructing counsel should confirm with their Russian lawyers that the application package addresses the undertaking-as-to-damages requirements that Russian courts may scrutinise. Vetrov & Partners advises on all three stages and can review existing application packages on request.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry