Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Expert witness use in interim relief applications in Russian courts

Elizaveta Razina · July 2026 · 5 min read

Russian courts now scrutinise expert evidence in interim relief with increasing rigour. What instructing counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.

In practice, the evidentiary threshold that Russian courts apply to interim relief applications sits at a level that many foreign instructing firms do not anticipate. Expert witness evidence, when introduced at the interim stage, is assessed neither to the standard of full merits proof nor simply accepted at face value. Russian court practice has settled on a probabilistic standard – does the application demonstrate a reasonable basis for believing that the respondent's assets are at risk of dissipation or concealment? – and expert opinion evidence is evaluated against that specific question, not the underlying dispute.

What courts require from expert evidence in interim relief applications

The core requirement, as established through Supreme Court guidance on interim measures and reflected in the prevailing approach of the arbitrazh courts, is relevance to the grounds for interim relief, not to the merits of the primary claim. An expert report directed at demonstrating the claimant's substantive case – the value of a loss, the technical particulars of an alleged breach – will ordinarily carry limited weight in interim relief proceedings in Russia unless it also speaks to asset risk.

Courts are primarily interested in two questions at this stage. First, whether there is a genuine connection between the facts described by the expert and the specific assets the claimant seeks to freeze or recover. Second, whether the expert's analysis supports the urgency element – that delay in granting relief would result in practical frustration of any eventual judgment or award.

Expert reports drafted to Western or common-law conventions frequently address neither question directly. A report structured around establishing causation or quantifying loss may be entirely appropriate for the trial stage but will not, by itself, satisfy a Russian arbitrazh court at the interim stage. Instructing counsel preparing to engage local counsel Russia should factor in the need for a separate – or substantially re-focused – expert contribution at the interim applications stage.

A brief but important procedural point: Russian civil procedure does not provide for oral expert examination at interim relief hearings in the same way that common-law systems do. The expert's contribution is documentary. This makes the clarity, structure, and jurisdictional focus of the written report the only medium through which the expert's analysis can reach the court.

How do Russian courts assess expert evidence in practice?

In practice, Russian arbitrazh courts approach expert evidence in interim relief applications through the lens of judicial economy: the application is decided quickly, and the expert material must make its point without requiring the court to work through extended technical elaboration. Reports that exceed approximately ten pages of substantive analysis are, in the experience of practitioners in this field, less effective than concise, focussed submissions that identify the asset risk in clear terms.

Circuit variation exists and should be acknowledged. Courts in the Moscow circuit, which handle a disproportionately high volume of commercially significant interim relief applications, have in recent years shown greater receptiveness to forensic accounting evidence in support of asset dissipation arguments – particularly where offshore assets with Russian-registered counterparts are involved. Courts in the Siberian and Ural circuits, where Vetrov & Partners has direct procedural experience, apply the same legal standard but tend to favour straightforward asset-identification evidence over complex financial modelling.

A further practical point concerns the source of the expert appointment. Russian civil procedure distinguishes between a court-appointed expert and an expert instructed by a party. At the interim stage, party-instructed expert reports are the relevant format – the court appointment mechanism applies at the merits stage and is not available in interim applications. Foreign instructing firms should be aware that a report from an expert not admitted to practice in Russia, or from a foreign-domiciled expert, is not inadmissible on that ground alone, but the court will weight it differently from a report by a Russia-qualified expert with relevant domain credentials. Where offshore asset Russia issues are in play – for example, tracing assets through a Russian operating company to beneficial interests held offshore – the dual-jurisdiction dimension of the expert's analysis should be structured so that the Russian-law elements are clearly delineated and, where possible, confirmed by Russian-qualified expert input.

For instructing counsel considering the use of foreign experts in interim relief applications Russia, the practical recommendation is to structure the engagement so that the foreign expert addresses the foreign-law or foreign-market elements, while a Russia-qualified specialist addresses the Russian court practice and asset identification dimension. This division typically yields a more coherent product from the court's perspective and reduces the risk that the expert contribution is treated as directed at the wrong question.

What instructing counsel should do before filing

The following steps reflect current Russian court practice for interim relief applications in which expert evidence will be submitted. They apply regardless of whether the underlying matter is an arbitration or state court proceeding.

For instructing firms engaging local counsel in Russia for asset tracing and recovery matters, early coordination between foreign expert and Russian counsel typically determines whether the expert evidence reaches the court in a form it can use.

If you are instructing Russian lawyers on an interim relief application and need guidance on expert evidence requirements – contact the team at info@vetrovpartners.com or via

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry