Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Business Crime Defence

Court of appeal reverses on internal investigation management under Russian law: implications for claimants

Vitaliy Vetrov · May 2026 · 8 min read

A Russian appeal court ruling shifts internal investigation management obligations. Foreign managers face new procedural exposure. Make an enquiry.

In the past two years of advising foreign executives in Russian corporate structures, one question has surfaced with increasing frequency: how does an internal investigation conducted by or at the direction of a foreign manager interact with Russian criminal procedure? A recent appellate ruling has sharpened that question considerably. The court of appeal reversed the first-instance decision on the management of an internal investigation, holding that procedural steps taken by corporate officers – including non-Russian nationals – can be material to the subsequent criminal assessment of their conduct. For expat executives currently serving in Russian companies, the ruling is worth understanding carefully.

Background

A mid-sized Russian operating company, majority-owned by a foreign parent, became the subject of a regulatory inquiry involving alleged financial irregularities. The company's management – including a foreign national serving as a senior executive – initiated an internal investigation to identify the source of the discrepancy before the matter escalated to formal proceedings. The first-instance court, assessing an ancillary procedural question, found that the manner in which the internal investigation had been organised was an internal corporate matter outside the scope of the criminal review then under way.

The appeal arose when investigative authorities challenged that finding. The appellate court disagreed with the lower court's framing. Its central holding was that internal investigation management under Russian law is not procedurally quarantined from the criminal process: where the investigation involves officers with signatory or managerial authority, the steps they take – including which documents are gathered, which employees are interviewed, and in what sequence – can constitute conduct relevant to the criminal inquiry. The court's reversal turned specifically on the question of whether the foreign executive's direction of the internal investigation amounted to participation in conduct under review.

This distinction – between an investigation as a purely corporate governance exercise and an investigation as conduct visible to the criminal process – is not new in Russian legal thinking. What the appellate decision adds is a clearer articulation of the conditions under which the former becomes the latter, with consequences that affect any foreign manager currently overseeing or directing such a process.

The decision

The appellate court's reasoning rested on two related points. First, it held that internal investigation management in Russia does not enjoy a protected zone analogous to attorney-client privilege or legal professional privilege in common law systems. Documents generated in the course of the investigation, and the sequence of steps taken, remain potentially accessible to investigators if the investigation itself becomes a subject of scrutiny. Second, the court held that the authority formally vested in a manager – by virtue of their position in the Russian legal entity – means they cannot separate their corporate conduct from their personal legal exposure. A foreign executive directing an investigation is doing so as an officer of a Russian company, not as an agent of the foreign parent.

"The decision illustrates a structural asymmetry that foreign executives frequently underestimate: in Russia, managing an investigation is itself a form of conduct, assessed against the same standard as the conduct under review." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

The practical implications turn on a number of procedural variables. The scope of the executive's formal authority within the Russian entity matters: the broader the signatory powers, the more directly the court's reasoning applies. The timing also matters: an investigation initiated before investigative authorities have opened a case operates in a materially different procedural environment than one initiated after a formal inquiry has begun. And the involvement – or absence – of Russian-qualified defence counsel during the investigation itself was a factor the appellate court noted, though it declined to make it determinative.

Foreign managers should also understand the connection between internal investigation management and travel restrictions. Where a senior officer becomes a person of interest in an inquiry linked to events the internal investigation was meant to examine, the conditions for an exit ban under Russian law – which can be imposed without a criminal charge having been filed – may be engaged earlier than the manager expects. The appellate ruling does not directly address exit ban procedure, but the procedural logic it establishes makes the connection more proximate than prior case law suggested.

For those advising foreign companies with Russian operations, the decision is a reminder that the Business Crime Defence analysis of an executive's position must extend to the investigation governance layer, not only to the substantive allegations. The firm's earlier analysis of court practice on this point – Court practice shift on internal investigation management – noted the direction of travel; this appellate decision confirms it.

If you are a foreign executive currently directing or overseeing an internal investigation in a Russian entity – make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For foreign executives in Russian companies, the immediate practical question is not whether an internal investigation was justified, but how it was governed. The appellate court's reasoning applies to the mechanics of management: who gave instructions, in what form, and what documentation was produced. Executives who directed the investigation informally – verbally, without contemporaneous written record, or through intermediaries whose authority was ambiguous – are in a more exposed position than those who did so through a structured, legally supervised process.

Three implications follow directly from the ruling.

First, the distinction between the foreign executive acting as a corporate officer and as an individual is less durable under Russian law than comparable positions in German, English, or Dutch law. Russian criminal procedure attributes conduct to individuals through the lens of their formal authority within the Russian legal entity. A foreign manager appointed as a director, general director, or authorised signatory of a Russian company carries that authority whether or not they are physically present in Russia when they give instructions.

Second, the absence of qualified Russian counsel during the investigation is a factor courts may note adversely. This does not mean that every internal investigation requires the immediate involvement of criminal defence counsel – many investigations are a normal part of corporate governance and never approach criminal territory. But where the subject matter of the investigation overlaps with conduct that could attract regulatory or criminal attention, the involvement of Russian-qualified counsel from the outset changes the procedural character of the steps taken.

Third, any foreign executive who has recently directed an internal investigation involving financial, procurement, or regulatory matters in a Russian entity should review their current exposure in light of this ruling. The review is not a complex exercise, but it requires a clear-eyed assessment of the formal authority they held, the scope of the investigation, and the documentation trail. Our key risk points guide for internal investigation management sets out the specific checkpoints relevant to this assessment.

Foreign companies managing Russian operations remotely – a structure that became common after 2022 – face a particular variant of this risk. When the internal investigation is directed from abroad by a manager who retains formal authority within the Russian entity, the appellate court's reasoning does not become inapplicable simply because the manager is not on Russian soil. The Russian legal entity's governance structure is assessed under Russian law, and the manager's instructions, wherever given, are assessed as acts of an officer of that entity. For groups managing this exposure, the Business Crime Defence practice and the firm's broader matters experience across regulatory and criminal defence work provide the relevant reference point.

To discuss your current position in confidence – make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: Prior to this appellate decision, the prevailing first-instance position in many Russian circuits treated internal investigation management as a corporate governance matter, insulated from the criminal inquiry running in parallel. The appellate ruling changes that framing: it holds that where a manager with formal authority within the Russian entity directs the investigation, the steps they take are visible to the criminal process and may be assessed as conduct in their own right. In practice, this means that a foreign executive who manages an internal investigation without qualified Russian counsel, and without a clear procedural structure, may inadvertently create a documentary record that investigators can use against them. The change is not in the statutory framework – Russian criminal procedure has always permitted investigators broad access to corporate documentation – but in how courts are applying that framework to investigation governance.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: The most immediate step is to audit the governance of any internal investigation currently under way in a Russian operating entity. That audit should map who held formal authority, what instructions were given and in what form, and whether Russian-qualified defence counsel was involved. Where the investigation has already concluded, the review should assess whether its subject matter overlaps with matters that are now, or could become, the subject of regulatory or criminal scrutiny. For investigations not yet under way, the practical response is to involve Russian counsel at the design stage rather than after the fact, to structure the investigation so that the executive's role is clearly defined and documented, and to consider whether the scope of the executive's formal authority within the Russian entity should be reviewed in light of this ruling. Foreign companies operating remotely should not assume that physical absence from Russia provides procedural insulation from these principles.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry