Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Business Crime Defence

Russian arbitrazh court clarifies subsidiary liability interface with Russian criminal proceedings: key takeaways

Vitaliy Vetrov · October 2026 · 7 min read

A Russian arbitrazh court has clarified how subsidiary liability intersects with criminal proceedings. What expat executives need to know. Make an enquiry.

In advising foreign executives managing Russian subsidiaries over the past several years, one pattern has become increasingly clear: the boundary between civil subsidiary liability and the Russian criminal process is less stable than most corporate governance frameworks assume. A recent ruling by a Russian arbitrazh court has sharpened that boundary in a way that carries direct practical consequences for foreign managers holding formal positions in Russian entities. The decision does not overturn established doctrine, but it refines how courts assess the interface between a director's personal civil exposure and any parallel criminal investigation touching the same underlying conduct.

Background

The proceedings arose from a commercial dispute in which a creditor sought to hold the director of an insolvent Russian company personally liable under subsidiary liability provisions — the mechanism by which Russian insolvency law allows courts to pierce the corporate veil and recover against individuals whose conduct contributed to the company's financial failure. The respondent was a foreign national holding an executive role in the Russian entity. Separately, and prior to the civil proceedings, Russian investigative authorities had opened a criminal inquiry into overlapping facts: the same corporate decisions, the same transfer of assets, the same period of alleged mismanagement.

The central legal question before the arbitrazh court was whether, and to what extent, findings made or positions advanced in the parallel criminal process could influence the civil subsidiary liability analysis. More precisely, the court was asked to consider whether a criminal investigation — not yet resulting in a conviction — could be treated as a relevant factor in assessing the director's culpability for the purposes of the civil claim. The court's treatment of this question, and the reasoning it applied, is what makes the decision worth examining. For foreign executives currently holding directorships in Russian subsidiaries, the answer has implications that extend well beyond the specific facts of this matter.

If you are a foreign executive holding a directorship in a Russian entity and a criminal inquiry is under way, we recommend taking early legal advice. Discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

The decision

The arbitrazh court declined to treat the existence of a criminal investigation as a determinative factor in establishing civil liability — but it did not dismiss its relevance entirely. The court's position, as it emerges from the reasoning, rests on a distinction that Russian procedural doctrine has recognised but not always applied consistently: the evidentiary standards applicable in criminal proceedings differ fundamentally from those governing civil subsidiary liability. A criminal investigation presupposes the involvement of investigative authorities operating under criminal procedure rules; civil subsidiary liability is assessed on the balance of probabilities and by reference to the conduct standards that Russian insolvency legislation imposes on controlling persons.

What the court held, in substance, is that material gathered in the course of a criminal inquiry — documents, witness statements, expert conclusions — can be admitted and weighed in civil proceedings, but cannot substitute for the independent civil analysis. The civil court retains its own jurisdictional function. It neither defers to conclusions reached in the criminal process nor is obliged to suspend the civil claim pending the outcome of a criminal prosecution. In practice, this means that a foreign director facing both a subsidiary liability claim and a parallel criminal inquiry cannot assume that the civil claim will be stayed, that a criminal acquittal will extinguish civil exposure, or that an absence of criminal charges will preclude a finding of civil liability.

"The decision confirms what careful practitioners have long advised: criminal and civil tracks operate in parallel under Russian law, and a foreign executive must treat each as independently capable of producing adverse consequences." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

The court also addressed, in passing, the position of a foreign director who invokes the principle that self-incrimination concerns in the criminal process may constrain the evidence that can be produced in the civil forum. The arbitrazh court's approach was cautious: it acknowledged the tension but did not resolve it in the respondent's favour, suggesting that foreign executives should not rely on a mechanical privilege assertion as a litigation strategy in Russian civil proceedings.

What does this ruling change for foreign clients?

For foreign nationals holding executive roles in Russian subsidiaries — whether as general directors, chief financial officers, or members of the board — the ruling consolidates and sharpens a risk picture that many have underestimated. Three practical implications are worth noting.

First, the independence of the civil and criminal tracks means that exposure under subsidiary liability provisions is not contingent on the outcome of any criminal process. A criminal investigation that is ultimately discontinued does not close the civil route. A foreign executive who has managed a Russian subsidiary through a period of financial difficulty may face a subsidiary liability claim years after the criminal matter has resolved — or indeed at the same time, on parallel fronts.

Second, the court's treatment of documentary evidence generated in the criminal process confirms that materials produced or obtained during an investigation may find their way into civil proceedings. Foreign executives should assume that communications, management decisions, and board-level documentation that have already been reviewed by investigative authorities are potentially available to a civil claimant. This reinforces the importance of document management discipline from the earliest stage of any investigation.

Third, and perhaps most directly relevant to foreign managers, the ruling underlines that Russian arbitrazh courts will not automatically give weight to the structural differences between foreign corporate governance norms and Russian law expectations. A foreign executive appointed to a Russian directorship under an international group structure is assessed by Russian courts against the conduct standards applicable under Russian insolvency and corporate legislation — not against the governance expectations of their home jurisdiction.

For firms advising clients with Russian subsidiaries and executive appointments, the Business Crime Defence practice at Vetrov & Partners advises on both the civil exposure dimension and the criminal procedure dimension. Early coordination across both tracks — before positions become entrenched — is, in the firm's experience, the most effective approach. See also our related analysis on the legislative framework governing subsidiary liability and our earlier briefing on the subsidiary liability and criminal proceedings interface.

For in-house counsel or group legal teams managing cross-border exposure involving a Russian entity, the Matters page illustrates the range of mandates the firm has handled in analogous situations.

To discuss your matter in confidence, contact us at info@vetrovpartners.com or reach the team directly on

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign directors already facing a subsidiary liability claim in Russia?

A: The ruling reinforces that Russian arbitrazh courts assess subsidiary liability independently of any parallel criminal proceedings. A foreign director cannot assume that a criminal acquittal, or the closure of a criminal investigation, will preclude a finding of civil liability. The civil claim is governed by its own evidentiary and conduct standards under Russian insolvency and corporate legislation. Directors in this position should ensure they have separate legal representation for the civil and criminal dimensions — ideally with counsel who understands the interaction between the two tracks under Russian procedural law.

Q: What should foreign managers do in light of this decision?

A: Three steps are advisable. First, review your current exposure under Russian subsidiary liability provisions — particularly if you hold or have held a directorship in a Russian entity that is insolvent, near-insolvent, or has experienced significant financial difficulty. Second, audit the documentary trail of management decisions taken during any period that may be in issue — because, as this ruling confirms, materials gathered in a criminal inquiry can be used in civil proceedings. Third, take early legal advice in Russia before positions in either the civil or criminal track become fixed. The window for managing exposure proactively is typically narrowest once formal proceedings have commenced.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry