Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Business Crime Defence

Russian arbitrazh court on search and seizure in Russian criminal investigations for British executives: key takeaways

Vitaliy Vetrov · July 2026 · 7 min read

Russian courts have clarified search and seizure powers in criminal proceedings. What British executives in Russia need to know. Make an enquiry.

In advising British executives working within Russian commercial structures, one question arises with striking regularity: what actually happens when investigators arrive at the office, and what rights does the executive — or the company — retain at that moment? A recent decision by a Russian arbitrazh court, in which a commercial entity successfully challenged the continued retention of seized business assets following criminal proceedings initiated against its director, provides a useful occasion to examine how Russian courts approach the intersection of criminal investigative powers and commercial property rights. The ruling does not rewrite the framework, but it sharpens several points of practical importance for any foreign national holding a senior position in a Russian company.

Background

In Russian law, search and seizure in criminal proceedings is governed by the Code of Criminal Procedure. Investigators may conduct searches of premises and seize documents, devices, and other items once a criminal case has been opened and the relevant procedural requirements have been observed. The procedure applies to individuals and to premises associated with them — including, in practice, corporate offices and server infrastructure where the suspect is a director or beneficial owner. The company itself is not a party to criminal proceedings, but its assets may be affected where investigators determine that seized property is relevant to the investigation or could be used to satisfy a future civil claim within the proceedings.

This intersection — between criminal procedure and commercial property rights — is precisely where arbitrazh courts have a foothold. While courts of general jurisdiction handle the criminal case itself, a commercial entity that considers its property rights to have been unlawfully restricted may bring a separate challenge before the arbitrazh court. In the matter under review, a company whose office equipment, financial records, and digital storage media had been seized in the course of an investigation into its director brought proceedings seeking the return of assets it argued were not the subject of, and not reasonably connected to, any legitimate investigative purpose. The question before the court was not whether the investigation was lawful, but whether the continuing retention of specific categories of business assets was proportionate and procedurally sound.

For British executives in comparable positions — whether as director, general director, or senior manager of a Russian subsidiary or joint venture — the procedural map described in this matter is directly relevant. Understanding where the arbitrazh track begins and where it ends matters considerably when planning a legal response under Russian criminal procedure.

The decision

The arbitrazh court found in favour of the commercial entity on a narrow but significant ground: the investigating authority had not demonstrated, within the period examined, that the retained items were either material evidence in the criminal case or subject to a lawful property restriction order in connection with it. The court drew a distinction between the initial seizure — which it treated as within the investigator's powers — and the prolonged retention of assets that the investigation had not subsequently formally designated as evidence or as the subject of a confiscation claim. On that basis, the court ordered the return of certain categories of equipment and documentation.

The ruling did not disturb the investigation itself, and the court was careful to limit its reasoning to the property rights dimension. It noted that criminal proceedings against the director remained a matter for the court of general jurisdiction and that nothing in its order affected the conduct of that case. This framing — narrow, calibrated, explicitly non-intrusive on criminal jurisdiction — is characteristic of how arbitrazh courts have tended to handle applications of this kind in recent years. The court is not invited to assess guilt or innocence; it is asked whether a retained asset meets the procedural conditions for continued restriction.

"The case confirms that prolonged asset retention without formal evidentiary designation is a procedural vulnerability — and one that a well-prepared legal team can challenge effectively in the arbitrazh track." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

For British executives and the companies they lead, the significance of this approach is practical. It means that where investigators seize business assets and then fail to complete the formal procedural steps required to maintain that seizure on proper grounds, the company retains a viable route to challenge. That route runs through the arbitrazh court, not through the criminal proceedings themselves — and it requires specialised counsel who can navigate both tracks simultaneously.

If your company's assets have been seized in connection with criminal proceedings in Russia, or if you are a British executive facing investigative scrutiny, speaking with experienced Russian criminal procedure counsel at an early stage is the most important practical step. Discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For British nationals holding directorships or senior management roles in Russian entities, the decision offers three practical takeaways that should inform how they approach criminal risk in Russia.

First, the company's legal position is separate from the individual's. Even where criminal proceedings are directed at a director personally, the company retains independent legal standing to challenge measures that restrict its property rights. This separation is not always intuitive for executives accustomed to English law, where the distinction between individual and corporate criminal exposure operates differently. In Russia, acting on behalf of the company — through the arbitrazh track — does not prejudice or implicitly concede anything in the criminal proceedings. The two tracks are legally distinct.

Second, timing matters considerably. The arbitrazh challenge in this matter succeeded in part because counsel identified the procedural gap — the absence of a formal evidentiary designation — at a stage when it was still arguable. Had the investigation progressed to a point where those designations had been formalised, the basis for the challenge would have narrowed significantly. For any British executive whose company has been subject to a search and seizure, the question of which assets were seized and on what formal basis should be assessed with Russian counsel as promptly as circumstances allow.

Third, the existence of the arbitrazh track is not widely understood among foreign executives who have not previously encountered Russian criminal procedure. The instinctive response — to engage only with the criminal defence lawyer handling the individual case — leaves the corporate asset position unaddressed. A coordinated approach, in which the criminal defence team and the commercial litigation team are working in parallel and communicating with each other, is materially more effective than a siloed one. The firm's Business Crime Defence practice operates with precisely this coordination in view.

For context on how the legislative framework governing search and seizure has evolved, see Legislative amendments affecting search and seizure procedure in Russia and the broader procedural overview in Search and seizure in Russian criminal investigations: a practitioner's guide. A record of representative matters in this area is available on the Matters page.

At this stage, having experienced counsel who understands both Russian criminal procedure and the cross-border dimension — including the specific concerns that apply to British nationals working in Russia under current conditions — is the practical priority.

To discuss your legal position in confidence, contact Vetrov & Partners: info@vetrovpartners.com | | asked questionsQ: What does this ruling change for British executives working in Russian companies? A: The ruling does not alter the fundamental scope of investigative powers under Russian criminal procedure — investigators retain the authority to conduct searches and seize assets where the procedural conditions are met. What the decision reinforces is that continued retention of seized business assets is subject to a distinct proportionality and procedural adequacy standard, and that a commercial entity has a viable route — through the arbitrazh court — to challenge retention that is not supported by formal evidentiary designation. For British executives, this is most directly relevant where the company they lead has had assets seized in proceedings directed at them personally: the company's position can and should be addressed in parallel with the individual criminal defence.

Q: What should a British executive do immediately following a search of company premises in Russia? A: The priority immediately following a search is to establish, with Russian counsel, precisely what was seized and under what procedural authority. This means reviewing the search warrant and the seizure protocol — documents that investigators are required to provide — and identifying whether each category of seized item has been formally designated in a way that establishes a continuing lawful basis for retention. Criminal procedure counsel should be engaged for the individual dimension; commercial litigation counsel should assess the company's position separately. The two engagements should be coordinated from the outset, not treated as independent matters. Vetrov & Partners advises on both dimensions and can engage English-language counsel in the UK where required for cross-border coordination.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry