Russian civil and criminal proceedings may run simultaneously against one person. Key implications for foreign executives in Russia. Make an enquiry.
Russian law does not prohibit civil and criminal proceedings from running simultaneously against the same person. A company or individual harmed by conduct that also constitutes a criminal offence may bring a civil claim independently of the criminal investigation, and both tracks can – and frequently do – advance in parallel.
Under Russian procedural law, a civil claim related to criminal conduct may be filed either within the criminal proceedings themselves, as a civil claim attached to the criminal case, or separately before a general-jurisdiction or commercial court. When filed within the criminal proceedings, the civil court's judgment is deferred: the civil court may suspend its proceedings until the criminal case is resolved, because a criminal conviction carries binding factual findings that the civil court cannot re-examine. Where the civil claim is filed separately and no suspension is ordered, both sets of proceedings move independently – on different timetables, before different courts, with different evidential standards.
For a foreign executive or manager in Russia, this creates a specific practical exposure. Evidence gathered during a criminal investigation – witness statements, seized documents, forensic accounting results – may be disclosed in or relied upon by civil proceedings. A civil judgment against the executive can be sought even before the criminal case concludes. Conversely, an acquittal in criminal proceedings does not automatically extinguish civil liability: the standards of proof differ, and a court may find civil liability established on facts that did not meet the criminal threshold.
The practical priority at this stage is to have a single counsel – or a coordinated team – overseeing both tracks simultaneously. Uncoordinated responses to civil and criminal process, particularly where statements made in one set of proceedings can be used in the other, represent the principal risk that experienced defence counsel work to contain from the outset.
For more on the procedural mechanics of the criminal track, see How Russian courts approach parallel civil and criminal proceedings. The firm's Business Crime Defence practice page sets out the full scope of the practice.
Make an enquiry — info@vetrovpartners.com |
— Vitaliy Vetrov Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners vetrovpartners.com/vetrov/
Vitaliy Vetrov founded the firm in 2009 and leads its disputes and arbitration practice. He has advised foreign companies and creditors in matters before Russian state courts, the ICAC at the Chamber of Commerce and Industry (MKAS), and the Russian Arbitration Centre (RAC). Languages: Russian, English.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry