Foreign executives in Russian subsidiaries can face personal criminal exposure. Six steps every foreign director should review. Make an enquiry.
Foreign executives who lead or have led a Russian subsidiary are not automatically shielded from personal criminal exposure when the company faces financial, regulatory, or operational failure. Where a Russian subsidiary's conduct gives rise to criminal liability — for tax evasion, fraud, misappropriation, or breach of regulatory obligations — Russian criminal procedure does not stop at the company's registered address. It may follow the individuals who controlled it. This checklist sets out six areas that every foreign director, general manager, or board-level representative of a Russian subsidiary should review as a matter of practice hygiene, and certainly before any formal contact from the Russian Investigative Committee, the Federal Tax Service, or prosecutors.
Understanding where the Russian subsidiary's potential civil or administrative liability ends and personal criminal exposure begins is the first analytical step. Russian law distinguishes between the subsidiary's obligations and the personal liability of its controlling persons, but that distinction can collapse quickly once criminal proceedings are opened or an insolvency application is filed. Under Russian insolvency legislation, the concept of liability of controlling persons — those who directed the company's decisions — has expanded significantly over recent years, and Russian courts have shown a consistent willingness to pierce the formal corporate structure where they find evidence of direction or instruction from above.
The practical consequence is this: a foreign parent company that gave instructions to a Russian subsidiary's management, or a foreign director who approved transactions later characterised as preferential or fraudulent, may find themselves named as a respondent in subsidiary liability proceedings. In parallel, if those transactions are characterised as criminally motivated, the Investigative Committee may open a criminal case in which the same individual is a suspect rather than merely a civil respondent. Mapping this interface before proceedings begin is the only position from which rational defence decisions can be made.
For foreign executives who wish to assess their current exposure, the firm's Business Crime Defence practice advises on the full liability interface analysis — civil, administrative, and criminal.
For an initial review of your exposure to subsidiary liability and criminal proceedings — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The principal question for any foreign executive is whether their acts or omissions, performed in the capacity of director, general manager, or authorised signatory of a Russian subsidiary, fall within the categories of conduct that Russian criminal law treats as individual offences. Russian criminal procedure operates on the principle of personal guilt: criminal liability attaches to individuals, not to legal entities as such.
Several categories of conduct recur in matters involving foreign executives at Russian subsidiaries. These include: formal approval of tax planning schemes that the Federal Tax Service later characterises as evasion; authorisation of payments to counterparties subsequently identified as fictitious; signing of customs declarations or contractual documents that prove to contain false information; and instructions to transfer assets in the period preceding insolvency. The common thread is that the foreign executive's formal or de facto authority over the subsidiary brings their decisions within the reach of Russian criminal law — regardless of where they were physically located when those decisions were made.
Note: Remote instruction or approval does not exempt a foreign executive from Russian criminal jurisdiction. Russian criminal procedure asserts jurisdiction over offences committed "in Russia" — which courts and investigators have interpreted to include decisions that produce their effect in Russia, even if the decision-maker was abroad at the time.
For a working comparison of how Russian criminal exposure for foreign directors has evolved, see Legislative amendments affecting subsidiary liability.
The document trail associated with a foreign executive's decisions at a Russian subsidiary is the primary material that investigators will seek and that defence counsel will need to work with. Where that documentation is complete, coherent, and reflects decisions made on proper commercial grounds, it significantly strengthens the defence position. Where it is absent, contradictory, or was generated retrospectively, it creates a vulnerability that is difficult to address once proceedings are underway.
The review should cover: board and management resolutions at the subsidiary level; correspondence and instructions passing between the foreign parent and subsidiary management; signatory authorisations and powers of attorney; records of decisions on tax positions, asset disposals, and inter-company transactions; and any regulatory filings made on behalf of the subsidiary.
Note: Under Russian criminal procedure, investigators have broad powers to seize and examine business records held in Russia, including electronic communications stored on company servers and devices. Once a criminal case is opened, the window to organise and clarify documentation is materially narrowed. A document review conducted before any approach by investigators is a different and more effective exercise than one conducted in the immediate aftermath of a search or summons. Relevant materials should be identified and, where appropriate, secured outside the jurisdiction.
If you are concerned that documentation at your Russian subsidiary may be incomplete or inconsistent — speak to our team: info@vetrovpartners.com |
For a foreign executive who is no longer based in Russia, the immediate question on learning of any regulatory or criminal inquiry is whether travel to Russia is safe, and whether travel through third countries carries extradition risk. For a foreign executive who remains in Russia, the question is whether the conditions for their departure are already constrained.
Russian criminal procedure permits investigators to apply to a court for a travel ban — a measure that prohibits the subject from leaving Russian territory — at an early stage of proceedings, including during the pre-investigation inquiry. A ban of this nature is not always communicated formally to the subject before it takes effect. A foreign executive who attempts to depart Russia after such a ban has been imposed but before notification reaches them may find their documents seized at the border or may be detained.
Note: The intersection of a Russian travel ban with the cross-border dimension of this situation is one of the most time-sensitive areas in this type of matter. Foreign executives who have any reason to believe they may be of interest to Russian investigators — because of their role at the subsidiary, because they have received informal enquiries, or because the subsidiary is under audit or insolvency review — should confirm their travel status with Russian criminal defence counsel before any planned departure from or return to Russia.
For an overview of the cross-border dimension of these matters, see Subsidiary liability and Russian proceedings: a practical briefing.
The decision whether to attend an investigator's interview, a court hearing, or an administrative proceeding voluntarily — as opposed to attending under a formal compulsion mechanism or not attending at all — is one of the most consequential choices in a Russian criminal matter involving a foreign national. It is not a decision to make based on general principles, and it is not a decision to make without Russian criminal defence counsel.
The considerations are specific to the procedural stage, the character of the proceedings, the executive's status within them (witness, suspect, accused, or other), and the available procedural safeguards. In Russian criminal procedure, an individual's status can change during the course of an interview. A foreign executive who attends as a witness may find that the procedural framing shifts during the session. The right to decline to give testimony that may be self-incriminating exists under Russian law and is enforceable — but asserting it correctly requires counsel who is present and who knows when and how to intervene.
A foreign executive who has received any form of summons, informal request, or notification in connection with a Russian subsidiary matter should not attend any session — including administrative hearings before the Federal Tax Service or meetings framed as "explanatory conversations" — without Russian defence counsel present.
Where a Russian subsidiary matter touches a foreign parent company, foreign co-investors, or has produced litigation or regulatory scrutiny in another jurisdiction, the information shared in one proceeding may reach another. This is the cross-border disclosure dimension of subsidiary liability, and it is particularly acute where the foreign executive is also subject to reporting obligations, director's duties, or regulatory obligations in their home jurisdiction.
The relevant areas to review include: whether disclosure made in the Russian criminal proceedings is protected by legal privilege in the home jurisdiction; whether information provided to Russian investigators could be used as a basis for regulatory or civil proceedings elsewhere; whether assets held outside Russia are at risk of freezing or attachment based on the Russian proceedings; and whether the foreign parent company has its own reporting or notification obligations arising from the Russian situation.
Coordinating between Russian defence counsel and foreign counsel in the home jurisdiction — or in the jurisdiction of the parent company — is a practical requirement in these matters. The coordination itself requires discipline: communications between the foreign executive and different legal teams in different jurisdictions may not carry equivalent privilege protections. For matters requiring input in Western European jurisdictions, the firm works alongside trusted foreign counsel through established referral relationships. Relevant cross-border insolvency dimensions are addressed by the firm's Restructuring & Insolvency team where those issues arise in parallel.
For complex matters requiring coordination between Russian criminal proceedings and foreign counsel — discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Q: What is the "subsidiary liability interface" and why does it matter to foreign executives?
A: The subsidiary liability interface is the point at which a Russian subsidiary's civil or insolvency-related liability connects to the personal exposure of the individuals who controlled it. It matters to foreign executives because Russian law provides mechanisms by which a parent company's representatives — including foreign nationals who directed the subsidiary's decisions from abroad — can be held personally liable for the company's obligations in insolvency proceedings. When the same facts that underpin subsidiary liability also disclose conduct characterised as criminal, the interface extends to criminal proceedings. A foreign executive can, as a result, be simultaneously a civil respondent in subsidiary liability proceedings and a suspect or accused in a criminal case arising from the same transactions.
Q: Can a foreign executive be prosecuted in Russia for decisions made outside Russian territory?
A: Yes, in circumstances where the decision produced its legal or financial effect within Russia. Russian criminal jurisdiction is not limited to physical presence in Russia at the time of the offence. Where a foreign executive approved a transaction, signed a document, or gave an instruction that resulted in criminal harm within Russia — for example, a tax shortfall or a fraudulent disposal of assets — investigators have taken the position that jurisdiction is established. This has been applied, in practice, to foreign directors who operated entirely from outside Russia during the relevant period. Extradition risk in a third country is a separate and concurrent question that depends on the bilateral treaties and domestic law of the country in which the executive is located.
Q: At what stage should a foreign executive engage Russian criminal defence counsel?
A: As early as possible — and in any event before any contact with the Russian Investigative Committee, the Federal Tax Service in a capacity beyond routine audit correspondence, or any court in connection with subsidiary liability proceedings. The value of defence counsel is not limited to representing the executive in proceedings that have already been opened. Early engagement allows for an assessment of exposure before the procedural status of the executive is formalised; it allows for a review of documentation while the documentary position can still be clarified; and it allows for travel-status advice before departure or return becomes a pressing decision. In the firm's experience, the matters where the defence position is most difficult to build are those where counsel was engaged after the executive had already attended interviews, provided written explanations, or made travel decisions without legal advice.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry