Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Business Crime Defence

Russian Supreme Court clarification on asset seizure defence in Russian criminal proceedings

Vitaliy Vetrov · July 2026 · 8 min read

Russia's Supreme Court has clarified asset seizure defences for executives in criminal proceedings. What foreign managers must know now. Make an enquiry.

Following a clarifying resolution issued by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, the rules governing asset seizure in Russian criminal proceedings have been materially refined. For foreign managers and expat executives working in Russia, the update changes both the analytical framework that courts apply when evaluating seizure applications and the practical tools available to those seeking to challenge or limit a freezing order. This briefing sets out what shifted, who is most directly affected, and what a foreign executive or in-house legal adviser should consider doing now.

§ I. What changed: the Supreme Court's clarification on asset seizure defence

Before this clarification, Russian courts applied a relatively broad reading of the grounds for seizing assets in criminal proceedings. Investigative authorities could request — and courts would typically grant — freezing orders over a wide category of property without detailed scrutiny of proportionality or the connection between the specific assets and the alleged offence. Defence challenges to such orders faced a high evidentiary threshold, and courts gave substantial deference to the position of the investigating authority.

The Supreme Court's Plenum has now issued guidance that tightens this approach in several respects. First, courts are directed to assess the proportionality of a proposed seizure against the value of the alleged damage — broad "precautionary" freezing of assets that far exceeds the claimed loss is now explicitly identified as grounds for challenge. Second, the resolution clarifies that assets belonging to individuals who are not themselves accused — including family members and co-signatories on business accounts — may only be seized where there is a reasoned link established between those assets and the alleged criminal proceeds or civil liability. Third, the guidance addresses the standard of reasoning required in a seizure order: a court issuing or confirming a freeze must now articulate its findings on proportionality and connection, not merely record the investigative authority's request.

In practice, these changes shift some of the analytical burden back onto the prosecution. Defence counsel can now invoke the proportionality findings directly and request a reduction in the scope of a freeze at the review stage, rather than waiting for the conclusion of criminal proceedings.

"The Plenum's clarification is significant because it gives defence counsel a procedural foothold — proportionality is now a stated judicial obligation, not just an argument available in theory." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

If you are a foreign executive or a legal adviser managing an executive's exposure in Russian criminal proceedings — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Which foreign executives and expat managers are most affected?

The clarification is particularly relevant for three categories of foreign nationals working in Russia.

The first is foreign executives holding signatory authority over Russian corporate accounts. Where criminal proceedings are opened against a company — or against a Russian co-director — the assets of account signatories have historically been vulnerable to precautionary seizure even before any personal accusation is made. The new proportionality requirement makes challenges to this type of collateral seizure more viable.

The second category is expat executives in Russian companies where the underlying dispute has a tax, financial, or commercial dimension. In a number of matters reviewed by the firm, asset seizure orders in such cases have extended to personal property — vehicles, domestic bank accounts, and real estate — on the basis that the individual was a beneficiary of the alleged scheme. Under the clarified standard, the investigative authority must now demonstrate the asset connection with greater specificity.

The third category is foreign nationals who are co-shareholders or directors of joint ventures with Russian partners. Where a Russian co-director faces criminal exposure, the assets of the entire legal entity may be subject to a broad freeze. The new guidance on the scope of seizure applicable to third parties is directly relevant here.

One further consideration applies to all three categories: the relationship between asset seizure and exit restrictions. In Russian criminal proceedings, asset freezing orders and exit bans are legally distinct measures, but they are often applied together. The clarification does not directly amend the exit ban framework; however, a successful challenge to the scope of a seizure order can, in practice, support arguments for proportionality review of other restrictive measures. Foreign executives concerned about exit ban Russia exposure should note this indirect effect.

For those whose assets are subject to a freeze, the Business Crime Defence practice at Vetrov & Partners operates across both the defence of the underlying accusation and the procedural challenges to ancillary measures. The firm's experience in asset seizure defence in Russian criminal proceedings is described in further detail in the practice briefing on asset seizure defence and in the deep-dive analysis of asset seizure defence in Russian criminal proceedings.

If your assets or those of an executive you advise are subject to seizure in Russian criminal proceedings — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What foreign executives and their advisers should consider now

The clarification creates a concrete procedural opportunity that was not as clearly available before. The following steps are worth considering for any foreign executive currently subject to, or at risk of, asset seizure in Russian criminal proceedings.

The first step is to obtain a current analysis of any existing seizure order against the proportionality standard now articulated by the Supreme Court. Many freezing orders issued under the previous, broader practice will not satisfy the new requirement on their face. A review should assess whether the scope of the freeze is proportionate to the alleged loss and whether the connection between the frozen assets and the alleged offence has been adequately reasoned in the order itself.

The second step applies where the executive is not yet accused but holds assets that may be vulnerable as a third party. The clarification's guidance on the third-party asset connection test should be reviewed against the specific facts — the nature of the accounts, the basis of the alleged criminal proceeds, and the individual's formal role in the entity under investigation.

The third step is to ensure that defence counsel in Russia is actively monitoring the procedural timeline. The review mechanism for seizure orders operates within defined windows; missing an application deadline does not extinguish the right permanently, but it does narrow the available forums and may delay relief.

For foreign executives managing Russian criminal exposure, the most important practical consequence of the Plenum's resolution is that proportionality is now a judicially acknowledged standard — not merely a theoretical argument. That changes the character of the dialogue with the court and, in well-prepared matters, can materially reduce the scope of an asset freeze well before any final determination on the underlying charge.

The Matters page records a selection of the firm's experience in this area, including matters where asset seizure challenges were pursued successfully at the review stage.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically did the Russian Supreme Court clarify regarding asset seizure in criminal proceedings?

A: The Supreme Court's Plenum issued guidance establishing that courts must now apply a proportionality assessment when authorising or reviewing asset seizure in criminal proceedings. The order must be proportionate to the value of the alleged damage, and assets belonging to third parties — including family members and business associates of the accused — may only be frozen where a specific connection to the alleged criminal proceeds or civil liability is demonstrated. Courts issuing or confirming a freeze are required to articulate their reasoning on both proportionality and connection in the order itself. These requirements were either absent or inconsistently applied under the previous practice, and the clarification now gives defence counsel a formal basis to invoke them.

Q: Which foreign executives in Russia are most directly affected by this clarification?

A: The clarification most directly affects three groups: foreign nationals holding signatory authority over corporate accounts where the entity or a co-director is under criminal investigation; expat executives whose personal assets have been frozen on the basis that they benefited from an alleged commercial or financial offence; and foreign shareholders or directors of joint ventures where a Russian partner faces criminal exposure and a broad entity-level freeze has been applied. In all three situations, the proportionality standard and the third-party connection test introduced by the Plenum create a new basis for challenging or reducing the scope of the freeze.

Q: What should a foreign executive or their adviser do following this clarification?

A: Any existing seizure order should be reviewed against the proportionality standard now confirmed by the Supreme Court. Where the freeze substantially exceeds the claimed loss, or where the connection between the frozen assets and the alleged offence is not adequately reasoned, an application to reduce or lift the seizure is worth pursuing. Executive advisers should also note the indirect relevance to exit ban Russia situations — a successful proportionality challenge can support related arguments concerning other restrictive measures. Early engagement with experienced Russian criminal defence counsel is advisable, both to identify the applicable procedural window and to prepare the evidential basis for any challenge.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry