Cross-border parallel civil and criminal proceedings in Russia involving a foreign executive. Tax assessment substantially reduced at pre-litigation stage. Make an enquiry.
CRIMINAL DEFENCE — RUSSIA / GERMANY — Coordinated cross-border parallel civil and criminal proceedings in Russia involving a foreign executive: tax assessment substantially reduced at pre-litigation stage
Client. A German national serving as general director of a Russian operating subsidiary within a European manufacturing group, with personal tax and corporate reporting obligations arising in both Russia and Germany.
Background. Russian tax authorities initiated a field audit of the subsidiary that, in parallel, gave rise to a criminal referral against the general director personally under provisions of Russian law addressing large-scale tax evasion. The executive faced simultaneous civil tax proceedings — in which the company was the respondent — and a preliminary criminal inquiry in which he was identified as a suspect. The cross-border dimension complicated the matter: German employment and tax counsel had been instructed separately, and there was no coordinated legal response across the two jurisdictions. The risk of inconsistent positions being taken in Russian civil proceedings and in the criminal file was material.
Our role. Counsel was instructed to coordinate the Russian legal response across both procedural tracks. In the civil proceedings, the firm engaged directly with the Federal Tax Service at the pre-litigation stage, challenging the methodological basis of the assessment and the characterisation of the transactions under review. In the criminal track, counsel provided procedural defence support, assisted in preparing explanations for the investigative authority, and advised on the timing and substance of documentary submissions so as to avoid prejudicing either proceeding. The firm also liaised with German counsel to align the evidentiary record and ensure consistency in the positions taken across jurisdictions.
Outcome. tax assessment substantially reduced at pre-litigation stage. The criminal inquiry did not progress to a formal charge, and the preliminary investigation was discontinued following the resolution of the civil tax dispute. No trial proceedings were initiated against the executive.
Discuss a similar matter — info@vetrovpartners.com
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry