Foreign managers facing a pre-investigation check in Russia need a structured internal investigation approach. Vetrov & Partners advises. Make an enquiry.
In practice, the moment a foreign manager in Russia first learns that a pre-investigation check is under way is rarely the moment they expected. For a decade of advising foreign executives and their companies, one consistent observation recurs: internal investigation management at this stage is neither intuitive nor forgiving. The pre-investigation check — the formal preliminary stage of Russian criminal procedure preceding a decision to open a criminal case — creates a tight and consequential window. How a company and its management conduct themselves internally during this period shapes nearly every subsequent development, from the decision whether to open proceedings to the characterisation of the company's posture in any eventual trial.
Before working through the steps below, gather and review the following materials. The absence of any one of them during the check commonly creates avoidable complications.
If a pre-investigation check has been initiated — or if you have reason to believe one may be imminent — speak to our team before taking any further steps internally: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The first practical step is to identify, with precision, what authority is conducting the check and under what legal basis. In Russia, pre-investigation checks may be initiated by the Investigative Committee, the Ministry of Internal Affairs (police), or — less commonly — the Prosecutor's Office acting in co-ordination with these bodies. Each authority has distinct procedural powers during this stage, and the scope of permissible evidence-gathering differs accordingly.
Establish in writing — through formal requests to the relevant authority — the statutory grounds cited, the subject matter of the check, and the categories of information already requested from any counterparty or employee. This is not always straightforward, and in practice authorities are not obliged to disclose the full scope of their interest at this stage. Nevertheless, a documented attempt to identify the legal basis is itself a signal of co-operative posture that Russian counsel can deploy constructively in subsequent procedural exchanges.
For a foreign manager, the critical question at this step is personal scope: does the check appear to focus on corporate acts, or on individual decisions attributed to a named executive? The answer determines the appropriate structure of the internal investigation and the degree to which individual and corporate legal interests may diverge.
Internal link: The firm's Business Crime Defence practice has advised in this context across a range of industry sectors and company structures.
Document preservation during a pre-investigation check is among the highest-priority tasks, and one of the most frequently mishandled. The instinct — understandable but dangerous — is to organise documents in a way that presents the company's position most favourably before investigators see them. Under Russian criminal procedure, any evidence of document alteration or selective destruction, even at the pre-investigation stage, can constitute an independent basis for criminal exposure.
The correct approach is conservative: preserve everything in its current state, then map it. Appoint a single custodian — typically an in-house lawyer or a senior compliance officer, not a line manager with personal exposure — with responsibility for maintaining a complete document register. This register should record the location, format, author, and date of every document identified as potentially within scope. Electronic records require particular attention: email archives, messenger applications used for business communication, and cloud-based document systems should all be captured before any routine deletion cycles run.
Where Russian data localisation requirements under Federal Law No. 152-FZ interact with document preservation obligations — a situation that arises when the company's data infrastructure has a cross-border dimension — the preservation protocol must be reviewed by counsel before implementation.
Internal investigation management under Russian law at the pre-investigation check stage works best when the investigation team is structured to separate functions that the company has an interest in conflating. Three distinct functions require separate personnel: factual investigation (gathering and assessing what happened), legal analysis (assessing exposure and options), and communication management (managing what the company says, to whom, and when).
Assigning all three functions to a single in-house lawyer or compliance officer creates both practical and legal problems. Practically, one person cannot simultaneously conduct neutral fact-gathering and assess personal exposure risk for colleagues. Legally, the scope of legal professional privilege under Russian law — which is narrower and more procedurally fragile than its English law equivalent — depends in part on how the investigation function is structured and by whom it is led.
External counsel should be engaged at the outset for the legal analysis and communication management functions. The firm regularly acts as external counsel in this configuration, working alongside in-house teams whose role is appropriately limited to factual investigation under counsel's supervision.
Internal link: For an analysis of how Russian courts have recently characterised internal investigation outputs in subsequent criminal proceedings, see Court practice shift on internal investigations.
Employees occupy a difficult position during a pre-investigation check. They may be approached directly by investigators — this is permitted at the check stage, and investigators are not required to route requests through the company. They may also be interviewed internally as part of the company's own investigation. Managing both tracks simultaneously, without inadvertently creating contradictory accounts or placing employees in a position where their internal statements conflict with what they subsequently tell investigators, requires careful sequencing.
The practical approach is to conduct internal employee interviews only after counsel has assessed the risk profile of each individual — distinguishing between employees whose interests are broadly aligned with the company's and those who face personal exposure. For the latter group, internal interviews should generally not proceed without the employee first having access to independent legal advice. This is not merely a matter of fairness: an employee who later claims coercion in an internal interview can undermine the value of the entire internal investigation as a record.
For foreign managers directly, the most important guidance is this: do not give informal accounts — verbal briefings, emails summarising "what actually happened" — to colleagues, supervisors, or board members without counsel's involvement. These communications are not protected and are recoverable by investigators.
Foreign managers who need to understand their individual exposure at the pre-investigation check stage can discuss the matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The final step is the one most frequently deferred: engaging formally with the pre-investigation check itself. Many companies and their managers adopt a posture of minimal engagement at this stage on the assumption that it is too early to participate meaningfully. In the prevailing approach of Russian investigative authorities, however, a company's conduct during the check — including whether it voluntarily provided information, co-operated with evidence-gathering, or sought to understand its obligations — is factored into subsequent procedural decisions.
Formal engagement means, at minimum: responding in writing to all formal requests from investigators within the prescribed timeframe, ensuring that all responses are prepared or reviewed by external counsel, and filing any procedural objections where investigators have exceeded the scope of their authority. It also means preserving a complete record of all communications with investigators — both incoming requests and outgoing responses — as a contemporaneous log.
Where the pre-investigation check concerns the conduct of a foreign manager specifically, counsel may advise filing a voluntary account of relevant facts and decisions — a procedurally structured submission that sets out the company's or individual's version of events before investigators have completed their own inquiry. This is a tactical decision that requires careful analysis of the available evidence and the likely trajectory of the check. It is not appropriate in every case, but where the underlying facts support it, early formal engagement regularly reduces the risk that the check results in a criminal case being opened.
Internal link: For a detailed legal analysis of the framework governing corporate internal investigations in Russia, see The law and practice of internal investigations in Russia. The firm's full matters record is at Matters.
Q: How long does the pre-investigation check typically last under Russian criminal procedure?
A: The standard period for a pre-investigation check is 3 days from receipt of the initial report or information. This period may be extended to 10 days, and in certain categories of matter — particularly those involving economic crimes or requests for documentary evidence — a further extension to 30 days is available. In practice, authorities commonly use successive extensions, which means the check stage can run for several weeks before a formal decision on whether to open a criminal case is made. For a foreign manager, the practical implication is that this stage is longer and more procedurally significant than it may initially appear. Engaging counsel from the outset, rather than waiting for the check to conclude, is materially more effective.
Q: What documents should a company preserve once it becomes aware a pre-investigation check is under way?
A: Preservation should be comprehensive rather than selective. At a minimum: all contracts, invoices, payment orders, and correspondence relating to the subject matter under review; all internal communications — including email, messenger, and memoranda — touching on the relevant decisions or transactions; all board and management meeting minutes from the relevant period; and all prior communications with state regulatory bodies on the same subject. Electronic records are particularly important: routine deletion cycles should be suspended immediately. A document custodian should be appointed, and a register maintained from the point preservation begins. The scope of preservation should be reviewed with external counsel, since over-preservation is rarely harmful while under-preservation can be.
Q: What happens if an employee refuses to co-operate with the company's own internal investigation?
A: An employee who declines to participate in an internal company investigation during a pre-investigation check cannot generally be compelled under Russian labour law to give a statement. Disciplinary measures for non-co-operation are available in some circumstances, but using them during an active pre-investigation check risks being characterised as pressure — which can damage both the company's procedural posture and the employee's relationship with investigators if they are subsequently interviewed by the authorities. The more effective approach is to assess, with counsel, whether the employee's non-co-operation signals their own exposure, and to structure the internal investigation so that factual conclusions can be reached through documentary evidence rather than relying on employee accounts as the primary record.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry