Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Russian arbitrazh court clarifies major transaction procedure under Russian corporate law: key takeaways

Stanislav Lastovsky · January 2026 · 7 min read

Russian court ruling clarifies major transaction approval for foreign-owned subsidiaries. Key takeaways for in-house counsel. Make an enquiry.

In advising foreign multinationals on Russian subsidiary governance, one misconception surfaces more reliably than almost any other: the belief that group-level approval frameworks translate cleanly into the procedural requirements of Russian corporate law. A recent ruling by a Russian arbitrazh court on the major transaction procedure serves as a pointed reminder that they do not — and that the consequences of procedural non-compliance can reach well beyond administrative inconvenience.

Background

The major transaction procedure is a structural feature of Russian corporate law that applies to both joint-stock companies and limited liability companies incorporated in Russia. Under Russian corporate legislation, a transaction is classified as "major" if its value exceeds a defined percentage of the company's balance-sheet assets — a threshold calculated by reference to the most recent annual accounts. Transactions meeting this threshold require approval by a qualified majority of shareholders or, in some cases, the board of directors, before they can be validly concluded.

The case that prompted this comment arose from a commercial dispute in which one party sought to challenge the validity of a significant contract entered into by a Russian entity. The core contention was that the transaction fell within the major transaction category under Russian corporate law and had not been properly approved before execution. The respondent — an operating subsidiary with foreign participation in its ownership structure — maintained that the transaction had been authorised through internal group procedures and that Russian corporate law requirements had been satisfied in substance, if not entirely in form.

The matter proceeded through the arbitrazh court of first instance and was subsequently reviewed on appeal. The legal questions at issue — threshold calculation methodology, the scope of approval authority, and the consequences of defective approval — are precisely those that in-house counsel at multinationals with Russian subsidiaries encounter in the course of routine M&A, financing, and asset-disposal activity.

The decision

The court's analysis addressed three questions that have generated inconsistent treatment in Russian arbitrazh practice.

First, on threshold calculation: the court confirmed that the relevant balance-sheet figure is that recorded in the company's last approved annual accounts, not any interim management accounts prepared by or for the parent group. This is a point that in practice creates friction for foreign-owned subsidiaries, where group reporting cycles and the Russian statutory accounts cycle frequently diverge. The ruling reinforces that reliance on consolidated or unaudited interim figures — even where those figures form part of a group's standard governance process — does not satisfy the Russian corporate law requirement.

Second, on the scope of approval authority: the court drew a clear distinction between approval granted by the board of directors and approval granted by the general meeting of shareholders. Under Russian corporate legislation, the authority to approve major transactions is distributed between these two bodies according to transaction-value thresholds. The court declined to accept that a resolution passed by one body could cure the absence of approval by the body that the law designates as competent for the transaction in question. This has direct relevance for foreign parent companies that issue group-level board resolutions or investment committee approvals in the expectation that those instruments constitute valid authorisation under Russian law.

Third, on consequences: the court applied the established Russian corporate law position that a major transaction concluded without the requisite approval is voidable — meaning it can be challenged by the company, a shareholder, or in some circumstances by the other contracting party — but is not automatically void. The burden of bringing a challenge, the applicable limitation period, and the standing of potential challengers were each addressed, with the court offering useful clarification on which parties can bring an invalidity claim and within what timeframe under Russian civil procedure rules.

"The ruling reinforces a point that arises frequently in practice: Russian subsidiary governance cannot be managed by reference to group policy alone — the Russian corporate law procedure for major transactions operates on its own terms and on its own timetable." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel managing Russian subsidiary transactions, early-stage review of approval requirements can prevent post-completion challenge. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For in-house counsel at multinationals with Russian operating entities, this ruling sharpens three practical governance questions that should be addressed as standing items in any transaction approval workflow.

The first concerns balance-sheet monitoring. If a Russian subsidiary is party to contracts, financing arrangements, or asset disposals of material value, counsel should confirm — before transaction sign — that the relevant balance-sheet figure from the last approved Russian statutory accounts has been checked against the applicable threshold. This is not a formality that can be addressed retroactively with any confidence; a missed approval creates a voidable transaction that may be challenged for the duration of the applicable limitation period. Under Russian corporate legislation, that period typically runs from the date on which the claimant knew, or ought to have known, of the grounds for challenge — a test that courts have generally applied with reference to the date of board or shareholder meetings at which the matter could have been raised.

The second concerns governance documentation. Group resolutions, investment committee approvals, and group treasury authorisation letters do not substitute for the specific corporate approval required under Russian law. Where a Russian subsidiary is the contracting entity, the approval instrument must originate from the competent Russian corporate body — whether the board or the general meeting — and must be documented in the form prescribed by Russian corporate legislation. Foreign parent companies that centralise governance decisions without mirroring them at subsidiary level in the required form are exposed to exactly the risk this ruling describes.

The third concerns counterparty due diligence. The ruling is a timely reminder that foreign creditors, joint venture partners, and acquirers transacting with Russian entities should verify, as part of standard pre-signing diligence, whether any element of the proposed transaction triggers the major transaction procedure — and whether the relevant approval has been obtained. This applies not only to the principal transaction documents but also to security arrangements, guarantees, and ancillary agreements where the aggregate value may bring the overall arrangement above the threshold.

For foreign companies with Russian subsidiaries that have not recently reviewed their internal transaction approval protocols against the current requirements of Russian corporate law, this ruling provides a concrete prompt to do so. The firm's commentary on the legislative framework for major transactions and interested party transactions is set out in Major transaction procedure under Russian corporate law and in Legislative amendments affecting major transactions. A record of related governance matters handled by the firm is available in the Matters Hub.

Foreign subsidiaries that have completed significant transactions in the past three years without formal Russian corporate approval should treat this ruling as a prompt for a targeted review of their transaction record. The limitation exposure may already be running.

If your Russian subsidiary has concluded significant contracts, financing arrangements, or asset disposals without formal major transaction approval, consider a targeted review before the limitation clock becomes a live issue. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The ruling does not introduce new law; it clarifies how existing Russian corporate law requirements apply in practice. Specifically, it confirms that major transaction thresholds must be calculated using the last approved Russian statutory accounts — not consolidated or interim group accounts — and that approval must come from the corporate body designated by law for the relevant transaction value. It also clarifies the standing and timeframe for invalidity challenges, which is relevant for any party — including a counterparty to a disputed contract — assessing its exposure. In-house counsel whose internal approval workflows were designed around group governance rather than Russian statutory requirements should treat this ruling as a prompt to review those workflows before the next significant transaction.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Three steps are advisable. First, confirm that your Russian subsidiary's major transaction approval protocol correctly identifies the applicable threshold by reference to Russian statutory accounts — not group management accounts. Second, verify that transaction approvals are passed by the competent corporate body under Russian law and documented in the required form; group-level resolutions do not substitute for Russian corporate approvals. Third, if the subsidiary has concluded significant contracts, financing arrangements, or disposals in the past two to three years without formal Russian corporate approval, commission a targeted transaction review to assess the limitation exposure. Vetrov & Partners advises on corporate governance for foreign-owned Russian entities and can assist with both prospective protocol design and retrospective review of completed transactions.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry