Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Landmark Decision on Branch vs Subsidiary: Governance and Liability in Russia

Stanislav Lastovsky · July 2026 · 8 min read

A Russian court ruling clarifies branch and subsidiary governance and liability — what in-house counsel with Russian entities must review. Make an enquiry.

Foreign companies operating in Russia through a branch have long assumed that governance arrangements could be managed informally — that the absence of a separate legal personality simplified administration without meaningfully increasing exposure. A recent Russian court ruling challenges that assumption directly. The decision, handed down at the cassation level, addresses the allocation of governance responsibility and civil liability between a foreign parent and its Russian branch, and its implications for in-house counsel reviewing entity structures in Russia are material. For multinationals that have not revisited their branch governance documents since the structure was established, the ruling identifies a risk that is now harder to dismiss.

Background

The proceedings arose from a contractual dispute in which a counterparty sought to hold the foreign parent directly liable for obligations incurred by its Russian branch. The branch had entered into commercial arrangements in Russia under the authority of a duly appointed director, acting within a power of attorney granted by the parent. The counterparty's position was that the branch, lacking separate legal personality under Russian civil law, was in substance the parent — and that any liability the branch incurred was therefore undifferentiated from the parent's own liability.

That framing is not novel. Russian civil law has always provided that a branch is not a separate legal entity: it acts in the name of the organisation that established it, and the founding organisation bears full civil liability for the branch's obligations. What the court was called upon to clarify was narrower but consequential: whether the governance structure of the branch — specifically, the scope of authority documented in the constitutive instruments and the power of attorney — could operate as a limitation on the parent's liability in the circumstances of the particular claim, or whether the parent remained fully exposed regardless of how carefully that authority had been circumscribed.

A subsidiary, by contrast, is a separate legal entity incorporated under Russian law, with its own charter, registered capital, management bodies, and liability perimeter. The parent's exposure to a subsidiary's obligations is generally limited to the value of its participation interest, subject to the established grounds for piercing the corporate veil under Russian legislation. The structural difference is not new; what the ruling contributes is a sharper judicial articulation of how that difference operates when the branch's governance documents are incomplete, internally inconsistent, or silent on material questions.

The decision

The cassation court upheld the lower courts' finding that the parent was liable for the full extent of the branch's obligations. The reasoning centred on two points. First, the power of attorney under which the branch director had acted was drafted in general terms: it conferred authority to conduct commercial activity without specifying limitations by transaction type, value, or counterparty category. The court held that, in the absence of express restrictions that were both internally documented and communicated to the counterparty, the parent could not invoke the branch director's alleged excess of authority as a defence against a third party acting in good faith.

Second, the court examined the branch's internal governance documents — the regulation on the branch (положение о филиале) — and found that it did not reflect the operational scope that the parent retrospectively claimed to have intended. The regulation was a standard-form document that had not been updated since the branch was registered. It did not correspond to the commercial activities actually conducted through the branch, and it contained no provisions governing transaction limits, approval requirements, or escalation to the parent's own governance bodies.

The combined effect was that the parent's attempt to characterise the branch director's actions as ultra vires — and thereby limit its own exposure — failed at both the documentary and the reliance tests. The court's reasoning was explicit: a founding organisation that installs a branch, appoints a director, and issues a broad power of attorney assumes the corresponding liability for that director's acts in full, in the absence of documented restrictions that are effective against third parties.

"This ruling is a direct signal to any foreign parent operating through a Russian branch: governance documents that were adequate at registration may no longer be adequate now. The court's analysis of the power of attorney and the branch regulation as a unified governance instrument is a standard that many existing structures do not meet." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel considering whether the subsidiary model would have produced a different outcome: the answer, on the facts described, is likely yes — though the degree of difference depends on whether the conditions for piercing subsidiary liability under Russian legislation would have been met. That analysis is fact-specific, and the ruling does not resolve it; but it does clarify why the entity-form decision carries real governance consequence, not merely a structural one.

If your company operates in Russia through a branch and has not reviewed its governance documentation recently, this ruling gives specific reason to do so. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For in-house counsel at multinationals with Russian branches, the ruling identifies three areas that warrant prompt internal review.

The first is the power of attorney. If the authority conferred on the branch director is expressed in general terms — and most standard-form powers of attorney are — the parent has limited ability to argue, after the fact, that a particular transaction fell outside the director's mandate. The court's reasoning suggests that restrictions must be express, documented, and communicated in a form that affects third-party reliance. Updating the power of attorney to reflect transaction-type limits, value thresholds, and approval requirements is the minimum corrective step.

The second is the branch regulation. A regulation that was filed at registration and has not been revisited is an instrument that may no longer reflect the branch's actual operational scope. Under the court's reasoning, the regulation forms part of the evidential record when liability questions arise. A regulation that is inconsistent with actual practice, or that omits material governance provisions, is a liability document rather than a protection document.

The third concerns the entity-form question itself. Foreign companies that selected the branch structure for administrative simplicity — lower registration costs, no minimum share capital, no separate corporate formalities — may be carrying an undisclosed liability profile. A subsidiary established under Russian corporate legislation creates a distinct legal personality with a defined liability perimeter. For companies whose Russian operations have grown beyond the original scope, or whose branch is now conducting material commercial activity, the case for reconsidering the structure has strengthened.

Under Russian civil law, the three-year general limitation period means that the exposure window for past branch transactions is longer than many in-house teams assume. Companies that have conducted significant commercial activity through a branch — particularly under broadly drawn powers of attorney — should not wait for a counterparty action to discover the outer perimeter of parent liability.

The firm has recently advised a Western European manufacturing group on a governance review of its Russian branch structure following a regulatory inquiry, resulting in a revised branch regulation, updated powers of attorney, and a documented internal approval framework. No litigation arose.

To discuss a review of your Russian branch or subsidiary governance arrangements, make an enquiry in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign companies with Russian branches?

A: The ruling sharpens the standard against which a foreign parent's liability for branch obligations will be assessed. Russian civil law has always held that a branch has no separate legal personality and that the founding organisation bears full civil liability for branch obligations. What the court has now articulated is that governance documents — specifically the power of attorney and the branch regulation — must actively reflect the limitations on authority that the parent wishes to invoke against third-party claims. A general-form power of attorney, and a branch regulation that has not been updated to reflect actual operational scope, will not support an ultra vires defence. The practical consequence is that existing governance documents need to be reviewed against this evidential standard, not assumed to be adequate because they were accepted at registration.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: The immediate priority is a documentation audit covering the branch regulation and all powers of attorney currently in force. The audit should assess whether the authority conferred on the branch director is expressed with sufficient specificity to support a restriction argument in litigation; whether the branch regulation accurately reflects the branch's current operational scope; and whether the internal approval framework — transaction limits, escalation requirements, parent-body consent thresholds — is documented in a form that is effective against third parties. Where the existing structure was established for a branch whose commercial activity has since expanded, the entity-form question should also be revisited: a conversion to or establishment of a Russian subsidiary may be warranted. Counsel experienced in Russian corporate governance can assist with both the documentation review and the structural analysis.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry