Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Case comment: minority shareholder protection in Russian JSCs and LLCs under Article 65.2 of the Civil Code

Stanislav Lastovsky · May 2026 · 7 min read

Foreign shareholders in Russian companies face governance risks under Article 65.2. What a recent ruling means for minority protection. Make an enquiry.

In advising foreign shareholders in Russian joint-stock companies and limited liability companies, a pattern emerges that the statute books do not immediately reveal: minority protection in Russia is not principally a matter of special rules enacted for minority shareholders, but of general civil law obligations applied to corporate relationships. A recent decision by a Russian commercial court sharpened this understanding considerably, confirming that Article 65.2 of the Civil Code – which codifies the duty of good faith owed by all participants in a corporate entity – can be invoked directly by a minority shareholder to compel disclosure, challenge related-party transactions, and resist majority-driven governance changes. For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary or holding a minority stake in a Russian entity, the ruling repays careful attention.

Background

Russian corporate law distributes protection for minority shareholders across several instruments. Special legislation governing joint-stock companies and limited liability companies sets out minimum thresholds for convening extraordinary general meetings, blocking certain categories of major transaction, and accessing company documents. These protections are supplemented by the general framework of the Civil Code, which since a substantial reform in 2014 has required all participants in a corporate entity – regardless of the size of their stake – to act in good faith, not to cause harm to the company through the exercise of their rights, and to cooperate in achieving the company's objectives. It is this general framework, set out in Article 65.2 of the Civil Code, that the case under discussion placed at the centre of the analysis.

The proceedings arose from a dispute in which a minority participant in a limited liability company challenged a series of management decisions that, taken individually, fell below the thresholds triggering mandatory shareholder approval, but which, viewed together, substantially altered the company's asset base and financial position. The minority participant held a stake below the level at which the special legislation conferred the right to block major transactions, and the majority participants had structured the transactions accordingly. The question before the court was whether Article 65.2 of the Civil Code provided an independent basis for the minority participant to seek judicial protection – and, if so, what remedies were available.

The decision: what did the court hold?

The court held that Article 65.2 of the Civil Code is not a residual or supplementary provision that operates only in the gaps left by special corporate legislation. It is a self-standing obligation binding on all participants, enforceable directly, and capable of grounding a substantive claim where majority conduct – even if formally compliant with the thresholds and procedures set out in the JSC or LLC legislation – amounts to an exercise of rights contrary to the principles of good faith and reasonableness. The court noted that the structuring of transactions to avoid approval thresholds did not, in itself, cure the conduct; the question was whether the overall pattern of decisions was consistent with the duty that all participants owe to the company and to each other.

On disclosure, the court held that a minority participant invoking Article 65.2 of the Civil Code is entitled to the information necessary to assess whether the obligation of good faith has been observed – and that the company's refusal to provide that information in timely form was itself a factor in the court's assessment of the majority's conduct. This has practical significance: it suggests that information access claims in Russian courts are increasingly treated not merely as procedural entitlements derived from the company charter or the relevant statutory minimum, but as an aspect of the substantive good-faith obligation.

In terms of remedy, the court declined to unwind the impugned transactions – partly on proportionality grounds and partly because third-party interests had attached – but it awarded damages to the minority participant measured by reference to the diminution in the value of the participant's stake attributable to the majority's conduct. This remedial approach, while not novel in Russian corporate litigation, was notable here because the damages were assessed without requiring the minority participant to prove that any single transaction crossed a statutory threshold.

"

"The willingness of Russian commercial courts to read Article 65.2 of the Civil Code as a substantive cause of action – not merely a backdrop principle – changes the calculus for foreign minority shareholders who believed their position was structurally unprotected."— Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead – Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

"

If your company holds a minority stake in a Russian JSC or LLC and you have concerns about governance or related-party transactions, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign shareholders in Russian companies?

For in-house counsel and corporate advisers managing foreign shareholdings in Russian entities, this ruling clarifies the strategic landscape in several respects.

First, the good-faith obligation under Article 65.2 of the Civil Code is available as a cause of action regardless of stake size. Foreign minority shareholders who fall below the thresholds in the JSC or LLC legislation – and who may therefore have assumed they have limited grounds to challenge majority decisions – should reconsider that assumption. The provision applies to participants in both joint-stock companies and limited liability companies, and the threshold for invoking it is the conduct of the majority, not the size of the claimant's stake.

Second, the information access element of the ruling has direct practical value. Foreign shareholders frequently encounter resistance when requesting management accounts, related-party disclosure, or board minutes from Russian operating entities. The court's framing – that denial of information is itself relevant to the good-faith analysis – provides a basis for escalating such requests through judicial channels under Russian Corporate Governance law, rather than treating the matter as a purely contractual or charter-based dispute.

Third, and more broadly, this case illustrates a trend that has been developing in Russian commercial court practice: an increasing willingness to look through formal compliance with statutory thresholds and assess the substance of majority conduct against the Civil Code's general principles. Foreign shareholders who have structured their participation agreements on the assumption that Russian courts apply only the letter of the special corporate legislation should review those agreements in light of this developing interpretive approach. The firm's guide to minority shareholder protection in Russian companies – Minority Shareholder Protection in Russian JSCs and LLCs – sets out the full range of available instruments and is a useful companion to this case comment.

Foreign companies holding minority positions in Russian entities should also note that the Restructuring & Insolvency dimension is relevant: where a Russian company enters financial difficulty, the conduct of the majority in the period preceding insolvency may be scrutinised under both the special insolvency legislation and Article 65.2 of the Civil Code simultaneously. In-house counsel who have not reviewed their Russian subsidiary's governance documents recently carry a structural risk that is easily addressable before proceedings are filed. For a broader view of recent regulatory developments in this area, see also the Ministry of Finance guidance on minority shareholder rights.

For in-house counsel managing Russian corporate holdings where governance concerns have arisen, an initial 30-minute meeting – complimentary – is available to review the position: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign minority shareholders in Russian JSCs and LLCs?

A: The ruling confirms that Article 65.2 of the Civil Code – which imposes a duty of good faith on all participants in a Russian corporate entity – can be invoked as an independent cause of action by a minority participant, regardless of whether the majority's conduct crossed any threshold set by the JSC or LLC legislation. For foreign minority shareholders, this means that formally compliant majority decisions may still be challenged in Russian courts if the overall pattern of conduct is inconsistent with the good-faith obligation. The practical effect is to expand the available remedies beyond those derived from the company charter and the special corporate legislation.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign shareholders holding minority positions in Russian entities should review their participation agreements and corporate documentation to assess whether the information access provisions and related-party transaction controls are adequate in light of the court's framing of Article 65.2 of the Civil Code. Where information requests have been refused or governance arrangements have been altered without minority approval, there may be grounds for a claim even absent a breach of a specific statutory threshold. Early legal review – before the position crystallises into litigation – is the most cost-effective approach. Contact info@vetrovpartners.com to discuss a specific position.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry