Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Russian judicial practice on related-party transaction approval under Russian corporate law at the formation stage — commentary

Stanislav Lastovsky · May 2026 · 6 min read

Russian courts have clarified when related-party approval is required at the formation stage. What in-house counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.

For Russian subsidiaries of foreign groups, the question of whether a particular transaction requires approval as a related-party dealing is rarely straightforward. The challenge becomes acutely practical at the moment of incorporation. A body of Russian arbitrazh court practice has developed around whether approval obligations attach to transactions concluded during or immediately following the formation of a limited liability company or joint-stock company, before a full governance structure is operational. In a series of decisions examined here, the courts have refined the conditions under which formation-stage transactions engage the interested-party rules — with consequences that in-house counsel managing newly established Russian entities should not overlook.

What is the formation-stage problem in Russian related-party transaction law?

Russian corporate legislation draws a structural distinction between ordinary commercial transactions and those in which a defined interested party — a controlling shareholder, a management body member, or an affiliate of the company — stands on both sides of the dealing. For limited liability companies and joint-stock companies, transactions of this description are subject to a mandatory approval procedure designed to protect minority shareholders from value extraction by those with influence over the entity.

The complication at the formation stage is a factual gap. When a company is incorporated, its governance bodies may not yet be constituted, or may lack a quorum to act. Russian arbitrazh courts have been asked, on several occasions, whether this structural gap creates a carve-out from the approval rules, or whether the obligations apply regardless of the governance calendar.

The disputes in question involved supply agreements, lease arrangements, and loan facilities entered into by newly formed Russian entities whose counterparties were directly or indirectly connected to founding shareholders. The central legal question in each was whether the failure to obtain approval — or the practical impossibility of obtaining it — affected the validity of the transaction. The Corporate Governance dimensions of these disputes reach beyond the individual entities involved.

For in-house counsel assessing the governance compliance position of a recently established Russian subsidiary, early analysis is considerably more efficient than retrospective remediation — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

How did Russian arbitrazh courts resolve the approval gap?

The courts' analysis converged on a consistent position: the formation-stage context does not, of itself, displace the approval requirements under Russian corporate law. The operative test applied by the arbitrazh courts was whether, at the time of contracting, the legal conditions for interested-party classification were satisfied — not whether the governance machinery required to give effect to those conditions was then operational.

Where a company's governance bodies had not yet been fully constituted, the courts declined to treat this as a ground for retrospective validation of the transaction. Instead, they assessed whether approval could have been sought from whatever governance tier was available at the time. In most of the decisions examined, the general meeting of participants or shareholders — which exists by definition from the moment of state registration — was identified as the appropriate approval body for the formation period.

The courts also addressed the burden on the challenging party. A minority shareholder, or the company itself, asserting invalidity must demonstrate both that the interested-party conditions were met and that the transaction caused, or was capable of causing, prejudice to the company or its other shareholders. In several decisions, a formal procedural breach unaccompanied by demonstrable prejudice was held insufficient, in itself, to void the transaction — though courts have generally required this analysis to be conducted on the specific facts, rather than applied as a categorical rule.

"The courts' consistent message is that the interested-party rules follow the transaction, not the governance calendar. Formation is not a quarantine zone from Russian corporate law obligations." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

What does this mean for foreign companies with Russian subsidiaries?

For in-house counsel at a foreign parent establishing, or having recently established, a Russian subsidiary, the practical implication is clear: the governance gap at formation is not a safe harbour. Transactions concluded between a newly incorporated Russian entity and any entity connected to its founding shareholders should be assessed against the interested-party rules from day one of the company's existence — not from the date on which a full board or supervisory structure is in place.

This means that the standard governance checklist applied to ongoing operations must be extended, in abbreviated form, to the formation period. Where a founding shareholder or its affiliate is the counterparty to a contract entered in the first weeks of the Russian entity's life, the responsible step is to document the approval basis. Where approval was genuinely unavailable at the time of contracting — because governance bodies had not yet been constituted — counsel should record the reasoning and assess the residual risk of a subsequent challenge, including from minority shareholders whose position may have changed since formation.

The decisions also carry implications for cross-border structures in which a Russian entity forms part of a wider group. Intra-group transactions — management fees, intercompany loans, shared services agreements — concluded at or near formation are subject to the same analysis as dealings with third-party affiliates. Foreign groups establishing Russian subsidiaries should ensure that formation-stage compliance protocols reflect this position. The Russian Supreme Court's clarification on related-party transactions addresses the broader approval framework, and the practical guide to navigating related-party transaction approval sets out the procedural steps in detail. For groups managing distressed or restructuring scenarios alongside governance exposure, the firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice handles both dimensions. A record of representative mandates is available at /matters/.

If your group has recently established a Russian subsidiary and formation-stage transactions were concluded with connected parties, we can assess the approval position and any residual challenge risk — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The decisions reinforce that Russian corporate law's interested-party approval rules apply from the moment a company is incorporated, without a formation-stage grace period. Previously, some practitioners argued that the absence of constituted governance bodies at formation provided a procedural shield against invalidity claims. The courts have declined to accept that position. The practical change is that formation-period transactions with connected parties must be assessed under the standard approval framework — using whichever governance tier is available at the time, most commonly the general meeting of participants or shareholders — rather than deferred for ratification once a full board structure is in place. For foreign groups establishing Russian subsidiaries, this makes pre-incorporation planning, and early-stage governance documentation, materially more important than it may have appeared under a more permissive reading of the rules.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Three steps are advisable. First, map all transactions concluded at or near the formation of any Russian subsidiary against the interested-party classification criteria — including supply agreements, loan facilities, and intra-group arrangements such as management fees and shared services. Second, verify whether the general meeting of participants or shareholders approved, or was in a position to approve, each such transaction at the time of contracting; if not, document the governance position at the date of the transaction and the reasons approval was not obtained. Third, take legal advice on the challenge risk attaching to any transaction that was not approved and where the counterparty connection to a founding shareholder is demonstrable. Where a minority shareholder dispute is already in prospect, the window for addressing residual approval exposure is narrow.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry