Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Russian Supreme Court clarification on related-party transaction approval under Russian corporate law

Stanislav Lastovsky · September 2026 · 8 min read

Russia's Supreme Court clarified approval rules for related-party transactions. What in-house counsel at foreign subsidiaries must act on. Make an enquiry.

Following the Russian Supreme Court's clarification on related-party transaction approval issued in mid-2027, in-house counsel at foreign subsidiaries and joint ventures operating in Russia face a materially altered compliance baseline. The clarification addresses long-standing ambiguity in how Russian corporate law distinguishes interested-party transactions requiring formal approval from those that fall outside the approval regime — an ambiguity that, in practice, has produced inconsistent outcomes in different regional courts and created significant governance uncertainty for multinational groups with Russian operating entities.

§ I. What has changed — before and after the Supreme Court's clarification

Under Russian corporate legislation governing both limited liability companies and joint-stock companies, transactions in which a director, a significant shareholder, or a person affiliated with them has a material interest must, as a general rule, pass through a defined approval procedure before they are executed. The practical difficulty has always lain in the boundary: which transactions fall within the regime, and which do not? Two categories of dispute have repeatedly reached the appellate courts — intragroup transactions between a Russian subsidiary and its foreign parent or sister company, and transactions involving directors who hold a formal position at a counterparty but claim the role is non-executive and immaterial.

The Supreme Court's clarification, as it appears from the guidance issued in the relevant period, resolves both questions in a direction that expands the practical scope of the approval requirement. On intragroup transactions, the clarification indicates that the fact of common ultimate ownership does not, of itself, exempt a transaction from the interested-party regime: the question is whether a natural person who qualifies as an interested party within the meaning of Russian corporate law is capable of influencing the terms of the transaction, regardless of corporate structure. On the director-at-counterparty question, the clarification takes the position that formal title is not determinative — what matters is actual participation in governance at the counterparty, a standard that courts are expected to assess on the facts.

Before this clarification, Russian arbitrazh courts had adopted divergent approaches. Certain circuits applied a more formalistic test, treating intragroup transactions as structurally exempt where the counterparty was a wholly-owned subsidiary of the same parent. Others applied a substance-based approach that looked through the corporate structure to the natural persons in a position to benefit. The Supreme Court's guidance resolves this divergence in favour of the substance-based standard.

"The clarification is significant not because it creates new rules, but because it closes the gap that practitioners and in-house teams have been navigating case by case for several years. Groups that have been relying on structural exemptions should now treat those positions as requiring active review." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel conducting an initial review of transaction approval procedures in Russian subsidiaries — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Which foreign companies and shareholders are most directly affected?

The clarification carries practical weight for three categories of foreign participant in Russian entities.

The first is the foreign parent company that routinely enters commercial arrangements with its Russian subsidiary — supply agreements, service contracts, intercompany loans, or IP licences. Under the pre-clarification understanding that many groups had operationalised, these transactions were treated as outside the approval regime on the basis that no independent interest could exist within a fully consolidated structure. The Supreme Court's guidance, as applied through the substance-based test, means that this position is now more difficult to sustain, particularly where the Russian subsidiary has minority shareholders or where the approval requirement is being tested retrospectively in litigation.

The second category is foreign shareholders who are also parties to commercial arrangements with the Russian entity — a common structure in joint ventures where one partner provides services or technology to the jointly held operating company. For these shareholders, the clarification requires fresh examination of whether existing arrangements have the governance documentation that Russian courts will now expect to see.

The third category is foreign-appointed directors sitting on the boards of Russian entities. Where such a director holds a formal governance role at a counterparty — including a role in a foreign group company — the clarification indicates that the director's interest in a transaction with that counterparty must be disclosed and the approval procedure followed, regardless of whether the foreign role carries executive authority.

Foreign companies with Russian operating entities that have not updated their related-party transaction policies since the 2017 amendments to Russian corporate legislation should treat this clarification as a prompt for an active review. Russian courts examining transactions for approval compliance will apply the substance-based standard retrospectively in challenge proceedings — and preferential transfer challenges in insolvency, which frequently target intragroup transactions, are among the most common contexts in which the approval question arises. For transactions approved under a structural-exemption analysis that a Russian court may now regard as insufficient, the exposure is not limited to voiding the transaction: it may extend to personal liability for the directors who executed it.

If your Russian subsidiary has intragroup transactions or director-at-counterparty structures that have not been reviewed against the clarified standard — request our practice review: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What foreign clients and in-house counsel should do now

The practical response to the clarification follows a reasonably defined sequence, though the timeline for completing it will depend on the complexity of the group structure and the volume of affected transactions.

The first step is an audit of existing intragroup arrangements involving the Russian entity. This means mapping every commercial contract, financial arrangement, and IP licence where a counterparty is either a related company or an entity in which a director or significant shareholder of the Russian entity holds a governance role. The purpose of the audit is not to identify wrongdoing but to establish which transactions were approved under the old structural-exemption analysis and which may require rectification documentation.

The second step is a review of the company's articles of association and any existing shareholder agreements that address related-party transaction approval thresholds. Russian corporate law permits companies to adjust certain approval thresholds by charter, and groups with bespoke provisions may find that their charter language addresses the issue differently from the statutory default. This review should be conducted under Russian law — foreign law assessments of what the Russian charter means are not a reliable substitute for a Russian-law analysis.

The third step, for groups where the audit reveals transactions that were not approved through the required procedure, is a considered assessment of whether retrospective ratification is possible and advisable. Russian corporate law provides mechanisms for retroactive approval in limited circumstances; the conditions and procedural requirements for this vary by entity type, and the assessment is fact-specific.

For groups with minority shareholders in the Russian entity, the urgency of these steps is higher. Minority shareholders — including Russian minority partners in joint ventures — may use the clarification as a basis for challenging transactions that were previously understood to be outside the approval regime. The litigation risk should be factored into any decision about the pace and scope of the internal review.

The firm has acted for foreign shareholders and intragroup creditors in matters where related-party transaction approval has arisen as a collateral issue in restructuring and insolvency proceedings. For groups managing that intersection — particularly where the Russian entity is under financial stress — the related-party transaction position should be reviewed as part of the broader creditor-side analysis. Further context on the procedural aspects of this intersection is available in our overview of Corporate Governance for foreign shareholders and the comparative analysis at Comparative Analysis: Related-Party Transaction Approval Across Jurisdictions.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically did the Russian Supreme Court clarify regarding related-party transaction approval?

A: The Supreme Court's clarification, issued in mid-2027, establishes that the approval requirement under Russian corporate law is assessed on a substance-based test rather than a structural one. For intragroup transactions, common ultimate ownership does not automatically exempt a transaction from the interested-party regime. For transactions involving directors who hold governance roles at counterparties, the relevant question is actual participation in governance — not formal title. The effect is to extend the practical scope of the approval requirement beyond the positions that many multinational groups had previously adopted.

Q: Which foreign companies operating in Russia are most directly affected by this Russian law change?

A: The clarification most directly affects three groups: foreign parent companies entering commercial arrangements with their Russian subsidiaries, foreign shareholders who are also commercial counterparties to the jointly held Russian entity, and foreign-appointed directors holding governance roles at counterparties. Companies that have been relying on structural-exemption analyses — particularly for intragroup supply, lending, or IP-licensing arrangements — should treat those positions as requiring active review against the clarified standard. Russian entities with minority shareholders face the highest immediate exposure, since minority shareholders may use the clarification as a basis for challenge.

Q: What should in-house counsel at a foreign company with a Russian subsidiary do following this clarification?

A: The immediate priority is an audit of existing intragroup and related-party arrangements to identify which transactions were approved under the structural-exemption analysis that the Supreme Court has now moved away from. Following the audit, the company's articles and any shareholder agreements addressing approval thresholds should be reviewed under Russian law. Where the audit reveals transactions not approved through the required procedure, the question of retrospective ratification should be assessed on the specific facts. For entities with Russian minority shareholders or entities under financial stress, this review should not be deferred — the litigation window for minority shareholder challenges following a Supreme Court clarification is typically active in the period immediately after the guidance is published.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry