Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Russian court practice on minority shareholder protection in Russian JSCs and LLCs under Article 67.2 of the Civil Code (corporate agreements): 2026 update

Stanislav Lastovsky · March 2026 · 10 min read

Russian courts are reshaping minority shareholder rights under Article 67.2. What changed and what in-house counsel must review. Make an enquiry.

Following a series of decisions by Russian commercial courts in late 2025 and early 2026, the enforceability of minority shareholder protections in corporate agreements governed by Article 67.2 of the Civil Code has shifted in ways that affect foreign companies holding minority stakes in Russian joint-stock companies and limited liability companies. Courts have moved from a permissive interpretive stance — one that largely deferred to whatever the parties had agreed — toward a more structured analysis of whether specific protective provisions are consistent with the mandatory norms of Russian corporate law. For in-house counsel responsible for Russian subsidiaries or joint ventures, this shift is a material development that warrants a deliberate review of existing corporate agreement terms.

§ I. What changed — from permissive deference to structured review

For most of the period since Article 67.2 was introduced into the Civil Code, Russian courts treated corporate agreements in JSCs and LLCs primarily as a matter of private ordering. Provided the agreement was executed in the required form and filed where filing was obligatory, courts generally gave effect to its terms without conducting a searching inquiry into whether individual clauses might conflict with the dispositional or mandatory provisions of Russian joint-stock or LLC legislation.

That position has evolved. In the cases coming before arbitrazh courts in late 2025 and into 2026, the pattern that emerges is one of closer scrutiny — particularly of three categories of provision: clauses that restrict a majority shareholder's ability to call or vote at a general meeting; clauses that purport to grant minority shareholders effective veto rights over ordinary operational decisions; and clauses that establish penalty structures for breach that courts have found disproportionate under Russian civil law standards.

The shift is not a wholesale rejection of minority protection by agreement. Courts have continued to uphold transfer restrictions, tag-along and drag-along mechanisms, and obligations to vote in a specified manner on matters expressly enumerated in the agreement. What has changed is the analytical framework: courts now ask whether a provision, read against the background of Russian corporate legislation, restricts rights or imposes obligations that the legislation itself allocates to a different decisional mechanism. Where a provision attempts to achieve by agreement what Russian law reserves for a charter amendment, or what the legislation assigns to a qualified majority vote, courts have been readier to treat that provision as unenforceable.

For practical purposes, the distinction that matters to in-house counsel is between protective provisions that operate within the space Russian corporate law leaves to party agreement — and provisions that attempt to use the corporate agreement as a substitute for the charter or for mandatory statutory procedures.

"

"Russian courts are now drawing a cleaner line between what parties may achieve by corporate agreement and what Russian corporate legislation reserves for the charter or for statutory procedure — a distinction with direct consequences for minority protection architecture."— Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

"

For in-house counsel managing minority stakes in Russian JSCs or LLCs, this shift in judicial approach warrants early review of your corporate agreement terms against current court interpretation — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Who is affected, and how does the change vary by entity type?

The practical impact of this development falls unevenly across entity types and across the different functions that corporate agreements commonly serve.

In LLCs — which remain the most common vehicle for foreign joint ventures in Russia — corporate agreements have historically been used to supplement the participants' agreement, particularly where the charter itself was kept relatively lean. The developments in court practice affect LLC corporate agreements principally in two ways. First, courts have scrutinised provisions that would give a minority participant a blocking right over decisions that, under Russian LLC legislation, the charter could assign to a simple majority. Where the agreement purports to create a unanimity requirement for decisions that the legislation contemplates can be resolved by majority, courts have been less willing to treat that unanimity requirement as contractually enforceable against a third-party acquirer of shares, or to grant specific performance of it. Second, courts have applied greater attention to penalty clauses, particularly where the penalty for breach of a corporate agreement obligation is structured as a fixed sum rather than as a forfeiture of the economic benefit of the breach — a distinction that has influenced how courts assess proportionality.

In JSCs, the picture is somewhat different. Russian joint-stock legislation is more prescriptive than LLC legislation about the allocation of decision-making authority, which means corporate agreements in JSCs have always operated within a tighter set of constraints. The 2026 cases have reinforced this: courts in disputes involving JSC corporate agreements have been consistent in refusing to give contractual effect to provisions that, in substance, redistribute the statutory voting weight of share classes in ways not authorised by the legislation. This is of particular relevance for foreign shareholders holding preference shares in Russian JSCs who have entered corporate agreements designed to enhance their influence over operational decisions beyond what the share class itself provides.

For foreign shareholders in both entity types, there is an additional consideration that court practice has highlighted: the enforceability of corporate agreement provisions as between the parties themselves — in a Russian arbitrazh court, or before a contractually chosen arbitral institution — differs from their enforceability as a matter that binds the company or affects the validity of corporate resolutions. Courts have continued to draw this distinction, and the 2026 cases have sharpened it. A minority shareholder may have an enforceable contractual claim for damages against a majority shareholder who breaches an agreement obligation; the same breach will not necessarily give grounds to invalidate the corporate resolution that resulted.

Foreign companies holding minority positions in Russian joint ventures through intermediate holding structures should treat this distinction with particular care: the corporate agreement may not provide the structural protection that in-house counsel assumed it would, even if it remains contractually binding as a matter of Russian civil law.

Note: Russian corporate legislation sets limitation periods for challenging corporate resolutions that run from the date the shareholder learned or should have learned of the contested resolution. Where a minority shareholder relies on a corporate agreement breach as a ground for challenging a resolution, the applicable limitation period is shorter than may be expected. Missing this window is an irreversible procedural consequence. Counsel should verify the applicable period for each entity type at the time of any dispute.

Foreign companies with minority stakes in Russian JSCs or LLCs should assess whether their corporate agreement structure remains fit for purpose in light of current court interpretation — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What should foreign clients do now?

The immediate priority for in-house counsel is a structured review of any corporate agreement currently in place for a Russian subsidiary or joint venture entity. This review should focus on the following areas.

First, identify all provisions in the corporate agreement that create consent or veto rights in favour of the minority shareholder over categories of decision that Russian corporate legislation allocates to a qualified or simple majority. Courts' current interpretive approach means these provisions carry enforcement risk that was lower under prior practice. Where such provisions are material to the investment rationale — for example, where a foreign shareholder holds a minority stake in a Russian LLC on the basis that it has effective consent rights over material contracts — the structural question is whether equivalent protection can be achieved through a charter provision rather than a contractual one, and whether the majority shareholder will negotiate a charter amendment.

Second, review penalty clauses. Where the corporate agreement contains a fixed-sum penalty for breach of voting obligations or transfer restrictions, consider whether that sum would satisfy a Russian court's proportionality assessment. Disproportionate penalties risk being reduced by a court to a level that removes their practical deterrent effect, and in some of the 2026 cases courts have gone further by finding that a manifestly disproportionate penalty clause undermines the credibility of the enforcement case as a whole.

Third, consider the forum for resolving disputes arising under the corporate agreement. Russian arbitrazh courts have exclusive jurisdiction to hear corporate disputes involving Russian legal entities; claims under corporate agreements, to the extent they relate to the rights of participants or shareholders in a Russian company, are characterised as corporate disputes under procedural legislation. This means that contractual arbitration clauses referring corporate agreement disputes to international arbitration will be of limited utility for the most material category of claim — the kind that directly affects corporate resolutions or demands specific performance of voting obligations. Disputes framed as purely contractual claims for damages may remain arbitrable, but counsel should seek a confirmed opinion on the specific clause and entity type before relying on an international arbitration clause as the primary dispute resolution mechanism.

For foreign companies approaching this review from the context of a Corporate Governance audit, this is also an appropriate moment to cross-reference the corporate agreement terms against the current charter, since inconsistencies between the two documents create an additional layer of enforcement uncertainty that courts have shown limited appetite to resolve in the minority shareholder's favour.

Further analysis of the substantive protections available to minority shareholders in Russian JSCs and LLCs is set out in the firm's article on Minority Shareholder Protection in Russian JSCs and LLCs. For a broader treatment of the law and practice of minority shareholder protection across Russian corporate forms, see The Law and Practice of Minority Shareholder Protection in Russia. A summary of the firm's corporate-related advisory work is available via the Matters page.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on corporate agreements under Article 67.2 in 2025–2026?

A: Courts have shifted from broad deference to party-agreed terms toward a more structured review of whether individual provisions in corporate agreements comply with the mandatory and dispositional norms of Russian corporate legislation. The principal areas affected are: provisions purporting to give minority shareholders veto or blocking rights over decisions allocated by statute to a majority; penalty clauses that courts find disproportionate; and provisions that, in substance, attempt to achieve through agreement what Russian law reserves for a charter amendment or a qualified majority vote. Transfer restrictions, tag-along and drag-along rights, and enumerated voting obligations have largely continued to be upheld. The overall effect is a narrowing of the protective space that corporate agreements can reliably occupy in JSCs and LLCs under Russian law.

Q: Which foreign shareholders are most affected by this development in Russian corporate law?

A: The development is most directly relevant to foreign companies holding minority stakes in Russian LLCs or JSCs under joint venture arrangements where the corporate agreement was designed to give the minority shareholder meaningful influence over operational decisions or to protect its exit rights. In LLCs, minority participants relying on contractual consent rights over decisions that Russian legislation allocates to a majority face the highest enforcement risk. In JSCs, foreign holders of preference shares whose corporate agreement was structured to augment their influence beyond what their share class provides are also materially affected. Foreign shareholders who hold a majority stake, or whose corporate agreement is limited to transfer restrictions and tag-along mechanics, face more limited exposure from this development.

Q: What should in-house counsel do to address this risk in their Russian joint venture or subsidiary?

A: The immediate action is a review of the corporate agreement for the Russian entity, focusing on: consent and veto provisions and their alignment with Russian corporate legislation; the structure and quantum of any penalty clauses; and the forum clause, given the limitations on arbitrating corporate disputes involving Russian legal entities. Where material consent rights rest exclusively on the corporate agreement rather than on a charter provision, the question of whether equivalent protection is achievable at the charter level should be assessed. Where the corporate agreement pre-dates 2022, it is particularly likely to contain terms that do not reflect how Russian courts are currently approaching enforcement. Given the limitation periods applicable to challenging corporate resolutions, there is limited margin for delay once a dispute arises.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry