Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Regulatory update: corporate disputes: arbitration clauses in Russian law contracts under Article 67.2 of the Civil Code (corporate agreements)

Stanislav Lastovsky · July 2026 · 8 min read

Russian corporate agreements now face tighter arbitration clause requirements under Article 67.2 of the Civil Code. Review your contracts. Make an enquiry.

Amendments and evolving judicial interpretations bearing on corporate agreements under Article 67.2 of the Civil Code have, in recent periods, introduced a more demanding framework for arbitration clauses embedded in Russian law contracts. For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary or a joint venture structured under Russian corporate law, understanding what has changed — and what that change requires in practice — is now a routine governance task rather than a specialist enquiry.

§ I. What has changed in the treatment of arbitration clauses in Russian corporate agreements?

Before the current regulatory position solidified, arbitration clauses in Russian-law corporate agreements occupied contested ground. The 2016 arbitration reform — which remains the legislative foundation for arbitrability of corporate disputes in Russia — established that certain categories of corporate dispute could be referred to arbitration conducted by a qualifying permanent arbitral institution. That framework distinguished between disputes that Russian courts regard as inherently subject to exclusive state court jurisdiction and those that may be resolved by agreement through arbitration.

Article 67.2 of the Civil Code governs corporate agreements — contractual arrangements between shareholders of limited liability companies and joint-stock companies that regulate the exercise of corporate rights, including voting obligations, share transfer conditions, and coordination of management decisions. The question of whether an arbitration clause inserted into such an agreement will be treated as valid and enforceable has, under recent judicial practice, come to depend on a set of conditions that Russian courts have refined considerably. The prevailing approach distinguishes between the corporate agreement as a contractual instrument (where arbitration is generally permissible for contract-based claims between the parties) and the underlying corporate dispute in its public dimension (where exclusive state court jurisdiction typically applies).

What has shifted is the granularity of scrutiny applied by Russian arbitrazh courts when examining whether a particular dispute falls within the contractual perimeter of the Article 67.2 agreement or within the non-arbitrable corporate dimension. Courts have generally held that claims arising directly from obligations assumed under the corporate agreement — a shareholder's breach of a drag-along provision, a failure to vote in the agreed manner, a damages claim for non-performance of an obligation to sell — are arbitrable, provided the arbitration is seated at a qualifying permanent arbitral institution. Disputes that require the court to alter or invalidate a corporate act — such as annulling a general meeting resolution or challenging a state registration decision — remain outside the scope of what an arbitration clause in a corporate agreement can reach.

For in-house counsel assessing whether your entity's corporate agreement requires revision in light of current Russian court practice, an initial review is a proportionate first step. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Which foreign shareholders and Russian subsidiaries are most affected?

The practical significance of the current framework is not uniform across all corporate structures. Foreign shareholders holding interests in Russian limited liability companies through a Russian-law corporate agreement are among those most directly exposed, since the corporate agreement is often the primary instrument through which minority protections, exit rights, and dispute resolution mechanisms are defined. For minority shareholders in particular — a category that frequently corresponds to the foreign investor in a joint venture with a Russian majority partner — the enforceability of the arbitration clause is rarely a theoretical concern. It becomes live at the moment the relationship deteriorates.

A key factor shaping exposure is whether the foreign shareholder's arbitration clause designates a qualifying permanent arbitral institution within the meaning of the Russian arbitration legislation. The Russian Arbitration Centre (RAC) and the ICAC at the Chamber of Commerce and Industry (MKAS) are among the institutions that have obtained the necessary status. Foreign-seated arbitration — ICC, LCIA, SCC, SIAC — presents a materially different picture: under the prevailing interpretation, Russian arbitrazh courts have, in the majority of cases, declined to treat a corporate dispute arising from an Article 67.2 agreement as arbitrable before a foreign-seated institution, treating the dispute as falling within exclusive state jurisdiction irrespective of the parties' contractual choice.

Foreign shareholders structured through intermediate holding vehicles — whether Cypriot, Dutch, or other holding jurisdictions — who have relied on English-law or foreign-law corporate agreements alongside a Russian-law corporate agreement for the Russian operating entity should note that the Russian-law instrument is governed by this framework independently of any foreign-law agreement. The presence of a parallel foreign-law shareholders' agreement does not extend the arbitrability of claims under the Russian-law Article 67.2 corporate agreement beyond what Russian courts will recognise.

"The enforceability gap between foreign-seated arbitration clauses and Russia-seated institutional arbitration in Article 67.2 corporate agreements is now a documented feature of practice — not a residual risk that careful drafting alone can eliminate." — Stanislav Lastovsky, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — Restructuring & Insolvency, Vetrov & Partners

§ III. What should foreign companies do now?

For in-house counsel, the practical response to the current framework is a structured review of existing Russian-law corporate agreements, prioritising those that contain arbitration clauses designating a foreign-seated institution or a non-qualifying arbitral body. The review should address three questions in sequence.

First, does the arbitration clause in the Article 67.2 corporate agreement cover disputes that Russian courts are likely to characterise as falling within the contractual perimeter of the agreement — damages, specific performance of shareholder obligations — or does it extend to relief that requires a Russian court act, such as annulling a resolution or compelling a registration? Clauses drafted broadly to cover "any dispute arising from or in connection with" the agreement may face partial severance in Russian court proceedings.

Second, does the designated institution qualify under Russian arbitration legislation? If not, the clause's enforceability before a Russian arbitrazh court is uncertain. Where the corporate agreement is currently in force and renegotiation is not immediately possible, foreign shareholders should take legal advice on the steps available to them in the event the Russian counterparty initiates state court proceedings in disregard of the arbitration clause.

Third, for corporate agreements under negotiation or in the process of renewal, the current framework supports a considered choice between domestic institutional arbitration and state court jurisdiction for Russian-law disputes, with realistic expectations built into the drafting. Hybrid structures — where contractual disputes are referred to institutional arbitration and corporate-act disputes are conceded to state courts — have gained traction in practice and merit consideration for new agreements.

§ IV. Open questions and what to watch

Several interpretive points remain unsettled in Russian court practice. The boundary between a contractual claim and a corporate-act claim is not always drawn consistently across circuits; the Siberian and Ural federal districts have, in documented cases, applied a narrower reading of what falls within the contractual perimeter than the Moscow commercial courts. For multinational groups whose Russian operating entity is registered outside Moscow — a common outcome of regional acquisition — circuit-level variation in arbitrability analysis is a material consideration.

A further open question concerns the treatment of institutional arbitration awards rendered on Article 67.2 claims where the counterparty challenges recognition in Russian state court proceedings on public-policy or jurisdictional grounds. The grounds for non-recognition are invoked with some frequency in corporate disputes, and the outcome depends substantially on the specific relief awarded and the drafting of the clause under review.

If your group holds an interest in a Russian entity governed by an Article 67.2 corporate agreement and the dispute resolution mechanism has not been reviewed against current Russian court practice, the appropriate moment to do so is before a dispute arises — not during one. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in the treatment of arbitration clauses in Article 67.2 corporate agreements under Russian law?

A: The core legislative framework — established by the 2016 arbitration reform — has not been displaced. What has developed is the granularity of Russian court analysis when determining whether a specific claim arising from a corporate agreement falls within the arbitrable contractual perimeter or within non-arbitrable corporate-act jurisdiction. Courts have generally required that the arbitration clause designate a qualifying permanent arbitral institution, that the relief sought be contractual in nature (damages, specific performance), and that the clause does not purport to submit disputes requiring corporate-act annulment to arbitration. In-house counsel should treat the distinction between contractual and corporate-act claims as the operative filter when assessing whether a given clause will be enforced.

Q: Which categories of foreign shareholder are most directly affected by this framework?

A: Foreign shareholders holding minority interests in Russian limited liability companies or joint-stock companies through a Russian-law corporate agreement are most directly affected — particularly where the agreement designates a foreign-seated arbitral institution. Under the prevailing Russian judicial approach, such clauses in corporate disputes have generally not been recognised as valid arbitration agreements by Russian arbitrazh courts. Foreign shareholders structured through intermediate holding entities in Cyprus, the Netherlands, or similar jurisdictions, relying on a parallel foreign-law shareholders' agreement, should note that the Russian-law corporate agreement is assessed independently. The holding structure does not extend arbitrability of claims under the Russian-law instrument.

Q: What practical steps should in-house counsel take in response to the current framework?

A: Three steps are advisable. First, audit existing Russian-law corporate agreements to identify arbitration clauses that designate foreign-seated or non-qualifying institutions — these present enforcement risk in Russian proceedings. Second, assess the scope of the arbitration clause against the boundary between contractual and corporate-act claims; overly broad clauses may be partially severed. Third, for agreements under negotiation, consider domestic institutional arbitration (RAC or MKAS) for contractual disputes, with state court jurisdiction expressly reserved for corporate-act relief. Taking legal advice before a dispute arises allows these adjustments to be made on a considered timetable rather than under procedural pressure.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry