Major transaction approval in Russia follows distinct rules when the counterparty is an individual. What subsidiaries must do. Make an enquiry.
Unlike English or German corporate law, which typically treat all counterparties to a significant transaction identically for approval purposes, Russian corporate legislation draws important procedural consequences from the nature of the counterparty itself. When a Russian subsidiary of a foreign company enters into a transaction whose value exceeds the statutory threshold — measured against the company's balance-sheet asset value — it must complete a major transaction approval procedure before signing. That procedure applies whether the other party is a corporate entity or a private individual, but the documentation requirements, the verification steps, and the practical risks differ materially in each case. This guide sets out the procedure for in-house counsel managing Russian subsidiaries whose major transactions involve individual counterparties — a configuration more common than many governance teams anticipate, arising in asset purchases, loan agreements, and settlement arrangements with founders or former officers.
Before the approval process formally begins, the subsidiary's legal or compliance team should assemble the following materials. Incomplete preparation at this stage is the most frequent cause of procedural delays in practice.
If you are preparing a major transaction involving an individual counterparty and need to confirm whether the threshold is reached, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The first step is calculating whether the transaction meets the statutory threshold. Under Russian limited liability company legislation and Russian joint-stock company legislation, a transaction is classified as a major transaction when its value — or the value of the property being transferred or used — exceeds 25 per cent of the total value of the company's assets as shown on the most recent balance sheet.
For transactions with individuals, this calculation has a specific practical complication: the consideration may be structured as a series of payments, a forgiveness of debt, or a combination of cash and property. In each case, the full economic value must be aggregated before the comparison to the balance-sheet threshold is made. Courts have consistently held that parties may not artificially divide a single economic arrangement into sub-threshold tranches to avoid the approval requirement — a practice that Russian courts treat as a basis for voiding the transaction at the suit of a participant or the company itself.
Equally, certain categories of transaction are excluded from the major transaction regime regardless of value: transactions in the ordinary course of business, transactions between a company and its sole participant where that participant is also the sole executive, and transactions subject to a separate interested-party regime. The in-house team should confirm that none of these exclusions applies before proceeding to the approval stage.
The asset base figure used for the threshold is the balance-sheet total assets line — not net assets, not revenue. This distinction matters practically: a company with high gross assets but negative equity may find that relatively modest transactions cross the threshold.
Once the transaction is confirmed as a major transaction, the approval must be obtained from the correct corporate body. Under Russian corporate legislation, the applicable body depends on the transaction's value as a proportion of the company's assets:
For subsidiaries wholly owned by a foreign parent, the "general meeting" is in practice a sole-participant decision — a written resolution of the parent entity acting as the single participant or shareholder. That resolution must be properly documented under Russian corporate procedure, adopted in the name of the parent, and retained in the Russian subsidiary's corporate records. A resolution adopted in the parent's home-country form but not translated and properly formalised for Russian corporate purposes has been found insufficient by Russian courts in subsequent challenge proceedings.
Note: A major transaction completed without the required approval is voidable — not automatically void — but it may be challenged in court by the company itself or by any participant or shareholder within a one-year limitation period running from the date the claimant discovered or should have discovered that the transaction lacked approval. For foreign parents, this risk is material: a transaction with an individual counterparty is less likely to be discoverable through public registers and more likely to surface only in subsequent due diligence or insolvency proceedings.
The individual counterparty dimension introduces a layer of due diligence that does not arise in corporate-to-corporate major transactions. The following categories of individual counterparty warrant heightened scrutiny before an approval resolution is tabled:
For transactions with current or former officers of your Russian subsidiary, the procedural requirements are layered — speak to our team before tabling the approval resolution: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The approval resolution must satisfy specific formal requirements under Russian corporate law. A resolution that is substantively correct but procedurally deficient can be challenged on the same basis as a missing resolution.
The resolution must identify: the parties to the transaction (including the individual's full name, passport series and number, and registered address); the subject matter of the transaction; the price or the basis on which the price is to be determined; and any other material terms that define the economic character of the transaction. Where the transaction involves movable or immovable property, the resolution must also identify the property with sufficient precision to allow identification.
For a sole-participant resolution, the document must be signed by the authorised representative of the foreign parent in the capacity of sole participant, not as a director of the subsidiary. This distinction in signing capacity has been the subject of challenge in Russian courts where a parent company's signatory signed in an ambiguous capacity.
The resolution should be dated and timestamped and placed in the subsidiary's corporate records book (книга протоколов) promptly. There is no statutory filing requirement for the resolution itself — it does not go to the tax authority or the trade register — but it must be available for inspection and must be produced in any subsequent challenge or audit.
If the charter requires notarisation of participant resolutions (the default position for LLC participant meetings unless displaced by charter or by a prior notarially certified resolution of participants), the notarisation must occur before the transaction is signed, not after. Post-hoc notarisation does not cure the procedural deficiency.
Execution follows the approval resolution. The signed transaction document and the approval resolution are the two primary items in the compliance record. For transactions with individual counterparties, the record trail should also include the following, retained in the same file:
For immovable property transactions, state registration is a separate downstream step with Rosreestr, and the approval resolution is a required supporting document in the registration package. The registration officer will verify the resolution's formal compliance — this is a practical quality check, but it does not substitute for a substantive legal review.
If you are managing the post-execution compliance record for a completed major transaction and are uncertain whether the documentation meets the current standard, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The major transaction approval procedure does not end at execution. Two ongoing governance obligations deserve attention from foreign parents managing Russian subsidiaries.
First, the one-year challenge window. As noted above, an approved transaction cannot be challenged on major-transaction grounds, but the limitation period for challenges to unapproved transactions runs from the date the claimant knew or should have known of the missing approval. For parent companies, the risk crystallises most acutely in M&A due diligence: a target subsidiary that completed unapproved major transactions with individual counterparties will carry a latent voidability risk for up to one year after the acquirer gains actual knowledge. In practice, that means the limitation period can run well beyond one year from the transaction date if the acquirer did not discover the deficiency promptly.
Second, annual governance review. Russian corporate law does not require a retrospective approval of completed transactions, but a periodic internal review of major transactions executed in the preceding financial year is good governance practice for foreign-owned subsidiaries. It identifies patterns of threshold misclassification, flags individual-counterparty transactions that were not subjected to the interested-party check, and supports the subsidiary's reporting obligations to the parent under group governance standards.
The firm's Corporate Governance practice advises foreign companies on subsidiary governance matters including major transaction compliance, interested-party procedures, and corporate record maintenance. Related analysis on recent legislative changes affecting the major transaction regime is available at Legislative amendments affecting major transactions in Russian corporate law and Strategic considerations in major transaction approval.
For broader enforcement considerations where a completed transaction is subsequently disputed in Russian proceedings, the firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice handles creditor-side mandates in those proceedings. An overview of representative cross-border matters is available at the firm's Matters page.
Q: How long does the major transaction approval procedure typically take in a Russian subsidiary?
A: In a subsidiary without a functioning board of directors — which describes the majority of single-purpose Russian subsidiaries held by foreign parents — the procedure runs from threshold determination to signed resolution within five to ten business days when all documents are in order. The principal variable is the time required to obtain the parent company's internal approval and to arrange notarisation of the participant resolution if required. Where the charter displaces the notarisation requirement (which requires a prior notarially certified resolution of participants to that effect), the timeline can be compressed to two or three business days. The threshold calculation and the identification of individual-counterparty due diligence requirements should not be treated as same-day tasks; allow at least two business days for careful verification.
Q: What documents does the individual counterparty need to provide for the approval resolution to be complete?
A: The individual must provide passport details sufficient to identify them unambiguously in the approval resolution: full name as it appears in the passport, passport series and number, date and place of issue, and registered residential address. No notarised copies are required by the corporate law itself, though the subsidiary's compliance practice may require certified copies for its records. If the individual is a foreign national, a Russian-language translation of the relevant passport pages is advisable. For the interested-party check, the individual must also disclose any direct or indirect equity interest in the subsidiary or in any other entity that is also a party to the transaction. The subsidiary is responsible for verifying this declaration in good faith.
Q: What happens if a major transaction with an individual counterparty is completed without the required approval?
A: The transaction is voidable, not automatically void. It remains legally effective until a court sets it aside. The right to challenge belongs to the company itself and to any participant or shareholder; the individual counterparty does not have standing to challenge on major-transaction grounds. A successful challenge results in the transaction being unwound — each party is required to restore what it received — which can create significant practical difficulties where the individual has already disposed of funds or property received under the transaction. The challenge must be brought within one year of the date the claimant knew or should have known of the missing approval, subject to a general limitation backstop. Courts have in practice been willing to void transactions where the individual counterparty knew or should have known that the approval procedure was not completed, particularly where the individual was an officer or participant of the company.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry