Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Drafting issues in major transaction procedure under Russian corporate law: common pitfalls

Stanislav Lastovsky · September 2026 · 5 min read

Drafting errors in Russian major transaction procedure can invalidate board approval. A practitioner note for in-house counsel. Make an enquiry.

Under Russian corporate law, the major transaction procedure is a formal governance mechanism with precise technical requirements — not a procedural formality that can be addressed retrospectively. Unlike approval processes under many European corporate regimes, where ratification after the fact is ordinarily available, Russian law takes a stricter position: a major transaction concluded without the requisite approval is voidable at the suit of the company or its shareholders. For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary, the drafting quality of the underlying approval documents is therefore a material legal risk, not merely an administrative concern.

The core operative paragraph — typically one line in the board or shareholder resolution — carries more legal weight than most GCs accustomed to English or German corporate practice would expect.

What does the major transaction procedure actually require?

Russian corporate legislation distinguishes between major transactions by value threshold, typically calculated as a percentage of the book value of the company's assets. Where that threshold is met or exceeded, the transaction must be approved by the board of directors (within defined limits) or by a general meeting of participants or shareholders. The distinction matters: approval by the wrong corporate body is not a technical irregularity that courts will overlook — it is treated as a substantive defect.

The approval resolution must identify the transaction with sufficient specificity. At a minimum, this means: the counterparty or category of counterparty, the subject matter of the transaction, its price or the basis for determining price, and any other terms the statute or the company's constitutional documents designate as material. Where the transaction involves a pledge or a guarantee, the secured obligation must be described in terms that allow a court to verify it against the actual agreement concluded.

A resolution that approves a transaction "on terms to be agreed" or "at a price not exceeding [amount]" without further specification has been found by Russian courts to fall short of the statutory standard in a number of reported decisions. The courts have consistently held that the resolution must reflect the transaction's essential conditions as they actually exist at the time of approval — not a range or a placeholder. In-house counsel reviewing approval documents for a Russian subsidiary should treat open-ended approval language as a red flag requiring clarification before execution.

Where do drafting errors arise — and why do they matter to Russian courts?

The most common category of drafting error involves mismatch between the transaction as approved and the transaction as executed. This arises in several recurring patterns.

First, the approved price differs from the price in the signed agreement — often because negotiations continued after the resolution was passed. Russian courts examining a challenge to a major transaction will compare the resolution and the executed agreement directly. A material discrepancy gives standing to a shareholder claimant and shifts the burden onto the company to demonstrate ratification or acquiescence.

Second, the counterparty is described incorrectly or insufficiently. A resolution approving a transaction with "[Company Name], registered in Russia" may be challenged where the actual counterparty is a different legal entity within the same group. The fact that the parties share economic ownership does not cure the defect.

Third, the asset subject of the transaction is not described with the precision the underlying registries require. For real property transactions in particular — which are the most frequent context for major transaction challenges in Russian court practice — a description that does not match the cadastral record creates a point of attack that a litigant counterparty or disgruntled shareholder will exploit.

A fourth, less obvious category: constitutional documents of the company may set a lower threshold or additional approval requirements beyond the statutory minimum. In-house counsel instructed from group headquarters often apply the statutory standard alone, without reviewing the Russian entity's own charter. Where the charter is more restrictive and the more restrictive standard was not applied, the approval is defective on its own terms.

Note: A challenge to a major transaction on approval procedure grounds may be brought within one year of the date on which the claimant knew or ought to have known of the alleged violation. This is a shortened limitation period. A minority shareholder who acquires an interest after the transaction is concluded is not necessarily time-barred: Russian courts have in some cases treated the date of acquisition as the date of constructive knowledge, extending the exposure window. Counsel advising on legacy transactions should assess this risk explicitly.

What should in-house counsel do before the next transaction closes?

Three practical steps reduce the drafting risk materially.

First, produce a transaction-specific approval checklist before the resolution is drafted — not after. The checklist should confirm: (a) whether the value threshold is met, calculated on current book value rather than group accounts; (b) which corporate body has authority; and (c) whether the constitutional documents impose requirements beyond the statutory floor. Each point should be confirmed by the Russian-qualified lawyer advising on the transaction, not assumed from prior experience with similar transactions.

Second, draft the approval resolution from the final, executed form of the agreement — or from a term sheet that is itself final and binding. Where commercial negotiations are genuinely incomplete at the time the resolution must be passed, consider whether the timing can be adjusted, or whether a conditional approval structure is technically available under the applicable statutory framework. This is a fact-specific question that depends on the corporate form of the entity.

Third, where the transaction is material at the group level and involves real property, share pledges, or guarantees, have the approval resolution reviewed against the executed agreement as a discrete step before filing. A mismatch identified at this stage costs little to correct. A mismatch identified after a challenge is filed is a substantially different problem.

For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary whose major transaction pipeline is active, these steps are worth embedding as a standing protocol rather than a case-by-case measure.

To discuss the major transaction procedure for a specific Russian entity — or to have existing approval documentation reviewed — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry