Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Court of appeal reverses on witness evidence collection in Russia for international arbitration: implications for claimants

Vitaliy Vetrov · January 2026 · 7 min read

A Russian appeal court reversed on witness evidence collection for arbitration. What instructing foreign firms need to know. Make an enquiry.

In practice, the collection of witness evidence in Russia for use in international arbitration has never been procedurally straightforward — but it was at least predictable. Foreign law firms advising claimants in LCIA, ICC, or RAC proceedings have developed working assumptions about what Russian courts would and would not do when asked to assist in gathering testimony located within Russia. A recent appellate decision has unsettled those assumptions, reversing the approach taken at first instance and signalling a shift in how Russian courts interpret their role in cross-border evidentiary assistance.

Background

When a witness with material knowledge of a dispute is located in Russia, foreign counsel instructing local lawyers for international arbitral proceedings must navigate two overlapping frameworks. The first is the international framework for judicial cooperation — principally the Hague Evidence Convention, of which Russia is a signatory — which governs formal requests from foreign tribunals or courts to Russian judicial authorities. The second is the domestic Russian civil procedure framework, which determines how Russian courts interpret and process such requests and what procedural standards a requesting party must satisfy before a Russian court will compel witness testimony.

For much of the past decade, first-instance Russian courts in cross-border litigation matters had taken a relatively permissive stance: where the requesting party demonstrated a direct connection between the witness and the substantive dispute, courts tended to allow the request to proceed, even where the procedural framing was less precise than the letter of Russian civil procedure technically required. This approach was convenient for foreign claimants, who frequently relied on it when instructing local counsel to prepare and submit assistance applications on short timelines.

The decision that prompted this commentary arose in precisely that context: an application by a foreign claimant, via Russian local counsel, seeking judicial assistance in collecting witness testimony from individuals based in Russia, for use in an international arbitral proceeding seated outside Russia. The first-instance court granted the application. The appellate court reversed it.

What did the appellate court decide?

The appellate court's reversal rested on several grounds, each significant in isolation; taken together, they represent a materially stricter reading of the procedural requirements than the first-instance court had applied.

The first ground concerned the specificity of the witness identification. The appellate court held that the application as formulated did not sufficiently identify the factual matters on which each witness was expected to give evidence, nor did it demonstrate that this testimony was not available through other means within the arbitral proceedings themselves. In the appellate court's reasoning, the assistance of a Russian state court in compelling witness appearances is not a procedural convenience — it is an exception to ordinary party-led evidence gathering, and that exception requires a clear showing that the evidence in question is both material and not otherwise obtainable.

The second ground was procedural: the application had not adequately described the evidentiary rules of the arbitral tribunal in question — in particular, whether the tribunal's procedural framework contemplated court-ordered witness testimony, or whether it operated under a document-production-first model that would make any pre-hearing witness order premature. This matters because Russian courts, in the appellate court's view, are not obliged to assist where the procedural posture of the foreign proceedings does not yet require the evidence being sought.

The third ground — and the one most likely to generate divergence across circuits — was jurisdictional framing. The appellate court observed that the application had not clearly established the basis on which the Russian court's assistance was being invoked: was this a formal Letter of Request under the Hague Convention framework, or a domestic application under Russian civil procedure? The two routes attract different procedural standards and different time frames, and the court declined to treat the application as satisfying both simultaneously.

"

If you are instructing local counsel in Russia for international arbitration proceedings, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

"

What does this mean for foreign firms instructing local counsel in Russia?

"This decision recalibrates the minimum threshold for witness evidence applications before Russian courts, and it does so in a direction that places a significant premium on procedural precision at the drafting stage — before any application is filed." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

For foreign law firms advising clients in international arbitral proceedings, the appellate reversal has three immediate practical implications.

First, the specificity requirements identified by the appellate court are likely to be applied more broadly. Even if circuit courts outside the district in question have not yet adopted the same approach, the reasoning is sufficiently principled that first-instance courts elsewhere will face pressure to follow it. Local counsel in Russia should, from this point, be preparing witness evidence applications with the level of specificity the appellate court required — identifying each witness, the factual issues they speak to, and the reasons those issues cannot be addressed through the arbitral tribunal's own evidence-gathering mechanisms — as a matter of default rather than only where the court requests it.

Second, the distinction the appellate court drew between Hague Convention Letters of Request and domestic civil procedure applications is procedurally consequential. The two routes are not interchangeable, and the choice of route has implications for the timeline of the application, the form of the resulting order, and the obligations it imposes on the witness. Foreign firms that have historically left this framing decision to local counsel without specific instructions should reconsider that delegation. The route taken should be a deliberate choice, informed by the timeline of the arbitral proceedings, the seat of the tribunal, and the likely cooperation of the witness.

Third, the decision reinforces the importance of early-stage coordination between foreign counsel and Russian local counsel in disputes where witness evidence located in Russia is material. The cost of an incorrectly formulated application is not merely a lost procedural step: it is a reversal on the record, a delay that may affect the arbitral timetable, and — depending on the arbitral rules — a potential argument for the opposing party that the evidence-gathering process was procedurally deficient.

For firms that rely on the Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice at Vetrov & Partners as local counsel, this development is one we flagged in our recent court practice shift analysis on witness evidence collection. The key risk points in witness evidence collection briefing, published alongside this commentary, sets out a practical checklist for foreign counsel managing evidence-gathering instructions into Russia. Additional matters from this practice area are listed on the Matters page.

Firms managing international arbitration matters with witnesses located in Russia are welcome to make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change? A: The appellate reversal establishes — or re-establishes, depending on the circuit — that Russian courts will scrutinise witness evidence applications for cross-border proceedings against a stricter procedural standard than many practitioners had assumed. The change is not a prohibition on collecting witness evidence in Russia for use in international arbitration: the Hague Convention framework and domestic civil procedure continue to provide viable routes. What changes is the level of specificity and procedural framing required at the application stage. Applications that are vague about the witness's factual role, or that fail to select and articulate the correct procedural basis, are now more likely to be refused at appellate level even if a first-instance court granted them.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision? A: The most immediate action is to review how witness evidence instructions are typically prepared and transmitted to Russian local counsel. Where the standard practice has been to instruct local counsel with a broad description of the witnesses and their general relevance, that practice should be upgraded. Applications should now specify each witness's factual contribution to the issues in dispute, confirm that testimony is not available through other means within the arbitral proceedings, and clearly identify the procedural route — Hague Convention or domestic civil procedure — through which the application is made. This is primarily a drafting and coordination issue, not a change in substantive Russian law, and it is addressable through adjusted working practices between foreign counsel and trusted local advisers.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry