Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Case comment: arbitration clauses governed by Russian law

Vitaliy Vetrov · May 2026 · 6 min read

Russian courts have clarified how governing-law choices affect arbitration clauses in contracts. What foreign counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.

In the course of advising foreign law firms on cross-border matters with Russian elements, a recurrent source of concern is the deceptively simple question of which law governs an arbitration clause when the governing law of the main contract is Russian. Russian courts have developed a body of case law on this question that is not always predictable from the text of the clause itself — and a recent decision has brought the position into sharper relief for foreign counsel instructing local lawyers in Russia.

Background

The matter arose in the context of a commercial contract between a Russian entity and a foreign counterparty, incorporating a standard international arbitration clause alongside a choice-of-law provision designating Russian law as the governing law of the contract. When a dispute arose, the Russian party commenced proceedings before an arbitrazh court, arguing that the arbitration agreement was invalid — or at least unenforceable in the particular circumstances — under Russian law, notwithstanding the parties' express agreement to submit disputes to international arbitration.

The legal question was substantively this: where an arbitration clause is embedded in a contract governed by Russian law, does Russian law apply to assess the formal and substantive validity of that clause? And if so, what standard does Russian law impose? The foreign party contested the arbitrazh court's jurisdiction on the basis of the arbitration agreement and sought a referral. The proceedings thus presented the court with the intersection of two bodies of doctrine: the separability principle as received into Russian arbitration law, and the consequences of a Russian-law governing-law clause for the validity and scope of the embedded arbitration agreement.

The decision

The court held that Russian law governed the validity and enforceability of the arbitration clause, treating the choice-of-law provision in the main contract as extending to the arbitration agreement by default, in the absence of a separate governing-law designation for the clause itself. On that basis, the court applied Russian standards of validity — examining, among other things, whether the arbitration agreement satisfied the formal requirements under Russian civil procedure and arbitration legislation, and whether the designated arbitral institution was properly identified under the evolving Russian framework for recognised arbitral institutions.

The court affirmed the separability principle: the arbitration clause survived as a legally independent agreement from the main contract, and its validity was to be assessed on its own terms. However — and this is the operationally significant holding — the choice of Russian law in the main contract was treated as the parties' implicit choice of Russian law to govern the arbitration clause as well, absent any contrary indication. Courts in parallel proceedings have approached this question inconsistently, and the decision under comment usefully consolidates the prevailing position.

For foreign counsel engaged in cross-border litigation in Russia, the practical consequence is material: a Russian-law governing-law clause does not merely set the substantive law of the contract. It carries a default rule — applied with increasing consistency by Russian courts — that Russian law will also determine whether the parties are validly bound to arbitrate, and on what terms.

"What this ruling consolidates is a default linkage between the main contract's governing law and the arbitration clause's governing law — a linkage that foreign counsel drafting for Russian-law contracts must consciously override if they intend a different result." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

For foreign firms advising clients on contracts with Russian-law governing-law clauses, or managing live proceedings in Russian courts, an early-stage review with experienced local counsel is advisable. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For foreign counsel instructing Russian lawyers — whether at the drafting stage or in live proceedings — the decision reinforces several practical considerations that are specific to the Russian cross-border context.

First, the default linkage is now clearly established. A contract governed by Russian law will, unless the clause specifies otherwise, be treated as conferring Russian law jurisdiction over the arbitration agreement itself. For parties whose arbitral seat is outside Russia (LCIA, ICC, VIAC, or otherwise), this may produce a mismatch: the arbitration proceeds under institutional rules and the law of the seat, while a Russian court considering a challenge to or enforcement of the clause will apply Russian law standards. This is a structural tension that arises at the drafting stage and cannot be fully remedied once proceedings have commenced.

Second, the decision is relevant to any foreign firm currently managing proceedings where a Russian counterparty has brought or threatened parallel court proceedings in Russia. The arbitrazh court's application of Russian law to assess the scope or validity of the clause means that local analysis — not merely a translation of the English-language clause — is the minimum required input. Firms instructing local counsel in Russia should specifically request an assessment of the clause's enforceability under Russian law standards, separately from the position under the law of the seat.

Third, for matters involving counterparties from EAEU or CIS member states, the position may be shaped additionally by bilateral and multilateral treaty obligations governing judicial cooperation and the mutual recognition of arbitration agreements. The domestic Russian position set out in this decision does not displace those treaty frameworks, but they interact with it in ways that benefit from local analysis.

For firms with existing matters or at the contract-review stage, this decision warrants specific attention to: (a) whether the arbitration clause carries its own governing-law designation; (b) whether the designated institution is identified with sufficient precision under Russian court standards; and (c) whether parallel Russian proceedings are a live risk that local counsel should be monitoring.

The firm's Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice regularly advises foreign law firms on the Russian elements of cross-border matters, including assessment of arbitration clause enforceability, coordination of parallel proceedings, and appearances before Russian arbitrazh courts. Further analysis of Russian Supreme Court guidance on arbitration agreements is available at Russian Supreme Court Clarification on Arbitration Agreements, and a broader practical guide to navigating arbitration clauses in Russian-law contracts is available at Navigating Arbitration Clauses Governed by Russian Law.

For firms advising clients with Russian arbitration clause exposure — whether at the drafting stage or in live proceedings — the firm welcomes enquiries from foreign counsel seeking local Russian analysis. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The decision consolidates — rather than creates — a default rule that Russian courts will apply Russian law to assess the validity and enforceability of an arbitration clause in a contract whose main governing law is Russian, absent a separate governing-law designation for the clause. Prior decisions were inconsistent on this point. The practical change is in the degree of certainty: foreign counsel and their clients can now proceed on the basis that Russian law applies to the arbitration agreement by default under a Russian-law contract, and should address that position expressly — at the drafting stage or in live proceedings — rather than assuming the separability principle insulates the clause from Russian law scrutiny.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Contracts at the drafting stage should include a governing-law designation specific to the arbitration clause if the parties intend the clause to be governed by a law other than Russian law. For existing contracts where the governing law of the arbitration clause is unspecified, foreign counsel should obtain a local Russian analysis of the clause's enforceability under Russian law standards before any dispute arises. Where proceedings in Russian courts are already under way or anticipated, instructing local counsel to assess the clause and, if necessary, to resist jurisdiction or enforce the arbitration agreement before the arbitrazh court is the recommended first step. Contact the firm's disputes team to discuss: info@vetrovpartners.com.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry