Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Recent Russian judicial practice on corporate disputes in Russian commercial courts — commentary

Vitaliy Vetrov · September 2026 · 7 min read

Russian commercial courts are reshaping corporate dispute resolution for foreign parties. Key rulings for instructing counsel. Make an enquiry.

Advising a foreign client with a live corporate dispute before a Russian commercial court has never been a straightforward instruction. In recent periods, however, the pattern of rulings emerging from Russian arbitrazh courts — the specialist commercial courts with exclusive jurisdiction over corporate disputes — has shifted in ways that practitioners instructing local Russian counsel need to understand before the claim is filed, not after the first hearing.

Background

Russian commercial courts have jurisdiction over a defined category of corporate disputes: disagreements concerning the formation, reorganisation, and liquidation of companies; disputes between shareholders and between shareholders and directors; challenges to resolutions of corporate bodies; and claims arising from the exercise of corporate rights more broadly. This is an exclusive jurisdiction, meaning that the ordinary civil courts play no role, and arbitration clauses in corporate agreements do not displace it — Russian law does not permit most corporate disputes to be referred to arbitration, including the institutional arbitration centres that foreign parties commonly use for commercial contracts.

The disputes examined in this commentary arose in the context of foreign shareholding structures: joint ventures between Russian and foreign co-investors, subsidiaries of foreign groups operating through Russian legal entities, and minority shareholding positions held by foreign institutional participants. In each context, the corporate dispute reached the Russian commercial court system. The central legal questions were ones that arise frequently in cross-border litigation in Russia: the scope of a minority shareholder's procedural rights in challenging a general meeting resolution; the standard applied to director liability claims brought by a foreign-nominated shareholder; and the interaction between Russian corporate law obligations and the terms of a shareholders' agreement governed by a foreign law.

These questions are not abstract. For a foreign law firm instructing Russian counsel, understanding how Russian commercial courts have approached each of them in recent practice is directly relevant to case strategy, the realistic assessment of prospects, and the structuring of client advice.

The decision

The most significant pattern to emerge from recent Russian commercial court practice in this area concerns the standing of minority shareholders to bring derivative and challenge claims. Russian courts have, over the course of recent years, applied a notably demanding threshold to procedural standing — requiring that the claimant shareholder demonstrate not only a qualifying shareholding percentage but also a direct link between the challenged corporate act and the diminution of the shareholder's rights in a concrete, not merely theoretical, sense. Courts have declined to treat the breach of corporate procedure in convening a meeting as automatically sufficient to ground a challenge; they have required evidence that the procedural defect materially affected the outcome.

This approach has material consequences for foreign minority shareholders in Russian joint ventures who discover, after the fact, that a significant decision — the approval of a related-party transaction, a dividend waiver, or a change to the charter — was taken at a meeting to which they received inadequate notice or from which they were effectively excluded. The availability of a challenge in the Russian commercial court is not simply a function of the procedural defect; it turns on what the court is persuaded the shareholder would have done differently, and whether that difference would have altered the result.

"

If you are instructing or co-counselling on a Russian corporate dispute involving a foreign shareholder, an early procedural review is essential before the limitation clock runs. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

On director liability, recent arbitrazh court practice has clarified the standard applied to claims brought against directors whose appointment was nominated or influenced by a foreign shareholder. The courts have applied a business judgement-style analysis that, while nominally protective of honest directors, places significant evidentiary demands on the claimant at the pleading stage. A director liability claim that would proceed to disclosure in an English court on a relatively low threshold must, in the Russian commercial court, be supported at the point of filing with sufficient factual particulars to demonstrate bad faith, self-dealing, or gross negligence — courts have been increasingly unwilling to allow these claims to proceed as speculative pleadings, and have struck out under-particularised statements of claim.

The interaction between shareholders' agreements and Russian corporate law has also produced a consistent line of cases. Where a shareholders' agreement contains a governing law clause selecting a foreign law — English law and German law feature most commonly in the matters seen in practice — the Russian commercial court will enforce the Russian statutory corporate framework regardless. The court will not treat the shareholders' agreement as creating corporate obligations that override the mandatory norms of Russian corporate legislation. The consequence is that a foreign party who structured a joint venture on the basis that the shareholders' agreement would govern shareholder conduct may find that Russian law imposes different default outcomes where the agreement is silent, and that the Russian court applies those defaults without reference to what the parties might have expected under their chosen governing law.

"The Russian commercial courts have been consistent on one point: the shareholders' agreement does not displace Russian corporate law where the two conflict. Foreign counsel instructing local Russian lawyers need to build their strategy around that baseline, not against it." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

What this means for foreign clients

For foreign law firms advising clients with Russian corporate holdings, the practical implications of recent arbitrazh court practice fall into three areas.

The first is early procedural mapping. The standing threshold and the particularity requirements at the pleading stage mean that corporate claims before Russian commercial courts require a more developed factual record at instruction than many foreign litigation teams anticipate. Engaging local Russian counsel before the limitation period becomes urgent is not merely preferable — it is structurally necessary, because the preparation required to file a properly particularised and well-grounded claim takes longer than a standard commercial dispute. The limitation periods for corporate challenges are strict, and the courts do not extend them generously.

The second is the governing-law gap. Where a joint venture or shareholding structure was established under a shareholders' agreement subject to English or another European governing law, foreign counsel should not assume that the contractual framework will translate into Russian corporate rights. The mapping exercise — identifying which provisions of the shareholders' agreement have a corporate law equivalent in Russia, and which do not — is a specialist task, and the gaps frequently surprise clients whose transactional lawyers structured the deal without Russian corporate law input.

The third is the forum question. Exclusive Russian jurisdiction over corporate disputes is not a rule that can be contracted around. Foreign parties who discover a corporate dispute after the relationship has deteriorated cannot elect to bring the claim in a more familiar forum. This is not a limitation on counsel's options; it is the starting point for any strategic analysis of a corporate dispute with a Russian dimension.

For practitioners instructing local Russian counsel, all three of these points inform what a meaningful pre-litigation instruction looks like. The role of Russian counsel in cross-border corporate disputes is not merely to appear in the arbitrazh court; it includes the early-stage advice on whether a claim is structurally viable under Russian procedural rules before a foreign client commits to the cost of proceedings.

Firms advising clients with Russian corporate holdings who need confirmed local counsel for a cross-border corporate dispute are welcome to make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change about corporate disputes in Russian commercial courts?

A: Recent Russian commercial court practice has tightened the conditions under which corporate claims can be advanced. The standing threshold for minority shareholder challenges is now applied with greater rigour, requiring concrete evidence of how the procedural defect affected the outcome rather than the mere existence of an irregularity. Director liability claims face higher pleading standards at the point of filing. And the courts have reaffirmed that Russian corporate law governs corporate relationships regardless of the governing law chosen in a shareholders' agreement. Together, these developments mean that corporate disputes involving foreign shareholders require more thorough pre-litigation preparation than was previously standard.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign companies and their advisers should begin by auditing the gap between their shareholders' agreements and the Russian corporate law baseline — particularly in joint ventures where the contractual framework was designed under a foreign governing law. Where a corporate dispute is anticipated or has already arisen, local Russian counsel should be engaged as early as possible, before the limitation periods become live constraints. The pleading requirements before Russian commercial courts favour claimants who have assembled a detailed factual record at the outset. Instructing Russian counsel at the strategic planning stage — not just at the point of filing — is the single most effective way to protect a foreign client's position in these proceedings.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry