Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Case comment: choice-of-law issues in cross-border contracts with Russian parties

Vitaliy Vetrov · March 2026 · 7 min read

Russian courts apply strict tests when parties dispute which law governs their contract. What in-house and foreign counsel need to know. Make an enquiry.

Practitioners advising on cross-border contracts with Russian counterparties frequently assume that a clearly drafted choice-of-law clause will be respected without difficulty by Russian courts. A recent decision by a Russian commercial appellate court – one of several in an emerging line – demonstrates that this assumption requires careful qualification. The ruling is instructive both for what it decided and for the reasoning the court deployed to reach that conclusion, particularly in proceedings where one party sought to override an express contractual choice of governing law on the basis of mandatory rules of Russian private international law.

Background

The matter involved a dispute between a foreign commercial counterparty and a Russian entity arising out of a long-term supply contract. The contract contained an express choice-of-law clause designating the law of a Western European jurisdiction as the governing law of the agreement. Proceedings were commenced in a Russian arbitrazh court after the Russian party unilaterally sought to have certain provisions of the contract characterised as void under Russian law, irrespective of the parties' express contractual choice.

The central question before the court was whether the designated foreign law applied to the disputed provisions, or whether Russian law applied by virtue of the mandatory rules embedded in the Russian conflict-of-laws framework. The Russian party argued that specific provisions of the contract – those touching on the formation and validity of certain obligations – were governed by Russian law as the law of the place where the Russian party's principal place of business was situated, and that this connection overrode the parties' express selection.

The matter reached the appellate level after the first-instance court found in favour of the Russian party on the mandatory rules point, declining to apply the foreign governing law to those provisions. The foreign counterparty appealed, contending that the lower court had misapplied the applicable conflict-of-laws analysis and had failed to engage properly with the question of whether the provisions at issue fell within the scope of Russian mandatory rules at all.

For foreign law firms instructing local counsel in Russian proceedings of this nature – make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

The decision

The appellate court partially upheld the appeal. It confirmed, first, that Russian private international law gives full legal effect to an express choice-of-law agreement between commercial parties, and that the threshold for displacing such a choice on mandatory rules grounds is deliberately high. The court noted that not every provision of Russian contract law qualifies as a mandatory rule in the conflict-of-laws sense: the mandatory character of a norm must be derived from its explicit terms or from the character and purpose of the provision in its regulatory context, not assumed from the fact that the norm cannot be excluded by agreement between parties in a purely domestic Russian contract.

On this reasoning, the appellate court found that the first-instance court had erred in treating a standard Russian law provision on contractual formation as a mandatory rule capable of displacing the parties' choice of foreign governing law. The provision in question, the court held, reflected a default position of Russian contract law that operated in the absence of contrary agreement – it was not a norm of the type that the Russian conflict-of-laws framework preserves irrespective of the parties' expressed intention.

The court also addressed the question of scope: even accepting that certain provisions of Russian law did qualify as mandatory rules, those rules applied only to the specific aspects of the contract falling within their subject-matter scope. They did not, in the court's analysis, transform the governing law of the contract as a whole. This point – the limited, clause-specific operation of mandatory rule overrides – is the most practically significant element of the ruling for foreign counsel advising on cross-border contracts with Russian parties.

The court accordingly applied the designated foreign law to the principal disputed provisions, whilst confirming that a small sub-set of formation requirements remained subject to Russian law as mandatory rules. The outcome was, in practical terms, a qualified vindication for the foreign counterparty, though one that illustrates how granular this analysis becomes in proceedings before Russian courts.

"The Russian appellate courts are refining the mandatory rules doctrine with greater precision than many foreign practitioners expect – a development that creates both risk and opportunity for parties with express choice-of-law clauses in their contracts." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

If you are instructing Russian lawyers in proceedings involving choice-of-law issues in cross-border contracts, or advising a foreign company in a dispute with a Russian party – make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For foreign law firms with clients exposed to Russian proceedings, this ruling reinforces several points that are easy to overlook when drafting or reviewing cross-border contracts with Russian counterparties. The enforceability of a choice-of-law clause before a Russian court is not binary: Russian conflict-of-laws analysis admits of a mandatory rules carve-out that can, when invoked, fragment the governing law of a single contract across different legal systems for different issues. Understanding where those carve-outs apply – and, critically, where they do not – requires familiarity with the current state of Russian appellate and cassation-level treatment of the mandatory rules doctrine.

The ruling also highlights a procedural dimension that matters for counsel co-ordinating cross-border proceedings. When a Russian court is asked to apply foreign law, it expects the party asserting that law to establish its content – through expert evidence or certified translations of relevant norms. Inadequate pleading of foreign law content remains one of the more common grounds on which Russian courts decline to apply designated foreign governing law in practice, irrespective of the theoretical validity of the choice. This gap between theoretical entitlement and practical enforcement is precisely the terrain on which experienced local counsel in Russia adds operational value to a foreign firm's instruction.

Foreign counsel advising clients on contract negotiation should also note that the risk is not symmetric. A Russian counterparty that anticipates litigation in Russian courts may have an interest in seeking to invoke mandatory rules precisely as the Russian party did here – as a mechanism for displacing agreed foreign governing law on commercially significant provisions. Drafting that anticipates this tactic – through jurisdiction clauses, arbitration agreements, or specific mandatory rules carve-out language reviewed against the current Russian conflict-of-laws framework – is considerably more effective when conducted before a dispute arises than when contested in proceedings. The firm's cross-border disputes practice [/practices/cross-border-disputes/] advises on both the litigation and the drafting angles.

For further analysis on how Russian courts have approached the governing law question across related contexts, see Russian Supreme Court clarification on choice of law and Navigating choice-of-law issues in cross-border contracts. A broader overview of the firm's experience acting in cross-border commercial matters is available at /matters/.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The decision refines the boundary between the parties' freedom to select a governing law and the mandatory rules exception under Russian private international law. Before this line of authority, first-instance courts in some circuits treated a wider range of Russian contract law provisions as mandatory rules capable of displacing an express choice of foreign law. The ruling makes clear that the mandatory character of a norm must be positively established from its text and purpose – it cannot be assumed from the fact that the provision is non-derogable in a purely domestic context. For foreign parties, this raises the analytical bar that a Russian counterparty must clear to succeed in a mandatory rules argument, though it does not eliminate the risk where genuinely mandatory norms are engaged.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign companies and their advisers should treat choice-of-law clauses in contracts with Russian parties as requiring Russian-law due diligence, not merely drafting precision in the chosen foreign law. This means identifying, before the contract is signed, which provisions are most likely to attract a mandatory rules argument in Russian proceedings, and assessing whether any Russian-law formation or validity requirements apply regardless of the chosen governing law. Where an arbitration clause is available as an alternative to Russian court jurisdiction, the interaction between the arbitral seat's conflict-of-laws rules and Russian mandatory rules should be separately mapped. For firms instructing Russian lawyers on these matters, early coordination on the Russian conflict-of-laws analysis – before proceedings are issued – is consistently more effective than attempting to reconstruct that analysis under procedural pressure. Make an enquiry with the team at info@vetrovpartners.com to discuss the specific contract or proceedings at hand.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry