Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Cassation review of recognition of MKAS and RAC awards abroad: a critical analysis

Vitaliy Vetrov · June 2026 · 9 min read

Russian cassation courts are reshaping MKAS and RAC award recognition abroad. What foreign counsel instructing in Russia needs to know. Make an enquiry.

In advising foreign law firms that instruct Russian counsel on enforcement mandates, one issue has become structurally more significant in recent practice: the effect of Russian cassation proceedings on the downstream recognition of MKAS and RAC awards in foreign jurisdictions. A Russian arbitrazh court's decision to grant or deny recognition and enforcement of an award issued by the International Commercial Arbitration Court (MKAS) or the Russian Arbitration Centre (RAC) does not mark the end of the road. That decision is itself subject to cassation review — and the outcome of cassation can materially alter the standing of the award before a foreign court operating under the New York Convention framework.

Background

The question arises most acutely when a party that has obtained an award from MKAS or the RAC — both of which are permanent arbitral institutions seated in Moscow — seeks to enforce it outside Russia in jurisdictions that are contracting states to the 1958 New York Convention. Under that framework, a foreign court asked to recognise the award may refuse enforcement if the award has been set aside or suspended by a competent authority of the country in which, or under the law of which, the award was made. This is the provision that gives Russian cassation proceedings their international significance.

The procedural context is as follows. An award creditor obtains a Russian arbitrazh court order granting recognition and enforcement. The losing party challenges that order through the cassation track: first to the relevant federal arbitrazh cassation court, and — in appropriate circumstances — on second cassation to the Judicial Chamber for Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. If a cassation court quashes or varies the original recognition order, the award's status changes. A foreign court must then consider whether the variation at cassation stage constitutes a "setting aside" or "suspension" for the purposes of the Convention — a question on which judicial practice across enforcing jurisdictions is not uniform.

A further complication arises when the cassation court remits the matter back for fresh consideration by the court of first instance, without itself resolving the substantive challenge. In that scenario, the award sits in procedural limbo: the original recognition order no longer stands, but the award has not been definitively set aside. Foreign courts have treated this situation differently, with some jurisdictions proceeding to enforce the award on the basis that suspension pending retrial is not equivalent to annulment, whilst others have stayed their own enforcement proceedings pending the outcome of the Russian retrial.

The decision

In a set of rulings considered by Russian cassation courts during 2026, the circuit cassation courts — and in at least one instance the Supreme Court on second cassation — addressed the evidentiary and procedural standards applicable when a lower arbitrazh court reviews recognition of an MKAS or RAC award that is contested on public policy grounds. The central holding that emerges from this line of authority is that a cassation court's role is not to re-examine the merits of the underlying dispute or the substantive correctness of the award, but to verify that the recognition procedure was conducted in accordance with the applicable procedural rules and that the public policy assessment was applied at the correct threshold.

This is significant for two reasons. First, it consolidates a standard under which cassation review operates as a procedural rather than substantive check. An award creditor facing cassation challenge by an award debtor who invokes public policy objections can take some analytical comfort from a framework that confines the cassation court to procedural verification. The public policy exception remains available, but cassation does not create a fresh avenue for relitigating the arbitral outcome on its merits. Second — and this is where the cross-border dimension becomes critical — the characterisation of cassation as procedural rather than substantive affects how the resulting cassation decision should be presented to a foreign court assessing the award's status under the New York Convention.

"[Quote text]" — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

"The practical consequence for foreign counsel is that the framing of Russian cassation decisions matters enormously in downstream enforcement proceedings: a cassation ruling that confirms the recognition order on procedural grounds is not equivalent to a merits endorsement of the award, and foreign courts should be assisted to understand that distinction." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

Where cassation proceedings concluded with the recognition order upheld, the award creditor's position in foreign enforcement proceedings is strengthened: the award has passed through two levels of Russian judicial scrutiny without being disturbed. Where cassation resulted in remittal, the challenge for foreign counsel is more complex — they must characterise the procedural position to the enforcing court accurately, without overstating finality and without conceding that the award is suspended in the Convention sense unless the Russian court has expressly ordered suspension.

For law firms advising award creditors or debtors with Russian cross-border enforcement issues, it is worth confirming the current cassation status of any Russian recognition order before commencing or opposing proceedings abroad. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign counsel instructing in Russia

For a foreign law firm managing cross-border litigation Russia — whether as lead counsel in the enforcing jurisdiction or as supervising counsel coordinating Russian proceedings — the cassation review track creates a set of specific practical concerns that affect case strategy from the outset.

The first is timing. Russian cassation proceedings at circuit level are typically initiated within a two-month window from the date the challenged decision takes effect, with the Supreme Court second cassation track available within a further defined period thereafter. An award creditor who does not account for this window when calculating the overall enforcement timeline risks presenting a foreign court with a recognition order that is subsequently varied on cassation — a scenario that can require urgent procedural steps in the enforcing jurisdiction to stay or revisit enforcement proceedings already commenced.

The second concerns the evidential presentation in foreign proceedings. A foreign court asked to enforce a MKAS award or a RAC award will typically require evidence of the current status of the Russian recognition decision. A certificate or court order confirming that no cassation appeal has been lodged, or that cassation proceedings have been concluded without disturbing the recognition order, is materially different in legal effect from a certificate that merely records that the recognition order was originally granted. Russian counsel — instructed as local counsel Russia — should be in a position to advise on the precise status at each stage and to provide documentary evidence suitable for use in the foreign forum.

The third consideration concerns parallel proceedings risk. Where an award debtor has lodged a cassation challenge in Russia contemporaneously with the award creditor commencing foreign recognition proceedings, both sets of proceedings are live simultaneously. Co-ordinating the conduct of Russian cassation defence with the management of foreign enforcement — to ensure that concessions or procedural positions taken in one forum do not prejudice the other — requires integrated case management between the foreign lead counsel and Russian counsel. This is one of the more practically demanding aspects of instructing Russian lawyers in a cross-border enforcement context, and it is an area where early coordination between instructing foreign firm and Russian counsel Russia is essential.

The position is broadly similar whether the award originates from MKAS or the RAC, though practitioners should note that the two institutions have modestly different procedural cultures and that the grounds most commonly advanced in cassation proceedings against recognition orders may reflect those differences. In practice, the volume of MKAS awards that have moved through the Russian recognition track is significantly larger than the corresponding volume of RAC awards, given the RAC's more recent establishment. This means that the body of cassation case law directly addressing RAC awards is still developing, and there is correspondingly more interpretive uncertainty at the margins.

For further context on how Russian courts approach recognition of MKAS and RAC awards at first instance, see How Russian courts approach recognition of MKAS and RAC awards and the related analysis in Supreme Court enforcement trends: recognition of Russian arbitral awards. Both articles are part of the firm's Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice resource, alongside the broader Matters Hub for anonymised case references.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for parties enforcing MKAS and RAC awards in foreign jurisdictions?

A: The most significant change is the consolidation of cassation review as a procedural, not merits-based, check on recognition decisions. For award creditors, this means that a cassation challenge by the award debtor does not reopen the substance of the arbitral decision before a Russian court. The practical consequence for cross-border enforcement is that a recognition order upheld on cassation — without substantive variation — should be presented to the foreign enforcing court as one that has survived a defined and procedurally bounded level of judicial scrutiny. Foreign counsel should ensure they obtain current-status evidence from Russian local counsel before commencing or advancing foreign enforcement proceedings, particularly where the cassation window is still open or proceedings are pending.

Q: What should foreign companies and their advisers do in light of this line of decisions?

A: The immediate practical step is to confirm, with the assistance of Russian counsel, whether any Russian recognition order that is intended to serve as the basis for foreign enforcement has reached procedural finality — meaning that the cassation window has closed without challenge, or that cassation proceedings have concluded without disturbing the order. Where cassation proceedings are pending or where the order has been remitted for retrial, foreign counsel should assess whether the enforcing court in the target jurisdiction treats a remittal as a suspension for New York Convention purposes, and adjust litigation strategy accordingly. Early engagement between the lead foreign firm and instructed Russian counsel is the single most effective means of managing the timing and evidential risks that the cassation track creates.

If your firm is coordinating enforcement of a MKAS or RAC award and needs to understand the current status of Russian proceedings, the team at Vetrov & Partners can advise directly. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com | Vetrov & Partners is a Russian boutique law firm established in 2009. The firm is recognised by Pravo-300 – Russia's principal legal directory – for eight consecutive years, and is listed as a trusted adviser by the German Consulate General in Novosibirsk.

The firm's Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice advises foreign companies, institutional creditors, and international law firms on MKAS and RAC proceedings, recognition and enforcement of Russian arbitral awards, and cross-border enforcement coordination. With over 1,000 matters handled since inception, the team combines direct partner involvement on every engagement with the practical advantage of a Siberian base — providing morning overlap with Asia-Pacific counterparts and afternoon overlap with European firms, alongside competitive fee structures and independence from Moscow-centred institutional relationships.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry