Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Russian arbitrazh court on enforcement of foreign arbitral awards in Russia under Article 248 of the Arbitration Procedure Code: key takeaways

Vitaliy Vetrov · September 2026 · 7 min read

Arbitrazh courts apply Article 248 APC to challenge enforcement of foreign awards in Russia. What foreign counsel needs to understand. Make an enquiry.

Among practitioners who advise foreign parties with Russian enforcement exposure, the expanding use of Article 248 of the Arbitration Procedure Code by Russian arbitrazh courts has drawn sustained attention. In a series of rulings handed down over recent years, Russian courts have applied this provision — which defines the exclusive jurisdiction of Russian arbitrazh courts — to challenge and, in some instances, suspend enforcement proceedings for foreign arbitral awards. The decisions carry material implications for foreign law firms instructing Russian counsel on cross-border enforcement matters and for parties holding ICC, LCIA, or other institutional awards against Russian respondents.

Background: what did the arbitrazh court consider?

The proceedings at issue arose from an application by a foreign claimant to recognise and enforce a foreign arbitral award against a Russian commercial entity. The award had been rendered by an internationally recognised arbitral institution following a multi-year commercial dispute. The Russian respondent, rather than contesting the award on the procedural grounds available under Russian civil procedure — such as manifest violation of procedural fairness or non-arbitrability of the subject matter — invoked Article 248 of the Arbitration Procedure Code as a basis for Russian court jurisdiction over the underlying dispute, and sought to have the enforcement application stayed or dismissed on that foundation.

Russian arbitrazh courts have jurisdiction to consider recognition and enforcement applications under the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, to which Russia is a party, and under the domestic framework for enforcement of foreign decisions. The question before the court was whether Article 248, which enumerates categories of disputes falling within the exclusive competence of Russian arbitrazh courts regardless of any arbitration clause or choice-of-court agreement, could override the arbitration agreement and provide grounds to refuse recognition. In this matter, the first instance court and the appellate court reached divergent conclusions before the cassation court issued a clarifying determination.

The decision: how did the court interpret Article 248 APC?

The cassation court held that Article 248 of the Arbitration Procedure Code does not automatically constitute a freestanding ground to refuse recognition of a foreign arbitral award under the New York Convention framework. In reaching this conclusion, the court distinguished between disputes that fall within the exclusive domestic jurisdiction provisions — which, in the court's framing, operate prospectively to confer competence over new proceedings — and the separate procedural question of whether a completed foreign arbitration award may be refused recognition at the enforcement stage. The court noted that refusal of recognition requires satisfaction of the grounds enumerated under the applicable convention and domestic recognition procedure, and that a bare invocation of Article 248 jurisdiction, without a corresponding finding that the award itself violates a specific mandatory rule of Russian procedural law or public policy, was insufficient.

That said, the cassation court's reasoning contained a significant qualification. Where a Russian arbitrazh court had already issued a ruling asserting exclusive jurisdiction over the underlying dispute — and had notified the foreign arbitral proceedings — the subsequently rendered award could, in the court's view, be subject to non-recognition on the basis that the arbitral tribunal had proceeded in disregard of a subsisting Russian court order. This qualification introduces a sequence-dependent element into the enforcement analysis that practitioners had not consistently applied in prior matters.

"The decision draws a line between Article 248 as a jurisdictional rule and Article 248 as a recognition defence — but the line depends on whether a Russian court order intervened before the award was rendered." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

The practical consequence is that the enforceability of a foreign award against a Russian respondent may now turn, in part, on whether the Russian party pursued a domestic jurisdiction claim during the arbitral proceedings and whether the Russian court acted on that claim in time. Awards rendered after a Russian court order asserting exclusive jurisdiction occupy a materially different position from awards rendered without any such intervening domestic proceeding.

If you are instructing Russian counsel on a foreign arbitral award enforcement matter — or if your client's counterparty has commenced Russian court proceedings alongside a foreign arbitration — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What does this ruling mean for foreign claimants?

For foreign law firms instructing Russian counsel, the ruling introduces a step that was previously treated as subsidiary into the mainstream enforcement analysis: the procedural history of the Russian respondent's domestic court filings during the arbitration. Before commencing an enforcement application in a Russian arbitrazh court, instructing counsel should now establish whether the Russian party filed — or threatened to file — a claim under Article 248 at any stage of the foreign proceedings, and whether a Russian court issued any order on that claim. This will typically require a targeted review of the Russian court register for proceedings involving the respondent entity during the arbitration period.

The ruling also reinforces a point that experienced cross-border practitioners recognise but that is not always communicated clearly to award-holding clients: enforcement of foreign arbitral awards in Russia under the New York Convention framework has never been mechanical. Russian courts retain grounds for refusal that, while nominally aligned with the Convention, have been interpreted with sufficient latitude to require careful procedural preparation at the recognition stage. The addition of the Article 248 qualification does not change the framework in its entirety, but it adds a documented sequence risk that now warrants explicit attention in any enforcement strategy for awards against Russian entities.

For matters involving parties from EAEU or CIS member states, separate bilateral and multilateral treaty frameworks may apply alongside or instead of the New York Convention, and the interaction of those frameworks with Article 248 jurisdiction claims has not been uniformly resolved across Russian circuits. In practice, the Siberian and Ural circuits, where Vetrov & Partners regularly acts in recognition proceedings, have applied the cassation court's reasoning with varying degrees of consistency, which underscores the importance of local procedural knowledge in selecting and managing the enforcement forum.

Vetrov & Partners acts in enforcement and recognition proceedings in Siberian and Ural circuit arbitrazh courts. To discuss an enforcement strategy for a foreign arbitral award — including assessing Article 248 exposure — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The ruling clarifies that Article 248 of the Arbitration Procedure Code does not, of itself, constitute an independent ground to refuse recognition of a foreign arbitral award. However, it establishes that where a Russian arbitrazh court has issued an order asserting exclusive jurisdiction over the underlying dispute before the award was rendered — and the arbitral tribunal proceeded regardless — the award may be refused recognition on the basis that it was made in disregard of that court order. The practical change is that the enforcement risk attached to Article 248 is now sequence-dependent: it crystallises only where a Russian court order was in place during the arbitration. For practitioners, this makes the procedural history of Russian domestic court filings by the respondent a standard due diligence step before commencing an enforcement application.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign award-holders and their counsel should, before commencing enforcement proceedings in a Russian arbitrazh court, conduct a targeted review of the Russian court register to establish whether the respondent entity commenced Article 248 jurisdiction proceedings during the arbitration and whether any Russian court order was issued. Where no such order exists, the Article 248 risk is materially lower. Where an order was issued, enforcement counsel will need to address that order directly in the recognition application — including any argument that the arbitral tribunal gave proper consideration to the Russian court's claim of exclusive jurisdiction. Early instruction of Russian counsel with direct experience of recognition proceedings in the relevant circuit is advisable, given the variation in how different arbitrazh circuits have applied this reasoning.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry