Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Russian arbitrazh court on ICC arbitration in Russia-related commercial disputes in the agriculture sector: key takeaways

Vitaliy Vetrov · March 2026 · 6 min read

Russian arbitrazh courts scrutinise ICC clauses in agriculture supply contracts. Key takeaways for foreign counsel and clients. Make an enquiry.

In advising foreign law firms and their agri-business clients on cross-border litigation in Russia, one pattern emerges with notable consistency: counsel who have drafted an ICC arbitration clause into a Russia-related agriculture supply contract frequently assume that Russian arbitrazh courts will respect that clause without question. Russian judicial practice, however, has demonstrated a more textured response — particularly where the underlying dispute engages Russian mandatory regulatory norms, such as phytosanitary certification requirements, grain quality standards, or export licensing obligations. Understanding where Russian courts have drawn jurisdictional boundaries, and why, is now a material part of advising on ICC arbitration in Russia-related commercial disputes in the agriculture sector.

Background

Agriculture supply contracts between foreign buyers and Russian producers or exporters routinely contain ICC arbitration clauses designating Paris, Geneva, or a neutral third-country seat. These arrangements reflect standard international trade practice. Where they become procedurally complex is when a Russian counterparty commences parallel proceedings before a Russian arbitrazh court — whether in the form of a claim on the merits, an application to invalidate the contract, or a challenge to the enforceability of the arbitration clause itself.

The legal question that arises in these proceedings has two components. First, does the arbitrazh court have jurisdiction to hear a matter covered by an ICC clause, and if so, on what doctrinal basis? Second, does the subject matter of the agriculture dispute engage any category of exclusive Russian jurisdiction or mandatory law that would, as a matter of Russian procedural law, override the parties' choice of forum?

In the set of proceedings this commentary examines — arising from a supply dispute involving grain quality, contract non-performance, and an export licensing issue — a Russian counterparty sought declaratory relief before an arbitrazh court, arguing that the regulatory character of the dispute brought it within the exclusive competence of Russian state courts. The foreign party, which had already commenced ICC arbitration, applied to have the Russian proceedings stayed.

The decision

The arbitrazh court declined to stay the Russian proceedings. Its reasoning, as it has appeared in analogous matters within the body of Russian judicial practice, rested on two related propositions. First, the court characterised elements of the dispute as touching mandatory Russian regulatory norms — specifically the requirements governing grain quality certification and export licencing under the applicable Russian agricultural and customs regulatory framework. On the court's analysis, disputes with a sufficient nexus to Russian state regulatory requirements are not amenable to arbitration in the ordinary sense, because their resolution requires the application of norms that Russian public law designates as non-derogable.

Second, the court applied the principle, recognised in Russian civil procedure, that the exclusive jurisdiction provisions applicable to disputes involving Russian immovable property, state registration acts, and certain regulatory determinations extend, by analogy, to disputes where the regulatory determination is integral to the merits. The court did not accept that the ICC clause, as drafted, evidenced a sufficiently clear waiver of the right to challenge jurisdiction in Russian courts in proceedings of this regulatory character.

The foreign party's application to stay was accordingly dismissed, and the Russian proceedings continued alongside the ICC arbitration, creating a parallel-track situation with material risk of inconsistent outcomes.

"Where an agriculture supply dispute is recharacterised as turning on a Russian mandatory regulatory norm, the ICC clause alone will not protect a foreign party from parallel Russian court proceedings — early-stage analysis of the contract's regulatory exposure is essential." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

For counsel advising foreign agri-business clients on cross-border litigation in Russia, early identification of mandatory-law risk in the transaction structure is the critical variable. If you are assessing a matter in which an ICC clause and Russian regulatory exposure intersect, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What does this ruling mean for foreign parties in ICC proceedings?

For foreign law firms advising clients with Russia-related agriculture contracts, the practical implications of this line of Russian judicial reasoning are significant. The decision — consistent with an emerging approach in Russian arbitrazh court practice — signals that the presence of an ICC clause is, of itself, insufficient to preclude parallel state court proceedings where Russian regulatory law is engaged.

Several practical consequences follow. First, the contract drafting stage is materially more important than it may appear. An ICC clause that does not expressly address Russian regulatory overlay, or that leaves ambiguous whether the parties intend to arbitrate disputes touching certification, licensing, and quality-standard compliance, creates a gap that Russian courts have shown willingness to exploit. The scope of the arbitration clause — not merely its existence — determines the degree of jurisdictional protection.

Second, where Russian proceedings are already underway alongside an ICC arbitration, the foreign party must make tactical decisions quickly. Applying for anti-suit or interim relief in the ICC arbitration, and simultaneously seeking recognition of the arbitration clause's scope in the Russian forum, are not mutually exclusive steps — but they require coordination between ICC counsel and Russian-qualified local counsel from the outset. Delays in retaining Russian-qualified representation at this stage commonly result in default positions forming in the Russian proceedings that are difficult to unwind.

Third, the interaction between Russian agricultural export controls — which have expanded meaningfully over recent years — and ICC arbitration clauses in existing long-term supply contracts deserves systematic review for foreign clients with ongoing Russian agricultural exposure. Contracts entered into before the relevant regulatory changes may not have anticipated the mandatory-law characterisation that Russian courts are now applying. See also our analysis of how Russian courts approach ICC arbitration more broadly at How Russian courts approach ICC arbitration and the related commentary on Roskomnadzor enforcement trends and ICC arbitration.

For a broader view of the procedural and strategic options available in Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration, including the firm's experience in matters before Russian arbitrazh courts and the MKAS, visit the practice page. A record of representative cross-border matters is maintained at Matters.

If you are instructing Russian counsel or considering how best to coordinate ICC and Russian state court proceedings in an agriculture-sector dispute, the firm is available for an initial 30-minute meeting — complimentary. Contact: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What changed in Russian arbitrazh court practice regarding ICC arbitration clauses in agriculture-sector contracts?

A: Russian arbitrazh courts have developed a line of reasoning — applied with increasing consistency in agriculture-related cross-border disputes — under which elements of a supply contract touching mandatory Russian regulatory norms, such as grain quality certification, phytosanitary requirements, or export licensing, may be characterised as outside the scope of a standard ICC arbitration clause. This characterisation can result in the court declining to stay its own proceedings, even where a valid ICC clause exists, on the basis that the regulatory subject matter falls within mandatory Russian court jurisdiction. The practical consequence is that foreign parties with an active ICC arbitration may face parallel Russian proceedings that cannot be halted by reference to the clause alone.

Q: What should foreign companies and their counsel do in light of this line of Russian judicial reasoning?

A: Three immediate steps are advisable for foreign counsel instructing on Russia-related agriculture matters. First, review existing ICC clauses for scope: a narrowly drafted clause that does not explicitly capture regulatory disputes creates exposure. Second, assess the current regulatory overlay on the contract — has Russian export control, certification, or quality-standard regulation expanded since the contract was executed? If so, the mandatory-law risk profile of the contract has likely changed. Third, ensure that Russian-qualified local counsel is engaged at the earliest opportunity, particularly if Russian proceedings have been initiated or threatened. Coordinating ICC strategy and Russian state court strategy from separate instruction chains — without a single Russian-qualified contact point — is one of the more common procedural errors the firm observes in cross-border agriculture matters.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry