Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Case comment: witness evidence collection in Russia for international arbitration in the transport and logistics sector

Vitaliy Vetrov · June 2026 · 7 min read

Russian courts tightened witness evidence collection in transport disputes for arbitration. Key points for foreign counsel. Make an enquiry.

In advising foreign counsel on Russian arbitration proceedings over recent years, one recurring difficulty stands out: the gap between how witness evidence is expected to function in international arbitration and how Russian courts and procedural rules approach the collection of that evidence on the ground. A recent cassation-level ruling in a dispute arising from a cross-border transport contract has sharpened the contours of that gap in ways that foreign counsel instructing Russian counsel on logistics and forwarding matters should understand before proceedings are under way.

Background

The underlying dispute arose from a contract for the cross-border carriage of cargo between a foreign principal and a Russian forwarding intermediary. Performance broke down at the delivery stage, and the foreign principal initiated international arbitration proceedings. To support its claim, the claimant sought to rely on witness testimony from individuals located in Russia – employees and agents of the Russian counterparty who had direct knowledge of events at the relevant warehousing and customs clearance stages.

Russian procedural law draws a clear distinction between the collection of evidence through a Russian state court – which requires a formal application to the arbitrazh court and engagement with Russia's own rules on witness examination – and the taking of witness statements by party representatives outside any court process. The latter, familiar to practitioners in common law jurisdictions, does not carry the same default procedural authority in Russia. Witnesses located in Russia cannot ordinarily be compelled to appear before an arbitral tribunal seated outside Russia, and their voluntary participation in written statement procedures depends entirely on their own cooperation.

The ruling under discussion arose when the claimant, having failed to secure voluntary cooperation from the relevant witnesses, sought the assistance of a Russian arbitrazh court to compel witness examination in support of the international arbitration. The court's response at first instance, on appeal, and ultimately on cassation review clarified the procedural conditions under which such assistance is – and is not – available.

If you are instructing Russian counsel in a transport or logistics arbitration where witness evidence located in Russia is a live issue, contact Vitaliy Vetrov to discuss the procedural options before the evidential window closes — info@vetrovpartners.com |

The decision

The cassation court affirmed that Russian arbitrazh courts retain jurisdiction to provide judicial assistance to international arbitral proceedings, but only within carefully defined limits. Assistance is contingent on the arbitral proceedings themselves meeting the court's threshold requirements: the arbitral institution must be one recognised under Russian law, the subject matter must fall within the scope of disputes that Russian law permits to be resolved by arbitration, and the application must be lodged before the evidentiary phase of the arbitral proceedings has formally closed.

In the transport sector specifically, the court's analysis was informed by the character of the evidence sought. Documentary records held by freight forwarders, customs brokers, and warehouse operators in Russia are subject to their own regulatory retention and disclosure obligations – and the court noted that the procedural route for compelling production of such records differs from the route for compelling oral witness examination. For the oral witnesses at issue, the court found that the procedural conditions for judicial assistance had not been satisfied: the application had been filed after the relevant procedural deadline, and the arbitral institution named in the application was not among those whose awards are routinely recognised by Russian courts in the prevailing period.

The cassation court declined to overturn the lower courts' refusals, leaving the claimant without court-assisted access to the witness testimony it needed.

"In transport and logistics disputes, the timing of the application for Russian court assistance is almost always the dispositive factor – by the time foreign counsel identifies the gap, the procedural window has often already closed." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

For a structured review of how your arbitration proceedings engage with Russian evidence-collection rules, request an initial consultation — info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign counsel and carriers

For a foreign law firm advising a client with a Russian counterparty in the transport or logistics chain, the ruling has three immediate practical implications.

First, the application for Russian court assistance must be made early – ideally before the arbitral proceedings have advanced past the first substantive hearing. The cassation court's confirmation that a post-deadline application will be refused as a matter of procedure, not discretion, removes any margin for a late-stage attempt. Counsel should map the procedural timetable of the arbitration against the Russian court's own procedural requirements at the outset of the matter, not as an afterthought.

Second, the choice of arbitral institution matters to the Russian court, not only to the parties. Where the arbitration agreement specifies an institution whose awards do not have a track record of recognition in Russian courts – whether through lack of registration, change in regulatory status, or otherwise – the Russian court's threshold analysis will likely present an additional obstacle. In the transport sector, where institutional choice is often left to standard contract terms, foreign counsel should review the position before proceedings commence.

Third, documentary evidence in the hands of Russian logistics operators is subject to a distinct procedural route from oral witness examination. Freight forwarders, customs agents, and warehousing companies in Russia operate under documentary retention obligations imposed by transport and customs regulation. An application targeted at records held by these entities – rather than personal witness examination – may face fewer procedural objections, but requires its own specifically drafted application to the arbitrazh court and a clear articulation of relevance.

Foreign counsel who wish to understand how the Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice at Vetrov & Partners approaches witness evidence collection in Russian proceedings may also find the following articles of use: the practice briefing on key risk points in witness evidence collection and the earlier legal update on court practice shifts in this area. For the broader landscape of cross-border matters the firm has handled, see the Matters page.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign counsel instructing Russian local counsel in transport arbitrations?

A: The ruling confirms that Russian courts will apply their procedural threshold criteria strictly when asked to assist with witness evidence collection for international arbitration. For transport and logistics matters specifically, the court's analysis makes clear that the timing of the application, the institutional identity of the arbitral body, and the precise character of the evidence sought – oral testimony versus documentary records – are each independently capable of defeating the application. Foreign counsel can no longer treat Russian court assistance as a fallback option to be invoked if other avenues fail; it must be built into the procedural plan from the outset. For firms advising carriers, freight forwarders, or cargo owners in cross-border disputes, the ruling also signals that the documentary evidence route – targeting regulatory records held by Russian logistics operators – merits separate and early analysis alongside any witness testimony strategy.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: The immediate step is to review any live or anticipated arbitration proceedings where witness evidence located in Russia may be relevant, and to assess whether the procedural conditions for Russian court assistance are currently satisfied or can still be met within the existing timetable. That review should address three points: whether the arbitral institution is one whose awards Russian courts are currently treating as recognisable; whether the application can be lodged before the evidentiary phase of the arbitration has formally closed; and whether a documentary-evidence route offers a more viable alternative to oral witness examination in the specific circumstances. Where the matter involves a Russian transport or logistics counterparty, the regulatory retention obligations imposed on freight forwarders, customs brokers, and warehouse operators may make the documentary route not only available but tactically preferable. Early coordination between foreign counsel and Russian counsel on these points is the critical practical step.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry