Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Russian arbitrazh court on arbitration clauses governed by Russian law at the appeal and cassation stage: key takeaways

Vitaliy Vetrov · October 2026 · 8 min read

Russian appeal courts scrutinise arbitration clauses governed by Russian law more rigorously. What foreign counsel should know. Make an enquiry.

In advising foreign law firms on Russian-seat and foreign-seat arbitrations over the past several years, one procedural dynamic has grown markedly more consequential: the willingness of Russian arbitrazh courts at the appeal and cassation stage to revisit the validity of arbitration clauses governed by Russian law, even where the first-instance court passed over the question without comment. The pattern is not uniform, and it does not arise in every dispute involving a Russian counterparty. But for foreign counsel instructing Russian litigation or enforcement support, it represents a material risk factor that repays careful analysis before any application is filed.

This note addresses recent arbitrazh court practice on this question, with particular attention to the appeal and cassation instances, and draws out the practical implications for foreign law firms managing cross-border mandates with a Russian dimension. It should be read alongside the firm's broader guidance on navigating arbitration clauses governed by Russian law and the Supreme Court's clarifications on arbitration procedure.

Background

Russian arbitrazh courts operate across three active tiers for most commercial disputes: the first-instance arbitrazh court, the appellate arbitrazh court (the apeliatsia), and the cassation court of the relevant circuit. A further cassation route exists via the Economic Chamber of the Russian Supreme Court in qualifying circumstances. Each tier has a defined scope of review, and the interplay between those scopes and the treatment of arbitration agreements becomes critical when a clause's validity is first contested late in proceedings.

The substantive backdrop is the separability principle: under Russian law, an arbitration clause is treated as a separate agreement from the main contract it forms part of. The invalidity, termination, or non-performance of the underlying contract does not, as a general rule, render the arbitration clause invalid. This doctrine is well-established in Russian arbitration law and is applied consistently at first instance. The complication arises when a party argues that the arbitration clause itself — not merely the main contract — is invalid, and that argument surfaces for the first time at appeal or cassation, rather than at the outset of proceedings.

Arbitration clauses governed by Russian law are subject to mandatory requirements that differ in some respects from equivalent requirements under English or German law, most notably in relation to certain categories of dispute that Russian law reserves for state court jurisdiction as a matter of public policy. Where a clause purports to submit such a category of dispute to arbitration — or where its drafting is ambiguous on the seat, the rules, or the scope — Russian appellate courts have, in a line of decisions over recent years, been prepared to treat the clause as a matter for independent examination, not simply as a question concluded at first instance.

The decision

The pattern examined here is not a single ruling but a documented tendency in arbitrazh appeal and cassation practice, drawn from the type of cases that recur in proceedings involving foreign claimants. In a representative category of these matters, the question before the appeal or cassation court was whether the arbitration clause in the commercial contract between the parties was valid and operative, where that clause was expressed to be governed by Russian law and had been invoked — or contested — by one party in the course of enforcement or recognition proceedings.

At the appeal stage, courts have generally treated clause validity as a question of law susceptible to fresh consideration, particularly where the lower court's analysis of the clause was summary or conclusory. This is consistent with the appellate court's general mandate: under Russian civil procedure rules applicable in arbitrazh proceedings, the appellate court reviews the matter on the law and on the facts within the scope of the appeal, and is not bound by the factual record in the same way as a cassation court. Where the clause was argued to fail on formal grounds — such as insufficient identification of the arbitral institution, ambiguity as to the applicable rules, or a scope limitation that excluded the actual dispute from arbitration — the appeal court has been willing to engage with those arguments substantively.

At the cassation stage, the court's formal mandate is narrower: it reviews questions of law, not the factual circumstances of the dispute. In practice, however, the classification of a clause's meaning as a question of construction — and construction as a question of law — has given cassation courts room to revisit arbitration clause analysis conducted below. This is particularly evident in cases where the first-instance and appellate courts reached different conclusions on the clause, or where one court treated the clause as valid without substantive reasoning and the other did not. The cassation court in such cases does not treat itself as bound by the lower court's resolution of what is framed as a legal question.

"At the cassation stage, what looks like a settled clause-validity question at first instance can be reopened as a matter of legal construction — and the outcome is not always predictable from the text alone." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

A consistent feature across this body of practice is the treatment of Russian public policy as a floor beneath which no arbitration clause — whatever its governing law — can validly operate. Where a dispute category falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of Russian state courts, an arbitration clause purporting to cover it has been set aside at both appeal and cassation regardless of whether the party raising the point did so at first instance. This is not a principle that foreign counsel can assume will be confined to enforcement proceedings: it has been applied in the context of recognition, stay applications, and anti-suit-adjacent procedural arguments in Russian courts.

If you are instructing Russian litigation or arbitration support and the validity of an arbitration clause governed by Russian law may become an issue at appeal or cassation, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

For foreign law firms managing mandates with a Russian counterparty or Russian-sited assets, this body of practice has three direct implications.

First, clause-validity risk is not extinguished by a first-instance outcome that does not address it. Where a Russian party has not raised the validity of an arbitration clause governed by Russian law at the initial stage of proceedings, that does not foreclose the point at appeal or — in matters engaging public policy — at cassation. Foreign counsel relying on a first-instance ruling that assumed the clause's validity without analysing it should treat that assumption as provisional, particularly if enforcement through Russian state courts is a foreseeable next step.

Second, the analysis of the clause needs to be done at the instruction stage, not after the first adverse procedural development. The firm's cross-border disputes practice sees this issue arise disproportionately in mandates where the foreign client instructed Russian counsel only once litigation had already begun in another jurisdiction. At that point, the Russian party may already have filed in the arbitrazh court, and the time for shaping the jurisdictional argument is narrower than it would have been at the outset. Identifying whether the clause is vulnerable — whether on formal, scope, or public-policy grounds — before any application is filed gives the advising firm a more complete picture of the risk profile.

Third, Russian courts' treatment of arbitration clauses governed by Russian law does not map neatly onto the way common-law courts approach equivalent clauses. The separability doctrine operates similarly in structure but yields different results in a number of categories — joint venture arrangements, certain real property disputes, IP assignments in certain configurations — where Russian law imposes mandatory jurisdictional requirements. For foreign counsel advising clients whose commercial contracts contain Russian-law-governed arbitration clauses and whose assets include Russian-sited property, this jurisdictional mapping is a necessary step before any enforcement or arbitral strategy is confirmed.

The firm has acted in matters before the Siberian and Ural circuit cassation courts in which arbitration clause validity was a live question, including matters where the clause's Russian-law governance interacted with a foreign seat. A summary of representative matters is available at /matters/.

Firms advising clients with Russian assets or Russian-counterparty disputes that involve an arbitration clause governed by Russian law are welcome to discuss a specific mandate in confidence — info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The practice documented here confirms that Russian appeal and cassation courts treat the validity of arbitration clauses governed by Russian law as a question of law that can be reopened at each tier of review, not merely as a factual finding concluded at first instance. For foreign counsel, the practical change is one of risk calibration: a clause that survived first-instance proceedings without challenge cannot safely be treated as settled for appeal, cassation, or enforcement purposes. Courts have applied this approach both where validity was contested below and where it was not — particularly in cases engaging Russian public policy on exclusive jurisdiction categories.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: The most effective response is pre-instruction clause review. Before any application is filed in a Russian arbitrazh court — whether in support of a foreign arbitration, in enforcement proceedings, or in response to a Russian party's first-instance filing — the arbitration clause should be assessed against Russian law requirements: formal validity, scope, identification of the arbitral institution, and compatibility with mandatory jurisdictional rules. Where the clause has weaknesses on any of those grounds, the litigation strategy should account for the realistic possibility that a Russian court will address them at appeal or cassation, regardless of what the lower court did. Instructing Russian counsel at the earliest stage — ideally before the foreign arbitral proceedings are commenced — materially improves the position.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry