Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Comparative analysis: arbitration clauses governed by Russian law and international standards

Vitaliy Vetrov · October 2026 · 17 min read

Arbitration clauses under Russian law diverge from international norms in key ways. What in-house counsel must know before drafting. Make an enquiry.

In the cross-border disputes practice, a pattern recurs with sufficient regularity to deserve systematic attention: foreign counsel inserts a well-tested international arbitration clause into a Russian-law contract, the clause passes internal legal review, and the parties proceed to sign — only for that clause to become the first contested point when a dispute arises. The clause may be valid under the law of its home jurisdiction, structurally unremarkable by ICC or LCIA standards, and yet substantively or procedurally deficient under the Russian legal framework that governs the underlying agreement. For in-house counsel at multinational companies with Russian counterparties, understanding where these divergences lie is not a theoretical exercise: it is the difference between an arbitration clause that functions as intended and one that produces preliminary litigation before the merits are ever reached.

What makes Russian arbitration clauses different from international precedents?

Russian arbitration law has undergone significant legislative development since the introduction of the federal legislation on arbitration and the federal legislation on international commercial arbitration, which modernised the framework that had governed domestic and cross-border arbitration for several decades. The amendments brought Russian arbitration law closer to the UNCITRAL Model Law in certain respects — recognising separability, allowing interim relief through state courts, and refining the grounds for setting aside awards. Yet the convergence is partial. In a number of areas that directly affect the drafting of arbitration agreements, Russian law imposes requirements that have no equivalent in standard ICC, LCIA, or AAA model clauses, and the consequences of non-compliance range from procedural complications to outright unenforceability.

The central divergence concerns the concept of arbitrability. Under Russian law, not all commercial disputes between parties to a contract governed by Russian law are capable of being referred to arbitration. Russian legislation excludes certain categories of dispute from arbitration — most significantly, corporate disputes involving participants in certain types of Russian legal entities, disputes connected to state registration, and matters where a Russian public authority is a necessary party. A foreign company negotiating an investment agreement, a shareholders' agreement, or a joint-venture charter with a Russian counterparty must verify the arbitrability of the specific dispute category before relying on an arbitration clause. A clause that covers disputes falling outside the permitted categories is not merely unenforceable in part: the affected proceedings may be dismissed, leaving the claimant to re-commence in a state arbitrazh court — a forum with substantially different procedural dynamics.

A second structural difference concerns the requirement that the arbitration institution be a permanently functioning arbitration institution (PFAI) with the authorisation of the relevant Russian governmental body, if the arbitration is to be seated in Russia. This requirement, which was introduced as part of the legislative reform, has no direct parallel in international arbitration practice. An ad hoc arbitration seated in Russia — other than in the form specifically contemplated by the legislation — faces significant enforceability risks, particularly at the enforcement stage before Russian state courts.

The Russian legal framework: what governs an arbitration agreement?

The validity and enforceability of an arbitration clause in a contract governed by Russian law is assessed primarily under Russian procedural legislation, the federal statute on arbitration, and the federal statute on international commercial arbitration (the latter governing international commercial arbitration matters). The substantive requirements for a valid arbitration agreement under Russian law map reasonably well onto the New York Convention framework — written form, agreement on a defined legal relationship, and mutual consent — but the procedural overlay is more demanding than international practitioners typically anticipate.

Form requirements deserve particular attention. Russian law, consistent with the New York Convention, requires an arbitration agreement to be in writing. The range of written forms recognised under Russian law has expanded — an exchange of electronic communications with confirmation, incorporation by reference to standard terms, and conduct of the parties in certain circumstances can satisfy the requirement. However, courts have approached these extended forms cautiously, and an explicit, well-drafted arbitration clause in the body of the agreement remains the only form that removes all doubt. In consumer contracts and in contracts with certain categories of counterparty, additional consent formalities apply.

The question of the governing law of the arbitration agreement itself — distinct from the governing law of the main contract — has been the subject of significant judicial attention in Russia, as in other jurisdictions. Russian courts have not adopted a uniform position analogous to the English law "three contract analysis", and the resolution of this question in any given case may depend on the drafting of the governing law clause, the choice of seat, and the institutional rules invoked. In-house counsel who leave the governing law of the arbitration clause unaddressed — as is common in contracts that simply state "governed by Russian law" — may find that this ambiguity is exploited at the jurisdiction challenge stage.

"The most costly mistake we see is the assumption that a clause which works in London or Geneva will work in a Russian-law contract without any adaptation. It rarely does, and the correction comes at the worst possible time."

— Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

For multinational companies managing Russian counterparty relationships, a cross-border disputes review of existing contract templates is typically the most cost-efficient first step before a dispute materialises.

For in-house counsel reviewing or updating a suite of Russian-law contracts, an early assessment of arbitration clause validity avoids the more significant cost of jurisdictional challenge at the dispute stage. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Where do international drafting templates break down under Russian law?

The failure modes of international arbitration templates applied to Russian-law contracts cluster around five identifiable problem areas. Each can be addressed at the drafting stage; each becomes substantially more expensive to address once a dispute has arisen.

The first concerns institutional designation. Many international templates designate an established foreign institution — ICC, LCIA, SIAC, AAA/ICDR — without specifying whether the seat is in the institution's home jurisdiction or elsewhere. When a Russian counterparty later contests jurisdiction, the Russian court will examine whether the designated institution qualifies as a PFAI under Russian law for a Russia-seated arbitration, whether the seat designation is valid under the agreement, and whether the clause is consistent with applicable Russian procedural rules. A clause that designates a foreign institution with an implicit assumption of a foreign seat, but which the claimant later attempts to enforce in Russia as a domestic award, creates avoidable complexity.

The second failure mode relates to language. Standard international clauses typically address the language of proceedings. Under the rules of most international institutions, this is uncontroversial. In practice, however, when enforcement of a foreign arbitral award is sought before Russian state courts, the translation and certification requirements for the award and the underlying arbitral record are prescriptive. A clause that is ambiguous about the language of the final award, or that assumes proceedings will be conducted in English without specifying this, adds a logistical layer to enforcement that could have been avoided.

The third and most consequential failure mode is arbitrability error of the type described above — incorporating a broad "all disputes arising out of or in connection with this agreement" formulation into a contract that includes dispute categories which are non-arbitrable under Russian law. Under Russian insolvency legislation and corporate law, a number of dispute types that appear to be purely contractual are characterised as corporate or public-interest disputes for jurisdictional purposes. Foreign creditors and shareholders have encountered this issue in the context of shareholder disputes and insolvency-related claims — areas where the boundary between arbitrable and non-arbitrable matters is less well-defined in Russian practice than in many comparable jurisdictions.

The fourth failure mode concerns the choice of interim relief mechanism. Standard international clauses often include emergency arbitrator provisions or rely on the institutional rules for interim measures. Under Russian law, interim relief in arbitral proceedings may require an application to the Russian state arbitrazh court — even where the arbitration is seated abroad — in circumstances where assets are located in Russia. A clause that does not address this coordination expressly, or that relies exclusively on the tribunal's own powers, may leave a gap in the interim relief framework that becomes apparent only when speed matters most.

A fifth area of divergence — of particular relevance to in-house counsel managing relationships with Russian state-owned or state-adjacent counterparties — concerns the immunity analysis. Russian state entities can and do participate in international commercial arbitration, but the framework for waiver of immunity in the arbitration agreement and the scope of that waiver at the enforcement stage require specific attention. A generic institutional clause is not sufficient.

Under Russian procedural legislation, failure to raise an arbitration clause as a ground for the court's rejection of a claim at the first available opportunity in state court proceedings may result in the right to rely on the clause being treated as waived. Foreign companies that receive a statement of claim in Russian arbitrazh proceedings and do not immediately invoke the arbitration agreement — whether through unfamiliarity with Russian procedure or because the clause is internally contested — risk losing the procedural protection the clause was intended to provide. For in-house legal teams monitoring Russian litigation risk across a portfolio of counterparty agreements, this timeline creates real exposure.

If your company holds Russian-law contracts with arbitration clauses drafted from international templates, a targeted clause review can identify enforceability risk before it becomes a live problem. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Institutional options under Russian law: MKAS, RAC, and foreign-seated arbitration

For contracts governed by Russian law between a foreign party and a Russian counterparty, three principal institutional frameworks merit comparison: the International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of the Russian Federation (MKAS), the Russian Arbitration Centre (RAC), and arbitration seated outside Russia at a recognised international institution.

MKAS is Russia's longest-established international commercial arbitration institution, with a procedural history and body of published rules that are well-understood by Russian arbitrazh courts. Awards rendered in MKAS proceedings are regularly enforced by Russian state courts, and the institution's caseload includes a significant proportion of disputes involving foreign parties. For foreign companies entering contracts with Russian counterparties where the governing law is Russian and enforcement of any award is likely to take place in Russia, MKAS remains a pragmatic choice, and its institutional rules broadly comply with the requirements applicable to PFAIs under Russian law.

The RAC, established in 2017, operates under the auspices of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs and administers both domestic and international arbitration. Its rules reflect post-reform legislative requirements, and the institution has developed a case management approach that foreign parties and their counsel have found comparatively accessible. The RAC rules include provisions for expedited proceedings and emergency arbitration, which have increased their utility for time-sensitive commercial disputes.

Foreign-seated arbitration — ICC Paris, LCIA London, SCC Stockholm — remains the preferred choice for many foreign companies contracting with Russian counterparties, particularly in higher-value or higher-complexity transactions. The primary advantage is institutional independence and the application of procedural rules with which the foreign party's counsel is already familiar. The primary disadvantage, which has become more pronounced in recent years, is the enforcement chain: a foreign arbitral award against a Russian entity must be recognised and enforced by a Russian arbitrazh court before Russian assets can be reached. That process is governed by Russian procedural rules and the New York Convention as implemented in Russian law, and it is subject to the grounds for refusal specified therein.

Foreign parties should also note that the choice of a foreign seat does not remove the Russian court's jurisdiction over interim relief applications where Russian assets are involved. Nor does a foreign seat eliminate the arbitrability analysis: if the dispute concerns matters that Russian law characterises as non-arbitrable, a Russian court will decline to refer the parties to arbitration regardless of the seat.

The Supreme Court's clarification on arbitration proceedings in Russia has provided helpful guidance on how Russian courts approach recognition and enforcement of foreign awards — a practical reference for in-house counsel assessing whether a foreign seat remains viable for their specific counterparty type.

For matters where enforcement across multiple jurisdictions is anticipated — including matters where Russian assets are part of a broader cross-border recovery — the firm's matters portfolio illustrates the range of enforcement challenges that arise in practice.

What in-house counsel should do before signing the contract

The practical steps for in-house counsel reviewing a Russian-law contract for arbitration clause quality fall into a sequence that is straightforward in principle but frequently abbreviated under commercial pressure.

The first step is an arbitrability analysis of the specific dispute types that the contract is likely to generate. This is not a generic exercise: the analysis depends on the nature of the underlying transaction, the legal form of the Russian counterparty, and whether any aspect of the agreement engages categories of dispute that Russian law reserves to state court jurisdiction. A corporate joint-venture contract, an infrastructure concession agreement, and a straightforward distribution agreement each present a different arbitrability profile, and a clause designed for one should not be used without adjustment in another.

The second step is institutional selection based on the enforceability objective. The question is not which institution the foreign party's external counsel is most comfortable with, but where an award is most likely to need enforcement, what the Russian courts' track record is with awards from that institution, and what procedural protections the institutional rules provide for a respondent who becomes obstructive. If enforcement in Russia is a realistic scenario, the enforceability analysis under Russian procedural law must drive the institutional choice — not the reverse.

The third step is governing-law clarity for the arbitration agreement itself. The clause should specify the law governing the agreement to arbitrate separately, or the governing law clause of the main contract should be drafted with sufficient precision to make the position unambiguous. Relying on implication, or assuming that "governed by Russian law" in the main contract resolves the question, creates an argument that has been raised with growing frequency in Russian jurisdictional challenges.

The fourth step is an interim relief mapping exercise. Before the clause is finalised, counsel should identify which courts — Russian state arbitrazh courts, or courts in the seat jurisdiction — are competent to grant interim measures in respect of Russian-situated assets, and whether the arbitration clause and the chosen institutional rules are consistent with that enforcement route.

Finally, in-house counsel should ensure that internal procedures for responding to Russian court process are in place. The procedural consequences of failing to invoke an arbitration clause promptly in Russian state court proceedings are real, and the organisational risk — that a subsidiary's management responds to a claim without immediately notifying legal — is underestimated in many foreign groups. A brief internal protocol for the Russian legal entity, setting out the requirement to notify group legal counsel immediately on receipt of any court claim, is an inexpensive safeguard.

The companion analysis on navigating arbitration clauses governed by Russian law addresses the procedural mechanics of invoking a clause once a dispute has arisen — the complement to the drafting analysis set out here.

For companies preparing or reviewing Russian-law contracts where the dispute resolution mechanism is material, a structured assessment of the arbitration clause is available on request. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What makes an arbitration clause unenforceable under Russian law even if it is valid under the law of a foreign jurisdiction?

A: An arbitration clause may be enforceable in the foreign jurisdiction where it was drafted but still fail in a Russian context on one of several grounds. The dispute in question may fall within a category that Russian law treats as non-arbitrable — certain corporate disputes, matters involving state registration, or insolvency-related claims. The designated institution may not meet the requirements applicable to institutionally administered arbitration under Russian law for a Russia-seated arbitration. The clause may not satisfy Russian form requirements as interpreted by Russian courts. Or the clause may be treated as waived if the party relying on it fails to invoke it at the outset of any state court proceedings. Each of these grounds is independent, and each must be assessed on the facts of the contract and the counterparty relationship before the dispute arises.

Q: Is it possible to designate a foreign arbitration institution — such as the ICC or LCIA — in a contract governed by Russian law?

A: Yes. Contracts governed by Russian law may validly designate a foreign arbitration institution such as the ICC, LCIA, or SCC, provided the seat of arbitration is outside Russia or the clause otherwise complies with Russian law requirements. The choice of a foreign institution does not in itself create an enforceability problem. The problem arises at two stages: first, at the jurisdictional stage in Russian state court proceedings, where the arbitrability of the specific dispute type will be assessed under Russian law regardless of the institutional designation; and second, at the enforcement stage in Russia, where the award must satisfy the requirements for recognition under Russian procedural legislation and the New York Convention as applied by Russian arbitrazh courts. In-house counsel should treat the institutional designation and the enforceability analysis as two distinct questions.

Q: What is the difference between MKAS and the Russian Arbitration Centre for in-house counsel choosing between them?

A: MKAS, administered at the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of the Russian Federation, is the longer-established institution with a substantial body of enforcement practice before Russian state courts. It is the default choice for parties who prioritise predictability and the Russian courts' familiarity with its awards. The RAC, established in 2017, operates under more recently drafted rules that reflect the post-reform legislative framework, including provisions for emergency arbitration and expedited proceedings. For in-house counsel, the practical distinction often comes down to the complexity and time-sensitivity of the likely dispute category: MKAS for higher-value, more legally complex matters where institutional standing matters at enforcement; RAC for disputes where procedural speed or emergency relief is the priority. Both are recognised as properly functioning institutions under Russian law.

Q: Does Russian law require the arbitration clause to specify the seat of arbitration?

A: Not as an absolute formal requirement, but the absence of a seat designation creates significant practical risk. Where no seat is specified in a contract governed by Russian law, Russian courts have adopted varying approaches — some treating the matter as an agreement to Russia-seated arbitration by implication, others refusing to enforce the clause on grounds of uncertainty. The risk of a court concluding that the clause is insufficiently definite to constitute a valid arbitration agreement is real. A well-drafted clause should specify the seat, the administering institution, the governing law of the arbitration agreement, and the language of proceedings. Leaving any of these elements to implication or residual inference creates arguments that experienced opposing counsel will raise at the first available opportunity.

Q: How should in-house counsel in a foreign subsidiary respond if a Russian counterparty files a state court claim despite an arbitration clause in the contract?

A: The overriding priority is speed. Under Russian procedural legislation, the right to invoke an arbitration clause as a ground for declining jurisdiction must be raised in the first substantive procedural step — typically the initial response or pre-trial conference. Filing a substantive defence without raising the arbitration clause may be treated as a waiver of the right to rely on it. The foreign subsidiary's management should notify group legal counsel immediately on receipt of any claim. External Russian counsel should be instructed to file the arbitration objection as the first procedural act, before engaging on the merits. Where the subsidiary lacks established internal procedures for this scenario, the risk of a procedurally expensive default is real and foreseeable.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry