Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Russian Supreme Court clarification on jurisdictional challenges in Russian arbitrazh courts

Vitaliy Vetrov · February 2026 · 8 min read

Russia's Supreme Court has clarified how arbitrazh courts must handle jurisdictional challenges. What in-house counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.

Following clarificatory guidance issued by Russia's Supreme Court on the handling of jurisdictional challenges in arbitrazh proceedings, in-house counsel at foreign companies with Russian legal exposure face a materially adjusted procedural landscape. The Supreme Court's position — delivered through its standard mechanism of a generalised review of court practice — tightens the procedural requirements governing when and how a party may raise a challenge to an arbitrazh court's jurisdiction, and sets clearer expectations for what courts must do when such a challenge is lodged. For foreign companies operating in Russia through subsidiaries, joint ventures, or direct contractual relationships, the implications are immediate and concrete.

§ I. What the Supreme Court has clarified — and what changed before this guidance

Before this clarificatory guidance took effect, Russian arbitrazh courts applied a broadly consistent but unevenly documented approach to jurisdictional challenges. A party wishing to contest the court's jurisdiction — whether on grounds of subject-matter competence, territorial attribution, or the distinction between arbitrazh and general civil jurisdiction — was expected to raise that objection promptly. In practice, however, courts in different circuits handled the timing, form, and consequences of such challenges with meaningful variation. Some circuits applied a relatively strict preclusion rule: a party that participated in preliminary hearings without raising a jurisdictional objection was treated as having waived it. Others continued to examine jurisdiction at any stage, effectively allowing strategic objections late in proceedings.

The Supreme Court's clarification resolves this divergence in three material respects.

First, it establishes that a jurisdictional challenge must be raised no later than the submission of a party's first substantive response on the merits. Participation in procedural steps — including the filing of procedural motions — before that response does not constitute waiver, but any first substantive engagement with the merits of the claim without a concurrent or prior jurisdictional objection will, under the clarified position, extinguish the right to raise it later.

Second, the guidance addresses the court's own-motion obligation. The Supreme Court confirms that an arbitrazh court must examine its own jurisdiction independently of whether either party raises an objection — but it clarifies that this obligation applies primarily at the stage of accepting the claim and in preliminary hearings, not as a continuing duty throughout the proceedings. Once a court has confirmed jurisdiction and the matter proceeds to substantive hearing, the burden shifts decisively to the challenging party.

Third, the guidance speaks to cross-border scenarios. Where a foreign entity is a party, the Supreme Court confirms that the arbitrazh jurisdiction rules apply in full, and that the foreign party's status does not in itself generate special procedural latitude — the same waiver principles apply. This is a significant calibration for foreign companies accustomed to broader jurisdictional flexibility in their home courts.

"What this guidance does, in practical terms, is close the window for tactical jurisdictional challenges raised once a party has already engaged substantively with the Russian court — a manoeuvre that was, in some circuits, still available." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

§ II. Who is affected, and why does this matter for foreign companies?

The companies most immediately affected are those already involved in, or anticipating, disputes before Russian arbitrazh courts. The clarification has different implications depending on the stage and nature of the proceedings.

For foreign companies that are respondents in claims brought by Russian counterparties, the narrowed window for jurisdictional objection is operationally significant. If Russian external counsel has not been instructed promptly — or if in-house counsel has handled early-stage correspondence with the court without specifically reserving jurisdictional position — the right to challenge jurisdiction on grounds such as an arbitration clause, a foreign exclusive jurisdiction clause, or improper territorial attribution may be treated as waived. In a foreign company dispute with a Russian counterparty, this represents a real shift in risk.

For companies that are claimants, the guidance has a different dimension: it raises the probability that a respondent's belated jurisdictional challenge will fail. For in-house counsel managing Russian litigation where the company is the initiating party, this offers a degree of procedural security — the counter-party cannot disrupt substantive proceedings with a late challenge once the merits phase is under way.

The relevance extends beyond active disputes. Foreign companies with Russian subsidiaries or long-term supply arrangements that are governed by Russian law, and where dispute-resolution clauses have not been reviewed recently, face a latent risk. A clause that purports to route disputes to a foreign forum may be challenged in Russian proceedings — and under the clarified framework, the foreign company's counsel must be positioned to raise that objection at the earliest procedural opportunity.

For companies operating in EAEU member states with Russian counterparties, it is worth noting that the arbitrazh jurisdictional framework applies to commercial disputes between entities where at least one has a Russian nexus, irrespective of whether the contractual relationship spans multiple CIS jurisdictions. The clarification does not alter that boundary, but reinforces how rigorously it will be policed.

Under Russian procedural rules as clarified, the first substantive response to a Russian arbitrazh claim is a hard deadline for jurisdictional objection — a deadline that, once missed, cannot be recovered regardless of the underlying merits of the challenge. For in-house counsel managing Russian disputes from abroad, where instructions to local counsel may be delayed by time-zone or organisational approval processes, this timeline demands specific internal protocols.

For in-house counsel managing Russian litigation exposure — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What foreign companies and their counsel should do now

The practical response to this clarification falls into two categories: active matter management and structural review.

For companies currently involved in Russian arbitrazh proceedings as respondents, the immediate step is to confirm with local counsel that no substantive response has been filed or is being prepared without a concurrent jurisdictional position. Where there is any doubt about the company's procedural standing on jurisdiction — for instance, where preliminary correspondence or procedural motions have already been filed — that question should be addressed before the first substantive response is due.

For companies not currently in active proceedings, the clarification warrants a targeted review of Russian-law contracts. Three categories of agreement are most material: long-term supply and distribution agreements with Russian counterparties where the dispute-resolution clause points to a foreign forum or arbitral institution; joint venture agreements governed by Russian law where the arbitrazh court may be the default forum by operation of law; and any agreement where the jurisdictional clause has not been tested or has been drafted without reference to the Russian arbitrazh rules specifically.

This review need not be extensive. A focused one-hour analysis by Russian counsel of each agreement's dispute-resolution clause, read against the clarified framework, will in most cases either confirm adequacy or identify the specific amendment needed.

For foreign law firms instructing Russian counsel in matters involving a Russian arbitrazh element — including cross-border insolvency, enforcement of Russian-law contracts, and shareholder disputes in Russian entities — the clarification reinforces the value of establishing a confirmed Russian counsel relationship before proceedings are initiated, not after. The jurisdictional challenge window under the clarified framework opens and closes faster than many foreign counsel anticipate.

For a broader analysis of how jurisdictional challenges arise and develop in Russian arbitrazh proceedings, see our practice briefing at Jurisdictional challenges in Russian arbitrazh courts and the detailed analytical piece Deep dive: jurisdictional challenges in Russia. Both are part of the firm's Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice guidance series.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically did the Supreme Court clarify about when a jurisdictional challenge must be raised in Russian arbitrazh proceedings?

A: The Supreme Court has clarified that a jurisdictional challenge — whether on grounds of subject-matter competence, territorial jurisdiction, or the arbitrazh-versus-general-jurisdiction divide — must be raised no later than the party's first substantive response on the merits of the claim. Prior procedural steps, such as the filing of procedural motions or attendance at preliminary hearings, do not constitute waiver. However, once a party engages substantively with the merits without raising a jurisdictional objection, the right to do so is extinguished under the clarified framework. The guidance also confirms that courts must examine jurisdiction on their own motion at the acceptance stage and preliminary hearing, but that this obligation does not continue indefinitely through proceedings.

Q: How does this Supreme Court guidance affect foreign companies that are respondents in Russian arbitrazh claims?

A: For foreign companies that are respondents, the narrowed waiver rule creates a hard procedural deadline. If a foreign company's in-house or external counsel files any response that addresses the merits of the claim — even partially — without a concurrent or prior jurisdictional objection, the right to challenge the court's jurisdiction on grounds such as a foreign arbitration clause or an exclusive foreign jurisdiction clause will be treated as waived. This is particularly material for foreign companies where the instruction of Russian local counsel is delayed, since the timeline runs from the first substantive court filing, not from any separate notice. Early coordination with Russian counsel on the jurisdictional position is the correct response.

Q: Does this clarification change anything for foreign companies that are the initiating party in a Russian arbitrazh claim?

A: For claimants, the principal effect is positive: a respondent's attempt to derail substantive proceedings with a belated jurisdictional challenge is now less likely to succeed. Once the respondent has engaged with the merits, the Supreme Court's clarified framework forecloses that avenue. For foreign companies that initiate Russian arbitrazh proceedings as claimants — for example, in disputes arising from Russian-law contracts with Russian counterparties — this provides a degree of procedural certainty that was previously less uniform across circuits. It does not, however, remove the need for claimants to ensure that the chosen arbitrazh court is the correct forum from the outset, since the respondent's right to challenge before engaging on the merits remains intact.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry