Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Russian court practice on arbitration clauses governed by Russian law at the appeal and cassation stage: 2027 update

Vitaliy Vetrov · September 2026 · 7 min read

Russian appeal courts have tightened their review of arbitration clauses in 2027. Key changes foreign companies need to review. Make an enquiry.

Since early 2027, Russian appeal and cassation courts have materially sharpened their scrutiny of arbitration clauses governed by Russian law — shifting from a broadly permissive posture to a framework that conditions enforceability on specific drafting choices. For foreign companies operating in Russia through subsidiaries, joint ventures, or long-term supply arrangements, this development carries a direct operational consequence: clauses that satisfied Russian courts at first instance as recently as two years ago are now being challenged successfully at the appeal stage. Understanding what changed, who is exposed, and what needs to be reviewed is now a routine task for in-house counsel managing Russian entities.

What changed at the appeal and cassation stage?

Russian courts have long accepted arbitration clauses in commercial contracts, but the standard of review applied at the appeal and cassation stage has historically been deferential. Through the first half of 2027, Russian appeal courts have consolidated a more interventionist approach, recharacterising several categories of previously uncontested clauses as defective on grounds that were treated as technical rather than substantive in earlier periods.

Before this shift, appeal courts reviewing first-instance decisions on jurisdiction would typically accept an arbitration clause if it identified an institutional arbitral body and contained no manifest ambiguity. The governing-law question — whether Russian law applied to the clause itself, as distinct from the underlying contract — received little independent scrutiny. A clause designating a foreign arbitral institution under English or Swiss governing law, even in a contract with substantial Russian performance obligations, was routinely left undisturbed on appeal.

The current position is different in three material respects. First, where the parties have chosen Russian law as the governing law of the arbitration clause — either expressly or by operation of default rules — appeal courts are now applying Russian law's substantive requirements to the clause with genuine rigour. This means courts are examining whether the arbitral institution named in the clause satisfies Russian law's criteria for a recognised arbitral body, whether the clause's scope of application is defined with sufficient specificity, and whether any mandatory provisions of Russian procedural law have been contracted out in a manner that Russian courts now treat as impermissible.

Second, at the cassation stage, the shift has been procedural as well as substantive. Cassation courts reviewing appellate decisions on arbitration clause validity have shown a greater readiness to treat deficiencies in clause drafting as grounds for independent cassation review, rather than deferring to the factual findings of the appeal court. This reduces the predictability that parties previously relied upon when calculating the risk of a jurisdiction challenge surviving to cassation.

Third, the scope of the review has extended to clauses in ancillary and associated agreements — side letters, pledge agreements, and guarantee arrangements that are often drafted by reference to the main contract's dispute-resolution clause. Where the main contract has been challenged, courts have begun drawing the ancillary agreements into the same review, sometimes with distinct results at each level.

"

"The shift at appeal and cassation is not procedural housekeeping. Courts are now treating governing-law compliance in arbitration clauses as a substantive enforceability condition, and that changes the risk calculus for existing contracts."— Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

"

For in-house counsel managing Russian subsidiaries with existing commercial contracts, the window to review clause drafting before a jurisdiction challenge arises in litigation is now shorter than it was. To discuss your current contract portfolio — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Which foreign companies are most exposed?

The practical exposure is not uniform. The highest-risk contracts are those concluded between 2019 and 2024, drafted under standard international terms without specific adaptation for Russian governing law, and where the counterparty is a Russian entity now subject to financial pressure or a change in ownership. In those circumstances, a jurisdiction challenge at the appeal stage is a commercially rational litigation tactic — it delays proceedings, creates uncertainty, and may shift the forum to one more favourable to the Russian party.

Foreign manufacturers with Russian distribution arrangements, European financial creditors holding security over Russian assets, and EAEU-member-state companies with cross-border supply contracts are the three client profiles most frequently appearing in the matters our practice has handled since the consolidation of this approach in the courts. The common thread is a governing-law structure that was designed in a different regulatory environment and has not been reviewed against current Russian court expectations.

There is a secondary exposure for companies that have already commenced arbitral proceedings or obtained an award under a clause that may now be characterised as defective by Russian standards. Recognition and enforcement of a foreign arbitral award in Russia proceeds through the Russian state courts, and a successful challenge to the underlying clause validity — even at the enforcement stage — remains a ground for refusing recognition. Foreign companies in live enforcement proceedings should treat this development as directly relevant to their current strategy. For context on how Russian courts approach the recognition of foreign arbitral awards more broadly, the firm's analysis of navigating arbitration clauses under Russian law addresses the foundational procedural framework.

What should foreign companies do now?

Three actions are relevant in the near term. First, identify which Russian-law-governed commercial contracts — or contracts with Russian-law-governed arbitration clauses — are currently active and involve a Russian counterparty where the relationship is under commercial strain. These are the highest-risk agreements for a jurisdiction challenge in the next twelve to eighteen months.

Second, review the drafting of the arbitration clause against current Russian court expectations: institutional designation, scope of application, conformity with Russian procedural requirements. A comparative review of how Russian-law arbitration clauses are typically drafted versus international standard forms is set out in the firm's comparative analysis of arbitration clause structures under Russian law, which provides a useful baseline for that exercise.

Third, where a clause is identified as potentially defective under the current approach, assess the options. These include renegotiation of the dispute-resolution clause before any proceedings arise, preparation of a jurisdiction defence strategy in anticipation of a challenge, and — where enforcement of a prior award is in prospect — early engagement with Russian enforcement counsel to assess the risk of a clause-based objection.

Waiting until a jurisdiction challenge is actually filed at first instance, rather than addressing clause risk in advance, is the costlier approach. By the time the matter reaches the appeal stage, the parties are committed to a litigation posture that limits their options. The matters section of this site includes representative examples of how the firm has acted for foreign clients in Russian jurisdiction disputes where clause validity was a live issue.

If your company holds active Russian-law contracts with arbitration clauses and has not reviewed them against the 2027 court practice — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in how Russian courts review arbitration clauses governed by Russian law in 2027?

A: Russian appeal and cassation courts have moved from a broadly deferential posture to substantive, independent review of arbitration clauses where Russian law governs the clause. Courts now examine whether the designated arbitral institution meets Russian law criteria, whether the clause scope is sufficiently specific, and whether mandatory Russian procedural provisions have been excluded. At cassation level, drafting deficiencies are now treated as independent grounds for cassation review rather than matters of first-instance fact.

Q: Which categories of foreign companies are most affected by this change?

A: The greatest exposure sits with foreign companies whose Russian-law commercial contracts were drafted between 2019 and 2024 under standard international terms, without specific adaptation to Russian governing-law requirements. This includes foreign manufacturers with Russian distribution arrangements, European financial creditors holding security over Russian assets, and companies from EAEU member states with cross-border supply contracts. Companies in active enforcement proceedings in Russia should also review the position, as clause-validity challenges remain available at the enforcement stage.

Q: What should in-house counsel do as a practical next step?

A: Three actions are time-sensitive. Identify active Russian-law contracts involving financially stressed Russian counterparties, where a jurisdiction challenge would benefit the Russian party. Review the arbitration clause drafting against current court expectations for institutional designation and procedural conformity. And where a clause is identified as potentially defective, engage Russian counsel before proceedings are commenced — options narrow significantly once a jurisdiction challenge is filed.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry