Russian courts applying Article V(2)(b) of the New York Convention create choice-of-law exposure for foreign counterparties in 2026–2027. Make an enquiry.
Regulatory update: choice-of-law issues in cross-border contracts
The intersection of contractual choice-of-law clauses and the public policy ground for refusing recognition under Article V(2)(b) of the New York Convention has long been a fault line in cross-border contract enforcement. In the period leading into 2027, Russian courts have sharpened their approach to this fault line in ways that matter directly to foreign companies with Russian counterparties. Where a contract governed by foreign law produces an award or judgment that a Russian party resists, Russian courts are increasingly prepared to examine whether enforcement would conflict with the fundamental principles of Russian legal order — not merely as a procedural formality, but as a substantive gatekeeping exercise. In-house counsel advising on contracts with Russian entities should treat this development as a live risk, not a theoretical one.
Before examining what has shifted, it is worth recalling the baseline. Article V(2)(b) of the New York Convention permits a court of the country in which recognition and enforcement is sought to refuse recognition if it finds that doing so would be contrary to that country's public policy. This ground is, in theory, reserved for the most fundamental violations of legal order — not ordinary conflicts between the foreign award and local law. Russian courts have nominally subscribed to this narrow interpretation for many years, consistent with the prevailing international consensus that public policy is an exceptional, last-resort defence.
What has changed is the texture of the reasoning. Russian courts have, in a discernible pattern across the Siberian, Volga, and West Siberian circuits, begun to engage more actively with the choice-of-law foundation of the award itself. Where an arbitral tribunal applied a foreign governing law — English law, Swiss law, or the law of another EU or EAEU member state — to resolve a dispute with a Russian party, Russian enforcement courts have in a number of instances examined whether the substantive outcome of that foreign-law application conflicts with mandatory norms of Russian civil law. The inquiry is no longer confined to whether the process was fair or whether the arbitration agreement was valid. Courts have reached into the substantive result and asked whether the choice of foreign law, as applied to produce the award, is reconcilable with foundational Russian norms on unjust enrichment, interest, and — notably — currency obligations.
This represents a qualitative shift from the pre-2024 position, when Russian courts largely treated the public policy review under Article V(2)(b) as narrow and outcome-oriented only in extreme cases. The shift does not constitute a formal amendment to Russian arbitration legislation or to Russia's obligations under the New York Convention. Russia ratified the Convention in 1960 and remains a contracting state. The change is doctrinal, not legislative — which makes it harder to track and harder to predict, but no less significant for foreign creditors and counterparties seeking to enforce foreign-law-governed awards in Russia.
For foreign companies holding contracts with Russian parties governed by English, Swiss, or German law, the practical implication is this: a choice-of-law clause that was once a reliable anchor for enforcement may now face a layer of substantive review that did not exist three years ago. The window between an adverse Russian court decision on enforcement and the expiry of the period for challenging that decision in the cassation courts can be measured in weeks — a timeline that in-house counsel and their external advisers must factor into enforcement strategy from the moment a dispute crystallises.
The exposure is not uniform. The pattern that has emerged from Russian enforcement proceedings in the period 2024–2027 suggests that certain combinations of contract type, governing law, and counterparty profile carry materially higher risk of a V(2)(b) challenge than others.
Contracts most exposed. Long-term supply and distribution agreements governed by English or Swiss law, where the Russian party is a significant domestic enterprise rather than a joint venture vehicle, have attracted the greatest scrutiny. The courts' substantive review has focused in particular on: (a) penalty and interest provisions computed under foreign law that exceed the levels which Russian courts would award under domestic rules on damages and unjust enrichment; (b) currency provisions denominated in US dollars or euros where the Russian party argues that enforcement in that currency conflicts with Russian currency regulation; and (c) asymmetric dispute resolution clauses — clauses permitting one party (typically the foreign counterparty) to elect between arbitration and national court litigation — which Russian courts have in certain instances treated as substantively incompatible with Russian procedural order.
Counterparty profile. The risk is elevated where the Russian counterparty is a company with significant domestic revenues and an incentive to resist enforcement by all available means. In such cases, the V(2)(b) public policy ground is frequently invoked not as a genuine constitutional objection but as a delay mechanism — one that, even if ultimately unsuccessful, may give the Russian party time to dissipate assets. Foreign companies with Russian subsidiaries or joint ventures — the core ICP-1 constituency — should note that even where the Russian party is an affiliate rather than an adversary, the enforceability of intra-group contracts governed by foreign law may come under scrutiny in the event of a shareholder dispute or regulatory investigation.
EAEU and CIS dimensions. Russia's membership of the EAEU and CIS creates an additional layer. Cross-border contracts between Russian parties and counterparties in Kazakhstan, Belarus, Armenia, or Kyrgyzstan that are governed by a third-country law (say, English law) may face a triangulated enforcement question: which jurisdiction's public policy governs? In practice, the country where enforcement is sought applies its own public policy standard. But where assets are held across multiple EAEU jurisdictions, a Russian court's refusal to recognise a foreign-law-governed award on V(2)(b) grounds may have knock-on implications for parallel enforcement proceedings in Minsk or Almaty.
For in-house counsel managing Russian counterparty relationships, the regulatory timeline here does not permit delay. A choice-of-law clause agreed three or five years ago under a different enforcement landscape may need to be renegotiated or supplemented by additional contractual protections before the next dispute arises.
If your company holds contracts with Russian counterparties governed by foreign law and you need to assess current enforcement risk under Article V(2)(b), make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The practical response to this development falls into three distinct categories: contractual, procedural, and strategic.
Contractual review. The most immediate action is to review governing-law and dispute-resolution provisions in existing contracts with Russian parties. Contracts governed by English or Swiss law that contain interest, penalty, or currency provisions likely to attract Russian court scrutiny should be reviewed against the current Russian public policy case law. Where renegotiation is not commercially feasible, supplementary documentation — a legal opinion on enforceability under current Russian practice, for example — provides a record that due diligence was conducted and can inform enforcement strategy if a dispute arises.
Procedural preparation. Where a dispute is already live or reasonably foreseeable, the enforcement strategy should be mapped before arbitration proceedings conclude. This means identifying the jurisdictions in which the Russian party holds attachable assets, assessing the relative enforceability of the anticipated award in each jurisdiction, and considering whether interim protective measures in Russian state courts should be sought in parallel with or prior to the commencement of arbitration. Russia's Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice encompasses precisely this kind of pre-enforcement mapping.
Choice-of-law alternatives. Some foreign companies with recurring Russian counterparty relationships are revisiting whether a partial shift to Russian governing law — or to the law of an EAEU member state such as Kazakhstan — might reduce V(2)(b) exposure without materially altering substantive rights. This is not a straightforward substitution: Russian contract law differs from English law in material respects, particularly on limitation of liability, consequential loss, and specific performance. The firm has addressed the underlying trade-offs in Navigating choice-of-law issues in cross-border contracts and Strategic considerations in choice-of-law issues in cross-border practice, which provide the comparative analytical framework for that assessment.
Monitoring. The doctrinal development described in this update is ongoing. Russian courts have not issued consolidated guidance — the relevant decisions are spread across circuit-level arbitrazh courts, and the position at cassation level remains to be definitively settled. Foreign companies should treat this as a developing area requiring periodic review rather than a one-time compliance exercise. The firm monitors circuit-level enforcement decisions across the Siberian and West Siberian districts and can provide targeted regulatory updates on request.
"[Quote — attributed below]"
Q: What specifically changed in how Russian courts apply Article V(2)(b) of the New York Convention?
A: The change is doctrinal rather than legislative. Russian courts, across several circuit-level arbitrazh courts, have moved beyond the traditionally narrow public policy review to examine whether the substantive outcome of applying a foreign governing law to a dispute is compatible with foundational norms of Russian civil law. This now routinely includes scrutiny of penalty and interest clauses, currency obligations, and asymmetric dispute resolution provisions. Russia's underlying New York Convention obligations have not changed — it ratified the Convention in 1960 and remains bound by it — but the practical standard courts apply when examining a V(2)(b) objection has tightened.
Q: Which types of foreign companies are most at risk from this development?
A: The highest exposure falls on foreign companies that hold long-term supply, distribution, or loan agreements with significant Russian domestic enterprises, where those contracts are governed by English, Swiss, or German law and contain penalty, interest, or currency provisions that exceed or differ from what Russian courts would award under domestic norms. Joint ventures and subsidiaries of foreign multinationals are also affected where intra-group contracts are governed by foreign law, since a Russian counterparty or shareholder in dispute may invoke V(2)(b) grounds to resist enforcement of an adverse award. EAEU-dimension contracts — governed by third-country law and spanning Russia and another EAEU member state — face an additional layer of complexity in parallel enforcement proceedings.
Q: What is the single most important action for in-house counsel to take now?
A: Review the governing-law and dispute-resolution provisions in your existing contracts with Russian counterparties against the current Russian enforcement landscape before a dispute arises. Once arbitration proceedings are under way, the options for adjusting enforcement strategy narrow considerably. If renegotiation is not available, a targeted enforceability assessment — mapping the contract's key provisions against current Russian public policy case law — provides the analytical foundation for a sound enforcement strategy and demonstrates appropriate diligence if the matter escalates.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry