Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Regulatory update: parallel proceedings in Russia and foreign jurisdictions in the mining and metals sector

Vitaliy Vetrov · September 2026 · 9 min read

Mining firms with Russian assets face simultaneous proceedings across legal systems. Key changes in 2026–2027 and what to do. Make an enquiry.

Following a period of sustained regulatory activity in Russia's procedural law between 2022 and 2026, multinational mining and metals companies operating in the Russian Federation now face a materially different environment for managing simultaneous proceedings across legal systems. Russian courts have sharpened their approach to anti-suit relief, jurisdictional priority claims, and the recognition of foreign arbitral awards in sector-sensitive asset classes – developments that directly affect how in-house counsel at foreign-invested mining businesses should frame their dispute resolution strategy and structure their asset positions in Russia.

§ I. What has changed – the regulatory and procedural shift

Russian civil procedure and arbitrazh court practice have moved in a consistent direction over the past three to four years: towards asserting greater jurisdictional control over disputes with a Russian nexus, particularly where the assets in question are natural resources, subsoil licences, or infrastructure connected to the Russian Federation's strategic industries. For in-house counsel at companies in the mining and metals sector, this creates a distinctive exposure that differs from the general cross-border disputes landscape.

Three developments in particular require attention.

First, the scope of exclusive Russian jurisdiction over disputes involving Russian subsoil licences, mineral extraction rights, and related contractual arrangements has been confirmed and in some circuits extended through a series of arbitrazh court decisions at cassation level. Where a mining asset is involved, a Russian court is increasingly likely to assert that the matter falls within categories of proceedings that Russian procedural law reserves to Russian courts, irrespective of the parties' contractual choice of foreign arbitration or a foreign court.

Second, Russian procedural law now provides a more explicit mechanism for Russian courts to issue anti-suit relief – orders instructing parties not to pursue or to suspend foreign proceedings – in circumstances where the Russian court considers that exclusive jurisdiction has been engaged. The application of this mechanism in practice has been uneven across circuits, but there is a clear trend in the Siberian and Ural federal districts, where a disproportionate share of Russian mining assets are located, towards granting such relief on application by a Russian counterparty.

Third, the recognition framework for foreign arbitral awards touching on natural resources assets has become more restrictive. Russian courts have exercised the public policy exception under the New York Convention with greater frequency in matters where the underlying asset is characterised as strategically significant. The standard of review applied to such awards has, in practice, shifted: courts in several circuits have treated the characterisation of the asset class as a threshold question rather than a peripheral consideration.

For companies holding Russian mining or metals assets through foreign holding structures, and managing those assets through joint venture agreements, offtake contracts, or licensing arrangements governed by foreign law, these changes compound one another. A dispute that arises in connection with a Russian subsoil licence may now simultaneously engage: the Russian arbitrazh court on jurisdiction; a foreign arbitral tribunal on the merits; and – if an award has already been issued – the enforcement track in multiple jurisdictions. The procedural map is more complicated than it was three years ago, and the consequences of navigating it without a confirmed Russian counsel relationship are more severe.

"In the mining and metals sector, we are seeing jurisdictional arguments used not as a preliminary objection but as a primary litigation instrument – the Russian court proceeding is opened not to resolve the underlying dispute but to constrain the foreign forum." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel assessing a dispute involving Russian mining assets, the configuration of proceedings across forums requires early-stage analysis before any formal step is taken – make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Which foreign companies in the mining and metals sector are most affected?

The regulatory developments described above do not affect all foreign-invested mining businesses equally. Three categories of company face the highest procedural exposure.

The first is foreign shareholders in Russian mining joint ventures. Where the joint venture agreement provides for foreign arbitration of shareholder disputes, but the underlying licence assets are held by a Russian legal entity, a Russian counterparty now has a well-developed procedural toolkit for bringing those disputes into the Russian courts. The combination of exclusive jurisdiction provisions in Russian procedural law and the anti-suit mechanism means that a foreign shareholder who opens foreign arbitration proceedings may quickly find those proceedings contested not on the merits but on jurisdictional grounds, with a parallel Russian court proceeding running simultaneously.

The second category is foreign offtakers and trade counterparties with contractual claims against Russian mining companies. Offtake agreements, supply contracts, and tolling arrangements in the metals sector frequently contain London or Swiss arbitration clauses. In the current environment, a Russian mining company facing a claim under such a contract may open a separate Russian court proceeding asserting that the contract or its performance has a Russian exclusive jurisdictional nexus – particularly if the contract concerns raw materials extracted from Russian subsoil. Even where this argument does not ultimately succeed, it creates a period of procedural uncertainty that carries real cost and timeline risk for the foreign claimant.

The third category is foreign creditors secured over Russian mining assets. Where a pledge or mortgage has been taken over Russian subsoil-adjacent assets, enforcement in a foreign forum will almost certainly require parallel Russian proceedings. The intersection of Russian insolvency legislation – which has its own rules on the priority of secured creditors in extraction-sector insolvencies – and the secured creditor's foreign-law enforcement rights creates a structurally complex parallel proceedings problem. Creditors in this position should also review their exposure through the lens of the Restructuring & Insolvency practice, where separate considerations arise.

It is worth noting that EAEU and CIS member-state companies operating in Russia face a distinct variant of this problem. Mutual legal assistance arrangements between EAEU member states create a degree of procedural coordination that does not exist for purely Western-counterparty disputes – in some matters, this makes the parallel proceedings problem more tractable; in others, it creates an additional layer of enforcement obligations that a Western counterparty would not face.

For a broader structural analysis of how parallel proceedings configurations arise and are managed in Russian courts across sectors, see Anatomy of parallel proceedings in Russia and foreign jurisdictions. For creditor-specific procedural considerations, see Foreign creditors and parallel proceedings in Russian courts.

In-house counsel managing a live dispute involving Russian mining assets should establish their Russian counsel relationship before the procedural configuration becomes fixed – make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What should in-house counsel do now?

The regulatory developments described above call for a structured review of dispute risk in any portfolio with Russian mining or metals exposure. The following three steps reflect the priorities that in-house counsel at foreign-invested mining businesses should address before a dispute is formally commenced.

The first step is a jurisdictional mapping exercise. For each material contract, joint venture agreement, or security arrangement connected to a Russian mining or metals asset, in-house counsel should identify: the dispute resolution clause; the nature of the underlying asset (subsoil licence, extraction contract, infrastructure, offtake); and whether a Russian court could plausibly assert exclusive jurisdiction over a dispute arising from that contract. This exercise is most usefully conducted with Russian-qualified counsel who can apply current circuit-level practice, not only the statutory text.

The second step is a forum-sequencing analysis. In parallel proceedings, the sequence in which proceedings are opened across forums can affect outcomes materially. Russian courts have, in a number of reported matters, treated the opening of a foreign arbitration proceeding as a trigger for asserting domestic jurisdiction – the so-called "first-mover" dynamic in the Russian courts. Understanding this dynamic, and advising the business on whether to open Russian proceedings first, whether to open foreign arbitration first, or whether to open both simultaneously, requires experienced cross-border disputes counsel familiar with current Russian court practice. See the firm's Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice for the scope of advisory work the firm handles in this area.

The third step is a review of how the company's Russian assets are reflected in its dispute-risk register. Mining companies with Russian assets held through intermediate holding structures should ensure that the risk register captures not only the direct contractual risk but also the indirect exposure arising from regulatory changes in the host jurisdiction – including the procedural developments described in this update. The matters section of the firm's website includes examples of how similar configurations have been navigated in practice.

Foreign companies that have already commenced foreign arbitration proceedings in connection with a Russian mining or metals matter and have not yet considered the Russian parallel proceedings risk should treat that as a priority review item. Under the prevailing approach in Russian courts, the window for structuring a coordinated response to a parallel Russian proceeding narrows significantly once the Russian court has formally recorded jurisdiction.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian procedural rules that affects parallel proceedings in the mining and metals sector?

A: Russian arbitrazh courts have, through a consistent line of decisions at cassation level, extended the categories of dispute treated as subject to exclusive Russian jurisdiction to include matters with a direct connection to Russian subsoil licences and strategic extraction assets. Simultaneously, the anti-suit mechanism available under Russian procedural law has been applied more actively, particularly in the Siberian and Ural federal districts. Together, these developments mean that a foreign arbitration clause in a mining joint venture agreement or offtake contract provides materially less procedural protection against a parallel Russian court proceeding than it would have four to five years ago.

Q: Which foreign companies with Russian mining assets are most exposed to this regulatory change?

A: The highest exposure falls on three groups: foreign shareholders in Russian mining joint ventures where the licence assets are held by a Russian entity; foreign trade counterparties holding London or Swiss arbitration rights under offtake and supply contracts with Russian mining companies; and foreign secured creditors whose collateral package includes Russian subsoil-adjacent assets. Companies in all three categories should conduct a jurisdictional mapping exercise across their Russian-connected contracts as a matter of priority. EAEU and CIS member-state companies face a related but structurally distinct variant of the problem, given the applicable mutual legal assistance framework.

Q: What is the most important immediate action for in-house counsel managing Russian mining exposure?

A: The most important immediate step is to establish a confirmed Russian counsel relationship before a dispute is formally commenced. The sequence in which proceedings are opened across forums can affect outcomes significantly under current Russian court practice, and that sequencing decision requires advice from Russian-qualified counsel with current circuit-level experience. Conducting a jurisdictional mapping exercise across material Russian-connected contracts – and understanding which of those contracts could attract an exclusive jurisdiction assertion by a Russian court – is the analytical foundation for any subsequent procedural decision.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry