Russian courts refined their Article V(2)(b) public policy analysis in 2027. What in-house counsel at multinationals must know. Make an enquiry.
In the period leading up to and through 2027, Russian arbitrazh courts and the courts of general jurisdiction have continued to refine the circumstances in which they will apply Article V(2)(b) of the New York Convention to refuse recognition or enforcement of a foreign arbitral award on public policy grounds. For in-house counsel at foreign companies with Russian operations or counterparty exposure, understanding where this doctrinal line now sits – and how the appeals and cassation review process interacts with it – has moved from a contingency concern to a live compliance and litigation-management question. Russian civil procedure affords multiple layers of review, and the strategic use of appeals cassation review at each tier materially affects whether a recognition order survives or is set aside.
The New York Convention's Article V(2)(b) permits a court to refuse recognition and enforcement of a foreign arbitral award if doing so would be contrary to the public policy of the country where enforcement is sought. Russian courts have always maintained that this ground is to be applied narrowly – mirroring the position of most Convention states – but the practical content of that narrowness has shifted noticeably in the current period.
Until recently, Russian judicial practice treated the public policy exception as a residual safeguard triggered only by the most fundamental violations: awards procured by fraud, awards requiring a party to perform an act that is criminal under Russian law, or awards that contradict constitutional guarantees in a direct and demonstrable way. The threshold was articulated by the Supreme Court in guidance that characterised Article V(2)(b) as a narrow escape valve, not an instrument of merits review.
What has changed in 2027 is the application of this standard at the appellate and cassation tiers rather than its formal content. Courts hearing appeals cassation review of first-instance recognition decisions have shown a more searching examination of the public policy dimension in specific categories of dispute. Three areas are now exhibiting this pattern: (i) awards arising from contracts involving state-owned or state-affiliated Russian counterparties, where courts at cassation have indicated that certain structural features of the underlying transaction may raise sovereign-interest considerations; (ii) awards touching on Russian real property or subsoil rights, where the intersection with mandatory domestic regulatory regimes has prompted closer scrutiny; and (iii) awards rendered in institutional proceedings under rules amended after 2022, where procedural fairness arguments at the cassation stage have occasionally been reframed through the public policy lens rather than the Article V(1)(b) due process ground.
This shift matters for in-house counsel because it affects the risk calculus at each stage of the Russian recognition and enforcement process – not just at the point of first-instance application.
Russian civil procedure does not offer a single appellate path. The structure of appeals cassation review depends on whether the recognition application was heard by a commercial arbitrazh court (if the award debtor is a commercial entity and the dispute is commercial in nature) or a court of general jurisdiction (for awards involving individuals or matters outside commercial arbitrazh jurisdiction). The overwhelming majority of foreign arbitral award enforcement matters against Russian corporate counterparties proceed through the arbitrazh court system.
Within the arbitrazh court system, a first-instance recognition decision is subject to appeal to the relevant circuit-level appellate arbitrazh court, and then to cassation review – first before the cassation arbitrazh court for the relevant circuit and, where a point of law of federal significance arises, before the Judicial Panel for Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court. Each tier of review is a further opportunity for the Article V(2)(b) ground to be raised, developed, or reassessed.
The procedural dynamics at cassation are distinct from those at appeal. At the appellate stage, the court reviews the first-instance decision on both factual and legal grounds. At cassation, review is in principle confined to questions of law – the cassation court examines whether the lower courts correctly applied the substantive and procedural rules, including the Convention's recognition framework. In practice, the Article V(2)(b) public policy ground is particularly well-adapted to cassation proceedings because it is framed as a question of legal principle rather than factual finding: whether enforcement of the award would contravene the fundamental principles of Russian law is, inherently, a legal question.
For in-house counsel managing a portfolio of Russian counterparty relationships, this structural feature of the appeals cassation review process means that an apparently successful first-instance recognition order is not the end of the analysis. Enforcement parties who proceed to asset attachment or execution without accounting for the remaining cassation window frequently encounter proceedings that restart from a tactically disadvantaged position.
"
"The public policy ground under Article V(2)(b) has always been formally narrow in Russian law – what 2027 reveals is that cassation courts are prepared to apply it more actively in specific transaction categories than first-instance practice suggested."— Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners
"
If your company holds or is seeking to enforce a foreign arbitral award against a Russian counterparty and the recognition order faces appellate or cassation challenge, early case analysis is essential — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The companies most directly affected by the 2027 developments in appeals cassation review are foreign corporate groups that: hold outstanding foreign arbitral awards against Russian subsidiaries, affiliates, or state-adjacent counterparties; are mid-process in recognition proceedings and have not yet obtained an enforceable Russian court order; or are assessing the strategic value of obtaining a new award in circumstances where the Russian counterparty may have available assets.
The EAEU and CIS dimension adds a further layer for multinationals with regional exposure. For awards rendered in EAEU member state proceedings or under CIS-affiliated institutional rules, the applicable treaty framework for recognition in Russia is not exclusively the New York Convention – bilateral and multilateral agreements within these regional frameworks may provide alternative or overlapping recognition routes. In practice, however, Russian courts frequently apply the New York Convention framework by analogy even where a regional treaty is nominally applicable, and the Article V(2)(b) public policy analysis that has evolved in 2027 tends to be deployed consistently across recognition routes. Foreign multinationals operating through regional structures should not assume that routing an award through a EAEU-seat institution insulates the recognition process from the public policy scrutiny that has characterised cassation review in this period.
For in-house counsel, the practical consequence is that enforcement strategy must now be conceived across the full tier structure from the outset. Decisions about jurisdiction clauses in new contracts with Russian counterparties, the choice of arbitral seat and institutional rules, and the drafting of award-triggering provisions all affect the downstream appeals cassation review exposure in Russian proceedings. The loss of an enforceable award through a successful Article V(2)(b) cassation challenge – after years of arbitral proceedings and a successful first-instance recognition application – represents an exposure that many general counsel teams have not fully priced into their Russian counterparty risk assessments.
Vetrov & Partners advises foreign companies on recognition and enforcement strategy across the full appeals cassation review process in Russia. To discuss your matter in confidence, contact info@vetrovpartners.com |
Three practical steps follow from the developments described above.
First, any company holding a foreign arbitral award against a Russian counterparty and currently pursuing or contemplating recognition proceedings in Russia should obtain a current procedural assessment that maps the Article V(2)(b) exposure specific to the award and counterparty type. General assessments prepared before 2027 may not reflect the current cassation-tier approach in the relevant circuit.
Second, companies that have already obtained a first-instance recognition order should review whether the statutory cassation window remains open and, if so, whether the counterparty has filed or indicated an intention to file. Where a cassation challenge is probable – particularly in cases involving state-affiliated counterparties or awards with a real property dimension – preservation of enforcement position requires active procedural management, including potential asset-freezing applications, during the review period.
Third, in-house counsel reviewing template dispute resolution clauses for new Russian-counterparty contracts should consider whether the current public policy landscape in Russian cassation review alters the relative attractiveness of specific arbitral seats and institutional rules. Courts applying Article V(2)(b) in Russia have shown sensitivity to the institutional provenance of certain awards; this is a factor that belongs in the contract-drafting calculus, not only in post-award strategy.
For current analysis of the practice area and a review of how these developments apply to your specific counterparty exposure, the firm's Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice page sets out the full scope of available support.
Q: What specifically changed in Russian courts' approach to Article V(2)(b) in 2027?
A: The formal standard – that the public policy exception must be applied narrowly and only where fundamental principles of Russian law are at stake – has not been revised. What changed in practice is the application of that standard at the cassation tier of the appeals cassation review process. Courts in 2027 have demonstrated a more searching Article V(2)(b) analysis in three categories: awards against state-affiliated counterparties, awards involving Russian real property or subsoil rights, and awards from institutions whose procedural rules changed materially after 2022. For in-house counsel, the consequence is that a successful first-instance recognition order now carries a higher appellate and cassation risk than it did under earlier practice, particularly in these specific matter categories.
Q: Which foreign companies are most affected by these developments in appeals cassation review?
A: The companies most directly exposed are those holding foreign arbitral awards against Russian corporate counterparties in the categories identified above, and those in the middle of recognition proceedings where the counterparty has not yet exhausted its review rights. EAEU and CIS-connected multinationals should note that the Article V(2)(b) analysis applied in Russian cassation proceedings tends to follow New York Convention doctrine even where a regional treaty is technically applicable. In practical terms, any foreign company that has not reviewed its enforcement strategy in Russia against the current cassation practice is operating with an outdated risk picture.
Q: What concrete steps should in-house counsel take in light of these developments?
A: Three steps are most immediately relevant. First, obtain an updated Russian-law assessment of Article V(2)(b) exposure for any live or pending enforcement matter – this analysis should be specific to the award, the counterparty type, and the circuit. Second, if a first-instance recognition order has already been granted, verify whether the cassation window is still open and consider asset-preservation measures during that period. Third, review dispute resolution clauses in new Russian-counterparty contracts with the current public policy landscape in mind: seat and institutional-rules choices affect downstream cassation exposure. Vetrov & Partners can assist with each of these steps through its Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry