Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Russian court practice on choice-of-law issues in cross-border contracts with Russian parties against insolvency estates: 2026 update

Vitaliy Vetrov · February 2026 · 9 min read

Russian courts now override foreign governing law clauses in insolvency matters. What GCs with Russian counterparties must know. Make an enquiry.

Foreign companies that structured their Russian relationships under English, German, or Swiss governing law are encountering a materially altered landscape in 2026. Russian courts — in particular commercial courts (arbitrazh courts) administering insolvency proceedings — have consolidated a line of practice under which contractually chosen foreign law yields, in whole or in part, to mandatory Russian law once an estate comes under bankruptcy supervision. The development affects every in-house team managing receivables, guarantees, or security rights against a Russian counterparty that has entered or is approaching insolvency: the governing law clause that anchored your transaction documentation may no longer perform the function you assigned to it.

What changed in Russian court practice on choice-of-law issues in 2025–2026?

Until relatively recently, Russian courts took a broadly permissive approach to party autonomy in commercial contracts. A foreign governing law clause in a cross-border agreement would ordinarily be respected by Russian arbitrazh courts adjudicating disputes, provided the clause met the formal requirements of Russian private international law. That position has been qualified — progressively and, as of the first quarter of 2026, with some consistency — in the specific context of insolvency.

The shift operates along two related lines. First, arbitrazh courts administering insolvency proceedings have applied the principle that the lex fori concursus — the law of the jurisdiction in which insolvency proceedings are opened, which is Russian law in each of these cases — governs not merely the procedural conduct of the estate but also the substantive determination of which claims are valid, how security rights rank, and whether particular contractual arrangements (set-off, netting, acceleration) produce the consequences the parties agreed. Second, courts have identified a category of Russian insolvency norms as mandatory rules (imperativnye normy) that displace the chosen foreign law regardless of party intention.

The practical effect is asymmetric: a foreign creditor holding an English-law-governed loan agreement with a Russian borrower, now in insolvency, cannot assume that English-law concepts of acceleration, cross-default, or subordination will be applied by the Russian insolvency trustee or confirmed by the arbitrazh court in the same way they would be applied before an English court. The court will characterise the claim, assess the validity of the security, and determine priority under Russian insolvency legislation — with the foreign governing law acknowledged in principle but overridden in substance wherever it conflicts with mandatory Russian insolvency rules.

One further development, specific to 2026, concerns the treatment of contractual set-off rights under foreign law. Courts have declined to give effect to contractually agreed netting provisions governed by foreign law where the counterparty is an insolvency estate, treating such provisions as potentially preferential and subject to avoidance analysis under Russian insolvency legislation. This is a direct departure from the pre-insolvency enforcement logic and requires immediate attention from finance and legal teams managing exposure to Russian estate counterparties.

"

"What Russian courts are now applying is not a blanket rejection of party autonomy — it is a structural priority: mandatory insolvency rules take precedence, and foreign governing law operates only in the space those rules leave open."— Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

" — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

If your company holds receivables or security rights under a foreign-law-governed contract with a Russian party now in insolvency proceedings, the procedural window for establishing your claim is typically limited — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Which foreign companies and in-house teams are most directly affected?

The development is not uniformly material for all foreign companies with Russian contractual exposure. Its significance scales with three factors: the nature of the claim, the type of security held, and the stage of the counterparty's financial distress.

Claims most at risk of characterisation under Russian law. Subordinated or inter-company loans governed by foreign law are the category where the gap between foreign-law intent and Russian-law outcome is sharpest. Russian insolvency legislation applies a structural subordination analysis to related-party claims that has no direct equivalent in most European governing law frameworks. Where the foreign governing law provides for pari passu ranking between an affiliate lender and third-party creditors, the Russian court may re-characterise the affiliate claim as subordinated, irrespective of the governing law clause.

Trade receivables under foreign-law sales contracts are a second material category. Where a foreign supplier extended credit terms to a Russian distributor — now insolvent — under an English or German-law governed supply agreement, the validity and priority of the current account balance will be assessed under Russian insolvency law. The governing law clause does not insulate the claim from the Russian insolvency framework.

Security rights — pledges over Russian-sited assets, retention-of-title clauses, and hypothecation arrangements — present a third area of exposure. Russian insolvency legislation regulates secured creditor rights directly and treats any purported enforcement mechanism under foreign law that conflicts with the statutory regime as unenforceable in the Russian proceedings. An in-house team relying on, for example, a retention-of-title clause under German law in respect of goods already delivered to and held by the Russian estate will find the provision substantively overridden.

EAEU and CIS dimension. For companies with Russian contractual counterparties who are also EAEU or CIS members — a structurally significant category — the applicable private international law framework includes treaty-level provisions that do not simply replicate Russian domestic private international law. Courts have not always applied the treaty framework with precision, and in insolvency contexts the domestic Russian mandatory-rule logic has tended to prevail over the treaty default. This is a further area of uncertainty for in-house teams whose Russian counterparties are incorporated or co-headquartered in EAEU member states.

The segment of foreign companies most directly affected by the 2026 practice update is, in practical terms, the in-house legal function of any multinational that (i) extended credit to a Russian entity under a non-Russian governing law, (ii) holds a security interest over Russian-sited assets, or (iii) entered into netting or set-off arrangements with a Russian counterparty. For GCs who had not factored the Russian insolvency law override into their exposure modelling, the current case line represents a material recalibration.

For in-house counsel whose company has Russian-law insolvency exposure under foreign-law contracts — request our practice review on cross-border disputes and insolvency: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What should foreign companies do now?

The immediate priority for most in-house teams is to complete an exposure audit across live Russian counterparty relationships and to identify, within that portfolio, which contracts carry a choice-of-law clause that may be displaced in a Russian insolvency context.

That audit should address three practical questions. First: has the Russian counterparty filed for insolvency or entered a pre-insolvency restructuring procedure? The trigger point for the mandatory-rule override is the commencement of formal proceedings. Where proceedings have not commenced, the foreign governing law clause remains fully operative in bilateral enforcement; the risk materialises at insolvency, not before.

Second: is the relevant claim one that the Russian insolvency trustee will characterise differently under Russian law than under the contractually chosen foreign law? The categories most at risk are identified in the previous section. Where the claim is an arm's-length trade receivable with no security dimension and no set-off component, the insolvency-override risk is lower, though not eliminated.

Third: is there a residual enforcement path outside the Russian insolvency proceedings? Where the debtor has assets in a third jurisdiction, and where the governing law clause and dispute resolution clause together support enforcement in that jurisdiction, the Russian insolvency proceedings do not automatically preclude parallel enforcement. The interaction between Russian insolvency law and foreign enforcement proceedings is a distinct analytical question — see Navigating choice-of-law issues in cross-border contracts with Russian parties and Strategic considerations in choice-of-law issues in cross-border contracts for broader analysis.

For companies that have not yet entered a live insolvency situation but are managing distressed Russian counterparties, the current practice development supports a reconsideration of contract documentation for new or renegotiated credit arrangements with Russian parties. Specifically: where the commercial relationship requires Russian-side asset security, structuring the security arrangement under Russian law from the outset — and ensuring that the security is perfected under Russian law — produces a materially more predictable enforcement position than relying on a foreign-law security document in the event of subsequent insolvency.

The Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice at Vetrov & Partners regularly advises foreign companies on the enforcement of foreign-law-governed claims in Russian insolvency proceedings, including creditor registration, challenge of trustee decisions, and priority assessment. The Matters section of the website includes representative examples of creditor-side mandates handled by the firm.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice regarding choice-of-law clauses in cross-border contracts against insolvency estates?

A: The core development is that Russian arbitrazh courts administering insolvency proceedings have consolidated a practice of applying Russian insolvency legislation as a body of mandatory rules that override contractually chosen foreign law. This applies to claim characterisation, security enforcement, and the validity of netting and set-off arrangements. The shift is not a statutory amendment — there has been no change to the Russian private international law framework itself. It is a doctrinal development in how courts apply the existing framework once the lex fori concursus logic is engaged by the commencement of insolvency proceedings. For in-house teams, the practical effect is that a foreign governing law clause in a pre-insolvency commercial contract does not carry the same protective force in a Russian insolvency context that it would in bilateral pre-insolvency enforcement.

Q: Which types of foreign companies are most directly affected by this court practice development?

A: The highest exposure sits with multinationals that extended credit to Russian entities under English, German, or Swiss governing law; companies holding pledge or security interests over Russian-sited assets documented under foreign law; and trading companies with set-off or netting arrangements against Russian counterparties. In-house teams in manufacturing, wholesale distribution, and financial services with significant Russian receivables books are the primary affected constituency. Companies whose Russian exposure is limited to arm's-length trade payables with no credit or security dimension face lower, though not zero, risk from the mandatory-rule override.

Q: What should an in-house team do if their company holds claims under a foreign-law contract against a Russian insolvency estate?

A: The immediate step is to confirm, through Russian counsel, whether the Russian insolvency proceedings are at a stage where creditor registration remains open — timelines under Russian insolvency legislation are strict, and late registration typically results in relegation to a subordinated queue of post-deadline claims. Simultaneously, the in-house team should instruct a review of whether the governing law clause and security documentation can support a parallel enforcement action in a third jurisdiction where assets may be held. It is also advisable to assess, at the outset, whether the claim will be subject to re-characterisation — affiliate loan versus trade receivable, secured versus unsecured — before the Russian trustee forms a provisional position.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry