Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Cross-border Disputes

Russian court practice on LCIA arbitration involving Russian parties at the first instance stage: 2026 update

Vitaliy Vetrov · January 2026 · 9 min read

Russian courts reshaped their approach to LCIA arbitration clauses in 2026. What in-house counsel with Russian exposure must know. Make an enquiry.

For in-house counsel managing Russian subsidiaries or counterparty relationships governed by LCIA arbitration clauses, the opening months of 2026 bring material changes to the first-instance procedural landscape in Russia. Russian arbitrazh courts — the commercial courts of first instance — have developed a more assertive posture in matters where LCIA arbitration involving Russian parties is engaged: they have extended their scrutiny of arbitration clause validity, refined the procedural conditions under which a Russian court will decline jurisdiction in favour of LCIA proceedings, and consolidated an approach to interim relief applications that diverges in important respects from the assumptions embedded in pre-2022 contract drafting. General counsel who designed their dispute resolution clauses in an earlier regulatory environment should treat this update as a prompt for clause review.

§ I. What changed in Russian first-instance practice in 2026?

Russian first-instance courts did not previously ignore LCIA arbitration clauses. The established position — inherited from the pre-2022 period — was that a validly constituted foreign arbitration clause would, in principle, be honoured: the arbitrazh court would decline jurisdiction on a defendant's application and refer the matter to arbitration. That position has not been formally reversed. What has changed is the threshold analysis applied by Russian courts of first instance when assessing whether a clause is "valid" and "enforceable" for the purposes of declining jurisdiction.

In 2025 and into early 2026, Russian first-instance practice consolidated around a cluster of grounds on which courts are prepared to conduct an independent assessment of the clause, rather than referring it to the arbitral tribunal under the kompetenz-kompetenz principle. These grounds broadly correspond to three categories: first, where the clause is alleged to be void as contrary to the exclusive jurisdiction of Russian courts by operation of Russian law — a category that expanded following amendments to the arbitration procedure rules in 2022 and 2023; second, where a Russian party argues that the clause was concluded by a person lacking authority under the constituent documents of a Russian legal entity; and third, where the clause is challenged on grounds that could be characterised as procedural unconscionability — including asymmetric clause structures that were common in financing agreements with Russian entities.

The before-and-after framing is precise: before the 2022–2023 amendments, a Russian first-instance court would, in the majority of contested cases, stay domestic proceedings and refer the jurisdiction question to the arbitral tribunal. After those amendments, Russian courts of first instance have — in a material share of the reported cases — retained jurisdiction pending resolution of the validity question. The effect is that the first-instance stage, not the recognition stage, has become the primary battlefield for LCIA arbitration involving Russian parties. What was once a downstream enforcement problem is now an upstream procedural contest.

For in-house counsel reviewing LCIA clauses covering Russian entities, the procedural exposure begins at the Russian first-instance stage — not at the enforcement stage. Make an enquiry to assess your clause: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Which foreign companies are most affected by this development?

The change in first-instance practice is not evenly distributed across counterparty types or contract structures. The entities most directly affected fall into three categories.

First, foreign companies holding framework agreements or long-term supply contracts with Russian legal entities, where the dispute resolution clause designates LCIA London arbitration. These are the contracts most frequently at issue in first-instance jurisdiction challenges, because the Russian counterparty — facing a claim — has a direct procedural incentive to argue clause invalidity before a domestic court before the LCIA tribunal is constituted.

Second, foreign shareholders in Russian joint ventures where the shareholders' agreement contains an LCIA clause. Russian arbitrazh courts apply a distinct analysis to disputes that touch on the governance of Russian legal entities, treating certain shareholder claims as falling within the exclusive competence of Russian courts regardless of the contractual dispute resolution mechanism. The scope of this exclusion has widened incrementally since 2022, and the first-instance courts have been consistent in applying it.

Third, foreign creditors with pledge or security arrangements governed by Russian law where the underlying credit agreement contains an LCIA clause. Russian first-instance courts have taken the position — consistently in recent practice — that enforcement of Russian-law security requires Russian court involvement, and that an LCIA clause in the primary agreement does not displace Russian jurisdiction over the security enforcement step.

For each of these categories, the risk is the same in structure if different in detail: a Russian counterparty or debtor commences first-instance proceedings in Russia, argues that the LCIA clause is invalid or inapplicable, and obtains an interim determination from the Russian court before the LCIA tribunal has had an opportunity to rule on its own jurisdiction. Companies with live LCIA clauses covering Russian counterparties should note that the limitation period for commencing Russian arbitrazh proceedings runs independently of LCIA proceedings — a domestic first-instance filing timed to pre-empt a London arbitration remains a practical tool available to Russian parties, and it is used.

"The primary strategic shift in 2026 is that first-instance courts have moved from procedural deference to substantive scrutiny of LCIA clauses — which means that the validity of a clause that seemed settled at the drafting stage is now genuinely contestable at the Russian court stage." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners

§ III. What should foreign companies with LCIA clauses do now?

The practical implications of this shift fall into three areas, each of which requires different action depending on where a company sits in its contractual lifecycle.

Clause review — active contracts. For general counsel with existing LCIA clauses covering Russian parties, the first step is an assessment of whether the clause falls into any of the vulnerability categories described above: exclusive Russian jurisdiction arguments, authority questions under the Russian entity's documents, or asymmetric structure. The Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice at Vetrov & Partners conducts targeted clause assessments for foreign companies in this position — a structured review of the clause against current Russian first-instance practice, delivered in English. The output is a practical risk rating and, where warranted, a redrafting recommendation for future contracts.

Monitoring active disputes. For companies already in LCIA proceedings where the Russian counterparty has not yet commenced first-instance proceedings in Russia, early-stage monitoring of the Russian commercial court register is advisable. Russian first-instance filings are publicly registered. The firm offers an ongoing monitoring facility for clients with active LCIA matters involving Russian entities. Related context on the broader procedural landscape is set out in our comparative analysis of LCIA arbitration involving Russian parties and in our practice briefing on LCIA arbitration involving Russian parties.

Interim relief coordination. Where a Russian first-instance court has been seised of proceedings — or is likely to be — the question of coordinated interim relief arises: whether to apply to the Russian court for measures that preserve assets pending the LCIA arbitration, and how to sequence that application against the LCIA tribunal's own jurisdiction on interim relief. The two processes are not mutually exclusive under Russian procedural law, but their interaction requires careful management at the first-instance stage. Our matters page contains anonymised references to matters in which the firm has coordinated interim relief applications at the Russian first-instance stage in parallel with foreign arbitral proceedings.

If your company holds an LCIA clause covering a Russian party and you have not reviewed its exposure in light of current Russian first-instance practice, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ IV. What questions remain open?

Several questions at the intersection of LCIA arbitration and Russian first-instance practice remain without settled answers as of January 2026.

The most significant is the treatment of LCIA clauses in contracts governed by Russian law. Russian first-instance courts have not adopted a uniform position on whether a choice of Russian law as the governing law of a contract carries any implication for the validity of a foreign arbitration clause. Some first-instance courts have treated Russian law governing clauses as a neutral factor; others have treated them as a pointer toward Russian court jurisdiction on validity questions. The cassation courts have not yet resolved this divergence definitively.

A second open question concerns the standard for granting a stay of Russian first-instance proceedings pending the LCIA tribunal's determination of its own jurisdiction. The applicable test is not codified; it is applied by first-instance courts on a case-by-case basis with reference to principles of procedural economy and the risk of contradictory decisions. Practice in the major commercial centres — Moscow, St Petersburg, Novosibirsk — differs in nuance, and those differences affect the strategic sequencing of parallel proceedings.

Finally, the position on costs awarded by a Russian first-instance court in a jurisdiction challenge that the Russian court ultimately resolves in favour of the LCIA clause remains unpredictable. There is no established tariff; the discretion applied by first-instance courts varies considerably.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in Russian first-instance courts' treatment of LCIA clauses in 2025–2026?

A: Russian arbitrazh courts of first instance — the commercial courts that hear claims involving Russian legal entities — progressively extended their willingness to conduct independent assessments of LCIA arbitration clause validity, rather than deferring that question to the arbitral tribunal. The change follows amendments to the Russian arbitration procedure rules enacted in 2022 and consolidated in practice during 2023–2025. The practical result is that first-instance courts in a material share of contested cases will now examine whether the clause is valid, rather than staying proceedings and referring the jurisdiction question to the LCIA tribunal. This is a procedural shift, not a formal legislative change: the statutory framework for recognising foreign arbitration agreements has not been repealed, but the conditions courts apply when scrutinising those agreements have tightened.

Q: Which types of foreign company are most exposed to Russian first-instance challenges to LCIA clauses?

A: Three categories carry the highest exposure. First, foreign companies with long-term supply or commercial contracts designating LCIA London arbitration and involving Russian legal entity counterparties — these are the most frequently contested. Second, foreign shareholders in Russian joint ventures, where Russian courts have extended exclusive jurisdiction over certain shareholder disputes regardless of contractual arbitration clauses. Third, foreign creditors holding Russian-law security where the primary credit agreement contains an LCIA clause: Russian first-instance courts have consistently treated Russian-law security enforcement as requiring Russian court involvement, separate from the contractual dispute resolution mechanism. Companies in all three categories should treat the Russian first-instance stage as a live risk, not a deferred enforcement question.

Q: What practical step should a foreign company take if its Russian counterparty commences first-instance proceedings in Russia despite an LCIA clause?

A: The immediate priority is to assess whether to appear and contest jurisdiction in the Russian first-instance proceedings, or whether a non-appearance strategy better preserves the company's position in the LCIA arbitration. Both approaches carry procedural risk. Appearing and losing the jurisdiction argument may create a res judicata complication in the arbitration; non-appearance forfeits the right to contest in the Russian proceedings and may result in a default determination. The correct approach depends on the specific clause, the nature of the claim, and whether the Russian court is applying general commercial procedure or one of the expanded exclusive jurisdiction provisions. Early-stage advice from Russian counsel is essential before the response deadline in the Russian proceedings.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry