Russian courts apply Article V(2)(b) of the New York Convention with growing scrutiny in ICC matters. What in-house counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.
Following amendments to the Russian civil procedural framework and a discernible shift in how Russian arbitrazh courts approach the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards, 2025 and early 2026 brought renewed attention to Article V(2)(b) of the New York Convention — the public policy exception — as applied to ICC awards in Russia-related commercial disputes. Foreign companies holding ICC awards against Russian counterparties, or anticipating future arbitral proceedings with Russian entities, face a recognition landscape that has become both more codified in rhetoric and less predictable in outcome. Understanding precisely what changed, who is affected, and what in-house counsel should do now is the practical priority.
The public policy exception under Article V(2)(b) of the New York Convention permits a court of the enforcement jurisdiction to refuse recognition or enforcement of a foreign arbitral award where doing so would be contrary to the public policy of that country. Russian courts have always retained this ground as a residual tool, but its application had historically been treated with relative restraint — consistent, broadly, with the established international approach of confining "public policy" to fundamental principles rather than domestic statutory compliance.
What shifted across 2025 and into early 2026 is the interpretive breadth Russian courts have applied when characterising what qualifies as a fundamental principle of Russian public policy in the context of cross-border commercial disputes. Two developments stand out.
First, Russian courts — primarily at the circuit cassation level in the Moscow Arbitrazh Court district and in the Siberian Federal District circuits — have issued a series of rulings in which awards rendered by international institutional arbitration bodies, including the ICC International Court of Arbitration, were refused recognition on Article V(2)(b) grounds where the underlying contract involved a Russian state-linked counterparty or a sector subject to Russian regulatory oversight. The reasoning in these rulings characterised state economic interests and the integrity of regulated sectors as components of Russian public policy for enforcement purposes.
Second, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation issued guidance — in the form of a review of judicial practice — clarifying that Russian courts should assess public policy not only at the moment of enforcement but prospectively, meaning that the economic and regulatory context prevailing at the time of the recognition application is the operative frame, not the context at the time the award was rendered. This prospective reading materially expands the scope for successful Article V(2)(b) objections in Russia-related ICC matters where the factual background has evolved between the date of the award and the date of the enforcement application.
Foreign claimants who secured ICC awards in 2023 or 2024 and delayed enforcement in Russia may now face a more difficult recognition environment than existed when their awards were issued. Under Russian procedural rules, the window for initiating enforcement after an arbitral award is issued is three years from the date on which the award became enforceable — a deadline that creditors and in-house counsel occasionally treat as a planning buffer when it should be treated as a hard outer limit, particularly given that the evidentiary and procedural landscape continues to shift.
If your company holds an ICC arbitral award with enforcement potential in Russia — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
"The practical consequence of the Supreme Court's prospective public policy framing is that enforcement applications submitted today will be assessed against the current regulatory environment — not the environment that existed when the ICC tribunal made its award. For in-house counsel advising a multinational with Russian assets, this changes the risk calculus on enforcement timing significantly." — Vitaliy Vetrov, Managing Partner, Vetrov & Partners
The affected population is broader than is sometimes assumed. The 2026 update to Russian court practice on Article V(2)(b) matters in Russia-related ICC arbitration is directly relevant to the following categories of foreign company:
The position of EAEU member state companies deserves a separate note. For companies domiciled in EAEU member states — Belarus, Kazakhstan, Armenia, Kyrgyzstan — the domestic arbitration and enforcement framework operates partly in parallel with New York Convention procedures. However, where an ICC award is the instrument of record rather than an award from a CIS or EAEU institutional body, the New York Convention framework, including Article V(2)(b), applies in Russian courts. The 2026 shift in interpretive approach therefore affects EAEU-domiciled claimants seeking ICC award enforcement in Russia on the same basis as companies from other New York Convention signatory states.
The profile of disputes where Article V(2)(b) objections are now most likely to succeed — based on publicly reasoned circuit court and cassation decisions reviewed to the date of this analysis — includes: disputes involving Russian state enterprise counterparties; disputes in which the ICC award includes a damages component relating to lost profit on regulated-sector contracts; and disputes where the underlying agreement was entered into before a subsequent regulatory restriction altered the commercial position of the Russian counterparty. None of these categories is new in principle, but the threshold for a successful Article V(2)(b) objection in each has demonstrably lowered.
For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary or a Russia-related enforcement file — request our practice review: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The adjustment required of in-house counsel is procedural as much as strategic. Three lines of action are most relevant.
Review enforcement timing. For any ICC award already rendered against a Russian counterparty, the three-year enforcement window should be reviewed immediately against the date on which the award became enforceable. If that window is within 12 months of closing, the decision to initiate or defer Russian enforcement should be taken with specific legal advice on the current Article V(2)(b) exposure profile of the specific award — not on the basis of prior general assessments made at the time the award was issued.
Conduct a public policy exposure analysis before filing. Any enforcement application to a Russian arbitrazh court should be preceded by a documented analysis of whether the award's subject matter, the identity of the counterparty, or the regulatory context of the underlying contract creates a credible Article V(2)(b) ground under the 2026 interpretive framework. This analysis serves two purposes: it allows the applicant to anticipate and address objections in the recognition brief, and it creates an internal record for the purpose of any parallel enforcement strategy in other jurisdictions where Russian assets may be located.
Consider parallel enforcement strategy. Where Russian enforcement is assessed as high-risk under the current Article V(2)(b) framework, the recovery strategy should account for Russian-linked assets held outside Russia — in EAEU member states, in European jurisdictions, or in other markets where the award-debtor has operational presence. The Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice at Vetrov & Partners regularly coordinates enforcement strategy across jurisdictions in close collaboration with trusted counsel in relevant markets. See also our earlier analysis at How Russian courts approach ICC arbitration and our note on strategic considerations in ICC arbitration involving Russian parties.
Reassess ICC clause drafting in active contracts. For companies whose Russia-related commercial contracts are still in negotiation or under periodic review, the 2026 developments should prompt a reconsideration of the dispute resolution clause. The combination of ICC arbitration with an explicitly agreed enforcement mechanism and governing law that avoids triggering Russian public policy concerns — together with a post-award asset-tracing strategy — is now standard practice-level advice, not a contingency measure. A discussion with Russian qualified counsel at the earliest contractual stage remains the most cost-effective risk mitigation available.
Q: What specifically changed in Russian court practice on Article V(2)(b) in 2025–2026?
A: Two material developments characterise the shift. First, Russian circuit and cassation courts — particularly in the Moscow and Siberian federal districts — broadened their reading of what constitutes a fundamental principle of Russian public policy, extending the concept to encompass state economic interests and the integrity of regulated sectors. Second, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation issued guidance adopting a prospective interpretation of the public policy assessment: courts are now directed to apply the public policy standard as it stands at the date of the enforcement application, not as it stood when the ICC award was rendered. Both developments expand the scope for a successful Article V(2)(b) objection by a Russian respondent, and together they represent a meaningful departure from the more restrained approach that characterised Russian enforcement practice in the preceding decade.
Q: Which foreign companies and ICC claimants are most affected by this shift?
A: The change in interpretive approach is most directly felt by multinationals holding ICC awards against Russian counterparties in regulated sectors — energy, infrastructure, financial services, and transport — and by foreign joint venture partners and trade creditors whose recovery strategy depends on Russian asset enforcement. EAEU member state companies with ICC awards are equally affected: the New York Convention framework applies in Russian courts regardless of the claimant's domicile within the EAEU when the award originates from an ICC or other international institutional arbitration body rather than a CIS or EAEU forum. Companies with awards rendered in 2022–2024 that have not yet initiated Russian enforcement proceedings face the most acute exposure given the combination of the three-year limitation window and the more difficult 2026 recognition environment.
Q: What should in-house counsel do now to protect the enforceability of an ICC award in Russia?
A: Three steps are most important. First, review the enforcement deadline for any existing ICC award against a Russian counterparty — the three-year window from the date the award became enforceable is a hard procedural limit. Second, commission a public policy exposure analysis specific to the award and counterparty before filing any recognition application in Russia — the current Article V(2)(b) interpretive framework requires applicants to anticipate and address objections with greater precision than was previously necessary. Third, consider whether a parallel enforcement strategy targeting Russian-owned assets held outside Russia better serves the recovery objective, either in combination with Russian proceedings or as an alternative. Vetrov & Partners advises on all three steps from a Russian-qualified perspective, with coordination support for foreign jurisdictions through trusted local counsel.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry