Dutch investor's document-production application dismissed in Russian arbitrazh proceedings under New York Convention Article V(2)(b). Cross-border matter, Russia–Netherlands.
Advised foreign investor on document production in Russian court proceedings under New York Convention Article V(2)(b) — claim dismissed
Client. A Dutch holding company with equity interests in a Russian operating subsidiary, engaged in specialised industrial manufacturing within the Siberian Federal District.
Background. Following the conclusion of an international arbitration seated abroad, the opposing party initiated proceedings before a Russian arbitrazh court seeking to resist enforcement of the resulting award on public-policy grounds under New York Convention Article V(2)(b). As part of those proceedings, a collateral application was made requiring the foreign investor to produce internal corporate documents held outside Russia. The scope of the production order was contested — the applicant argued that the documents were necessary to substantiate the public-policy defence; the investor disputed both the jurisdictional basis for compelling production of documents held in a foreign jurisdiction and the characterisation of the underlying award as contrary to Russian public policy.
Our role. The firm advised the Dutch investor on the procedural strategy for resisting the document-production application before the arbitrazh court, including the preparation of written submissions addressing the limits of Russian court jurisdiction over documents held abroad and the standard of proof applicable to Article V(2)(b) public-policy challenges under Russian judicial practice. Counsel also coordinated with the client's Dutch advisers to ensure that responses to the production request were consistent with the investor's obligations under Netherlands law.
Outcome. trademark invalidation attempt rejected; registration upheld. The document-production application was dismissed by the arbitrazh court. The court accepted that the applicant had not met the threshold required to invoke public policy as a bar to enforcement, and the collateral production order fell away. The matter was resolved approximately 11 months from initial instruction.
Discuss a similar matter — info@vetrovpartners.com
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry