MKAS and RAC awards require careful preparation to secure recognition in foreign courts. This practice guide sets out the key steps. Make an enquiry.
In the past several years of advising in-house counsel on cross-border disputes with a Russian dimension, one question recurs with notable consistency: once an award has been rendered by MKAS or the RAC in Russia, what does the recognition process actually look like in a foreign court? The answer is more structured than most GCs anticipate – and more variable than the New York Convention's apparent uniformity suggests. This practice guide sets out the procedural steps, documentation requirements, and practical considerations for foreign companies seeking to recognise a Russian institutional arbitral award in a non-Russian jurisdiction.
Before any court filing, the following materials should be assembled and reviewed. Gaps at this stage are the most common cause of delay in recognition proceedings abroad.
For in-house counsel managing a Russian arbitral award as part of a broader recovery strategy, assembling this package before counsel in the target jurisdiction is formally instructed saves material time and avoids duplicated translation costs.
If your company holds an MKAS or RAC award and is assessing recognition options abroad, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The starting point is not the award itself but the respondent's assets. Recognition proceedings are only commercially meaningful if assets are reachable in the jurisdiction where recognition is sought. This step involves three parallel assessments.
First, confirm where the respondent holds attachable assets – whether real property, receivables, bank deposits, or shareholdings in local entities. The location of assets determines where recognition is most useful. In practice, this analysis often involves coordinating with local counsel in two or three jurisdictions simultaneously before a primary target is selected.
Second, verify that the target jurisdiction is a party to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards. The Convention has a very broad membership, but certain jurisdictions relevant to Russian counterparty assets – including some CIS states – apply reciprocity reservations or subject-matter reservations that can affect the recognition of MKAS and RAC awards. The EAEU and CIS frameworks also provide treaty mechanisms that overlap with, and in some circuits take precedence over, the Convention regime.
Third, consider whether the respondent is likely to challenge recognition. If a challenge is foreseeable, the preparation at Step 0 – the documentation package – becomes the primary line of defence, not a formality.
This is the step where assumptions most frequently cause difficulty. Foreign companies operating in Russia and their advisers often proceed on the basis that the New York Convention provides a universal, largely automatic recognition pathway. In practice, the position is more nuanced, and the consequences of overlooking a jurisdictional gap can be significant: an unenforceable award discovered after a respondent has restructured its assets is a common and preventable outcome.
The New York Convention applies in over 170 states, but its application to MKAS and RAC awards requires specific attention to two points.
First, MKAS – the International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of the Russian Federation – has a long-established institutional record, and its awards are widely treated as commercial arbitration awards within the Convention's scope. RAC – the Russian Arbitration Centre at the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration – is a newer institution, established in 2016, and while it is gaining recognition in cross-border practice, in-house counsel should verify that the target jurisdiction's courts have dealt with RAC awards previously or are prepared to treat RAC proceedings as qualifying commercial arbitration for Convention purposes.
Second, for CIS and EAEU member states, parallel treaty frameworks – including the 1992 Minsk Convention and EAEU-specific mechanisms – may apply alongside or instead of the New York Convention. In some circuits, these mechanisms offer a more direct enforcement pathway; in others, they introduce procedural requirements that supplement the Convention process. This is a point where local counsel in the target jurisdiction must be instructed before a filing strategy is finalised.
With the treaty framework confirmed, the documentation package assembled at Step 0 should be reviewed against the specific requirements of the target jurisdiction's procedural rules. Requirements vary: some jurisdictions require apostille authentication on Russian court-issued documents; others accept notarial certification; some courts in CIS states operate under simplified authentication regimes for documents from Russian institutions.
At this stage, local counsel in the target jurisdiction should be formally instructed. Their role is to advise on: (a) the court of competent jurisdiction for recognition proceedings; (b) the procedural format of the recognition application (ex parte or inter partes); (c) the limitation period for bringing a recognition claim – which varies by jurisdiction and, in some cases, runs from the date of the award rather than the date of attempted enforcement; and (d) any fees or security requirements.
The firm regularly coordinates this instruction process for clients holding Russian awards, acting as the primary point of contact between the Russian-side record and foreign counsel. In a recent matter, the firm acted for a European trade creditor holding an MKAS award in coordinating recognition proceedings across two jurisdictions, ensuring consistent documentation standards and minimising the risk of conflicting procedural challenges. Resolution was achieved within fourteen months of the original award.
For MKAS and RAC awards specifically, it is also advisable to obtain, at this stage, a letter from the relevant institution confirming the procedural history of the case – constitution of the tribunal, conduct of proceedings, and absence of any pending set-aside application before a Russian court. This document is not always required, but it pre-empts a common line of challenge.
For guidance on instructing local counsel and coordinating the documentation package for an MKAS or RAC award, make an enquiry or speak to our team directly: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Recognition proceedings under the New York Convention are not a re-hearing of the merits. The foreign court's review is confined, in principle, to the grounds for refusal set out in the Convention – principally: validity of the arbitration agreement, proper notice and opportunity to present a case, whether the award falls within the scope of the submission to arbitration, whether the award has been set aside or suspended in Russia, and whether recognition would be contrary to the public policy of the enforcing state.
In practice, the public policy ground is the one most frequently invoked by respondents in contested recognition proceedings. Its application varies considerably by jurisdiction. Courts in common-law jurisdictions typically apply a narrow construction: public policy means fundamental procedural fairness, not a merits review. Courts in certain civil-law jurisdictions – and in some CIS states – have historically applied a broader construction, particularly where the respondent raises arguments about due process in the original proceedings or the composition of the tribunal.
For MKAS awards, the institutional track record is a significant practical advantage: the long-standing rules framework, the transparency of its appointment procedure, and the body of reported practice all support a finding that the proceedings met international procedural standards. For RAC awards, counsel should be prepared to address questions about the institution's rules and governance if the respondent raises an unfamiliarity argument in a jurisdiction where RAC awards have not previously been recognised.
The recognition application itself is typically filed with evidence in a single tranche, with the respondent then given an opportunity to file grounds for refusal. Timelines vary substantially – from three to four months in jurisdictions with streamlined enforcement tracks to eighteen months or more in jurisdictions where recognition proceedings are contested and proceed through multiple hearings. In-house counsel should factor this uncertainty into recovery planning and liquidity projections.
The overall landscape of foreign recognition for Russian institutional awards is covered in more depth in our analysis of Supreme Court enforcement trends for MKAS and RAC recognition proceedings and in the country-by-country survey at Recognition of MKAS and RAC awards abroad: a comparative framework. For the broader procedural context, see the firm's Cross-border Disputes & Arbitration practice page.
Recognition and enforcement are distinct steps, although they are often conflated. Recognition is the foreign court's formal acknowledgement that the award is valid and binding in that jurisdiction. Enforcement – the actual compulsion of payment or transfer of assets – requires a further procedural step in most jurisdictions: typically the issuance of a writ of execution, registration of the award as a local judgment, or appointment of a bailiff or enforcement officer.
Once recognition is granted, the following actions are typically required in parallel:
The risk of asset dissipation between the recognition order and actual enforcement is real and, in cross-border matters involving Russian counterparties, is not uncommon. Where the respondent holds assets in more than one jurisdiction, a coordinated multi-jurisdiction enforcement strategy – with parallel applications timed to limit the respondent's window for response – is the approach the firm typically recommends for ICP-1 clients managing portfolio recovery.
Information on insolvency-adjacent enforcement steps, including the interaction between foreign recognition proceedings and Russian insolvency filings, is available on the firm's Restructuring & Insolvency practice page and through the Matters section.
Q: What is the difference between MKAS and RAC, and does it matter for recognition abroad?
A: Both MKAS – the International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Russian Chamber of Commerce and Industry – and RAC – the Russian Arbitration Centre at the RANEPA – are institutional arbitration centres based in Russia, and awards from both are, in principle, enforceable under the New York Convention. The practical difference for recognition purposes is one of institutional familiarity: MKAS has operated since 1932 and has a long-established record in cross-border practice, meaning foreign courts across most jurisdictions have encountered its awards. RAC was established in 2016 and, while it is increasingly accepted, counsel should be prepared to address questions about its institutional status and procedural rules in jurisdictions where RAC awards have not previously been before the courts. In most major enforcement jurisdictions, this is a manageable point rather than a substantive barrier.
Q: Which jurisdictions are most reliable for recognising MKAS and RAC awards?
A: Jurisdictions that are full New York Convention signatories without reservations and that maintain efficient commercial court systems – including Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, and several common-law jurisdictions – have generally provided a reliable recognition pathway for Russian institutional arbitral awards. Within the CIS and EAEU zone, the position is more variable: some member states offer streamlined recognition under bilateral or regional treaty frameworks, while others apply procedural requirements that supplement the Convention process and extend timelines. The appropriate jurisdiction for recognition proceedings is ultimately determined by where the respondent holds attachable assets, not by which forum is most favourable in the abstract.
Q: Can a respondent challenge recognition on the basis that the original MKAS or RAC proceedings were unfair?
A: A respondent may raise a due-process challenge under the New York Convention's grounds for refusal – specifically, that it was not given proper notice or was otherwise unable to present its case. In practice, MKAS proceedings conducted under the institutional rules provide a documentary record that makes such challenges difficult to sustain: notice requirements, representation rules, and the composition of the tribunal are governed by established procedural frameworks. Challenges on this basis are not unknown, but they rarely succeed before courts applying the Convention's narrow grounds for refusal. Where proceedings were conducted under the RAC rules, the analysis is similar, though counsel should be prepared to explain the institution's governance structure in jurisdictions where RAC is less well known. A more common and more difficult challenge involves the public policy ground, where outcomes are less predictable and depend heavily on the jurisdiction.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry