Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Case comment: franchise agreement requirements in Russia

Elena Pavlova · January 2026 · 7 min read

Russian courts closely scrutinise franchise agreements for mandatory form and registration. What in-house counsel must know. Make an enquiry.

In a decision handed down in the second half of 2025, a Russian arbitrazh court ruled against a foreign company's attempt to enforce a commercial concession agreement, finding that the agreement did not satisfy the mandatory requirements imposed on franchise arrangements under Russian civil legislation. The ruling is a pointed reminder for in-house counsel overseeing Russian franchise operations: structural compliance is not a formality that can be deferred or delegated without risk. Agreements that do not meet the written form and registration requirements applicable under Russian law may be found unenforceable at the moment they are most needed — during a dispute with a franchisee.

Background: what was the dispute about?

The matter arose between a foreign franchisor and a Russian franchisee following the breakdown of a long-standing commercial relationship. The franchisee had been operating under an arrangement that the foreign company characterised, in commercial terms, as a franchise: it had granted the right to use its brand, trade name, and associated know-how in exchange for ongoing fees structured as royalties.

When the relationship soured, the foreign company sought to enforce the fee obligations and terminate the arrangement on the basis of the written agreement it held. The franchisee resisted, contending that the agreement was not validly constituted as a commercial concession contract under Russian law — and that, as a result, the enforcement mechanism the foreign company sought to invoke could not be applied.

The dispute turned on a question that will be familiar to lawyers advising foreign clients with Russian distribution structures: whether an agreement drafted according to the foreign company's standard form, and not specifically adapted to Russian commercial concession requirements, could be treated as a legally binding franchise arrangement under Russian civil legislation. The court found it could not.

The decision: what did the court hold?

The court's analysis proceeded in two stages. First, it characterised the relationship between the parties. On the evidence — the grant of brand rights, the imposition of operational standards, the royalty payment structure — the court found that the arrangement was, in substance, a commercial concession within the meaning of Russian civil legislation. That characterisation was not disputed by either party.

Second, and critically for the outcome, the court examined whether the formal requirements applicable to commercial concession agreements had been satisfied. Under Russian civil legislation, contracts of this type must be concluded in written form and registered with Rospatent, the federal intellectual property authority. Registration is a condition of validity in relation to third parties and, in the court's reading, a condition that bears on the enforceability of certain obligations between the parties themselves.

The court found that the agreement had not been registered. Notwithstanding the signed document, the court declined to give effect to the royalty enforcement provisions in the manner the foreign company sought. The franchisee's position — that the agreement's non-registration precluded enforcement of the fee obligations as structured — was accepted in material part.

The court also identified deficiencies in the agreement's content. The arrangement, as documented, did not clearly specify the scope of intellectual property rights being licensed, the territory of the concession, or the term — elements that Russian civil legislation treats as essential to a validly constituted commercial concession contract. The absence of these terms reinforced the court's conclusion that the agreement, as drawn, could not ground the enforcement claim as presented.

"

"The pattern is consistent: foreign-standard franchise agreements that have not been localised and registered under Russian civil legislation routinely fail at the enforcement stage, when the relationship is already under strain."— Elena Pavlova, Associate, Vetrov & Partners

" — Elena Pavlova, Associate, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel managing a Russian franchisee network, the regulatory timeline for agreement registration and the consequences of non-compliance leave limited margin for delay. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign companies operating in Russia?

For companies running franchise or brand-licensing arrangements in Russia, this decision — consistent with the prevailing approach of Russian courts on commercial concession validity — has several practical implications that in-house counsel should assess against their existing agreements.

The first concerns characterisation risk. Russian courts will look through the label that parties place on their arrangement. If an agreement, however it is titled, involves the grant of a right to use a brand, trade name, or business method in exchange for payment, a Russian court is likely to characterise it as a commercial concession. That characterisation triggers the formal requirements of the relevant chapter of Russian civil legislation, including the Rospatent registration obligation. Companies operating licensing or distribution arrangements that have franchise-like characteristics should treat this ruling as a prompt to review whether those arrangements are exposed to characterisation risk.

The second concerns the content of the agreement itself. The decision highlights that a commercial concession contract under Russian law must address a defined set of elements: the scope of intellectual property rights granted, the territory, the term, and the fee structure. Standard-form agreements prepared in a foreign jurisdiction — even when translated and signed by a Russian counterparty — frequently do not map onto these requirements. A legally sound agreement will require localisation, not merely translation.

The third, and most consequential for enforcement, concerns the registration gap. Agreements that have been operating without Rospatent registration are vulnerable. In the event of a dispute with a franchisee — precisely the situation where the foreign company most needs the agreement to function — the non-registration point is available to a counterparty seeking to resist enforcement. The window for remedying a registration gap is available while the relationship is functioning normally. It is materially more limited once a dispute has arisen.

Foreign companies listed as trusted advisers by the German Consulate General in Novosibirsk — and more broadly, any multinational maintaining a Russian franchise network — should review whether their current agreements have been registered and whether they contain the mandatory terms identified in this decision. Our Distribution & Franchising practice advises on franchise agreement localisation, registration, and dispute readiness across the Russian market.

For further background on the Supreme Court's guidance on these issues, see our analysis at Russian Supreme Court Clarification on Franchise Agreement Requirements. For a practical guide to navigating the requirements from the outset, see Navigating Franchise Agreement Requirements in Russia.

Foreign companies with existing franchise or brand-licensing structures in Russia may also wish to review how enforcement risk interacts with cross-border disputes before a counterparty relationship breaks down. Our Matters page includes representative mandates across distribution and franchise disputes.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The decision reinforces — rather than creates — an established principle of Russian franchise law: commercial concession agreements that are not registered with Rospatent, or that omit mandatory terms, are vulnerable to challenge at the enforcement stage. What the ruling adds to the picture is a clear illustration of how a court will approach an agreement drafted to foreign standards rather than to Russian civil legislation requirements. For in-house counsel, the practical change is this: the assumption that a signed franchise agreement is a workable enforcement instrument, without further verification of Russian law compliance, is no longer tenable. The registration requirement and the mandatory content rules apply regardless of the sophistication of the parties or the commercial history of the relationship.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign companies holding franchise or brand-licensing agreements with Russian counterparties should take three steps. First, identify whether any existing arrangement is likely to be characterised as a commercial concession under Russian civil legislation — the functional test applied by courts is broader than the contractual label. Second, verify whether any such agreement has been registered with Rospatent, and if not, assess the risk profile of proceeding without registration against the steps required to regularise. Third, review the agreement's substantive terms against the mandatory content requirements — scope of IP rights, territory, term, fee structure — and localise where necessary. Each of these steps is more straightforward when the franchisee relationship is intact; they become markedly more complex once a dispute is on foot.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry