Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Comparative analysis: IP licence as component of a Russian franchise and international standards

Elena Pavlova · June 2026 · 16 min read

Foreign companies structuring Russian franchises face material differences in IP licence rules. What in-house counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.

In the course of advising foreign companies on Russian distribution and franchise arrangements, one structural tension recurs with notable consistency: the gap between how IP licence obligations are understood under international commercial practice and how Russian law actually frames, registers, and enforces them. For in-house counsel managing a Russian franchise rollout or reviewing an existing commercial concession agreement, that gap is not merely academic. It affects whether the licence is enforceable, whether the sub-licence chain is valid, and whether a dispute arising from the arrangement will be resolved in a forum where the IP rights are even recognised. This analysis examines the principal structural divergences between the Russian legal framework for IP licences within a franchise context and the standards that foreign counsel and their clients typically bring to the table.

§ I. The Russian commercial concession framework: what it is and what it requires

Russian law does not use the term "franchise" as a term of art. The operative concept in the Civil Code is the commercial concession (kommerchesskaya kontsessiya), which is a distinct contractual form with defined mandatory elements. A commercial concession agreement grants the right-holder's counterpart — the user — the right to use a complex of exclusive rights belonging to the right-holder: most notably, the trademark, commercial designation, and know-how associated with the right-holder's business activity.

This framing immediately diverges from the international franchise model in one material respect. In standard international practice, a franchise agreement is principally characterised by the business-format obligations — the operating system, quality standards, marketing support, and territorial exclusivity arrangements. The IP licence element is typically embedded within the franchise agreement or provided as an ancillary schedule, and its terms are largely subordinate to the commercial framework. Under Russian commercial concession law, the logic is inverted: the IP licence is the definitional core of the arrangement. The agreement is constituted by the grant of rights over the intellectual property complex; the business-format obligations are layered on top.

This structural difference has immediate practical consequences. A foreign franchisor that structures its Russia entry by adapting an existing master franchise agreement without attending to the commercial concession rules may find that the document does not qualify as a commercial concession at all, falling instead into the category of an ordinary licence agreement. The regulatory treatment, the registration obligations, and the remedies available on breach differ substantially between those two categories.

The commercial concession framework also imposes minimum content requirements. The agreement must identify the scope of rights transferred, the method of use permitted, the territory of use, and the duration — or expressly confirm that no duration is specified. Failure to address these elements exposes the agreement to challenge on the basis of non-conformity with mandatory norms, which, in practice, courts have interpreted strictly when the relationship breaks down.

If you are reviewing or drafting a Russian commercial concession agreement and need confirmation that its IP licence component meets Russian mandatory requirements — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. IP rights within the franchise structure: what must be licenced and how?

The IP rights complex within a Russian commercial concession typically includes the trademark, the commercial designation (if separately registered or recognised), and know-how. Each element has its own treatment under the Russian legal framework, and they do not all travel together automatically.

The trademark is the most straightforward element. A licence over a Russian trademark — whether granted as part of a commercial concession or independently — must be registered with Rospatent, the Federal Service for Intellectual Property. This is a hard requirement, not a default rule that parties can contract out of. An unregistered trademark licence is not merely unenforceable against third parties; under the prevailing interpretation applied in Russian courts, it is treated as not having come into effect at all with respect to the third-party world. This creates a particular risk for franchise structures where sub-licences are granted to franchisees before Rospatent registration of the head licence is complete.

Rospatent registration of a trademark licence is a procedural step that typically takes several months, and the timeline can extend further if the application is submitted with deficiencies or if the trademark itself is subject to an opposition or cancellation action. In practice, foreign right-holders frequently underestimate this lead time when planning their franchise launch calendar, with the result that franchisees begin operating — and generating consumer recognition and contractual obligations — under a licence that has not yet achieved legal effect under Russian law.

Know-how occupies a different position. Russian law protects know-how as a secret of production — a form of confidential information with defined attributes. Unlike a trademark, know-how does not require registration. However, the right-holder must be able to demonstrate that it has taken reasonable measures to maintain secrecy, and the scope of what constitutes "know-how" for these purposes is construed narrowly. A franchise operations manual that is distributed to all franchisees without appropriate confidentiality protocols may not qualify as protectable know-how, which affects the enforceability of the restrictions the franchisor seeks to impose.

International franchise standards — the approach used in, for example, the UNIDROIT Model Franchise Disclosure Law or the guidelines developed by the International Franchise Association — tend to treat know-how as a broadly defined category encompassing the franchisee training system, proprietary processes, and accumulated operational experience. Russian law is more exacting. In-house counsel should not assume that what qualifies as protectable know-how in the home jurisdiction will receive equivalent treatment in Russia without specific structuring measures.

"The structural divergence between Russian commercial concession law and international franchise practice is most acute precisely where in-house counsel expect alignment: in the IP licence provisions that both systems place at the centre of the relationship." — Elena Pavlova, Associate, Vetrov & Partners

§ III. Rospatent registration mechanics: where the process diverges from international expectations?

The Rospatent registration requirement for IP licences within a Russian franchise structure is the single procedural element most likely to create operational disruption for foreign right-holders. Understanding the mechanics — and the points at which they diverge from what foreign counsel expect — is therefore a practical priority for in-house counsel managing Russia entry.

The registration requirement applies to licences over registered trademarks, registered appellations of origin, and patents. It does not apply to know-how or copyright (the latter is relevant for software and creative works included in the franchise system). A licence agreement covering multiple IP rights therefore requires Rospatent registration only to the extent that it covers registered rights; the know-how and copyright elements take effect between the parties on execution.

The application for registration of a trademark licence must include a description of the goods or services covered, the method of use authorised, the territory, and confirmation of the right-holder's consent. The application may be filed by either party or jointly. Rospatent examines the application for formal compliance and for consistency with the underlying trademark registration — but it does not conduct a substantive review of the commercial terms. This means that an agreement that is commercially one-sided or incomplete in its quality control provisions will pass through Rospatent registration without issue and may then be challenged later, in court proceedings, on grounds that fall outside the registration review entirely.

One structural feature of the Russian registration requirement that frequently surprises foreign counsel is the obligation on the franchisor — as right-holder — to ensure quality control over the goods and services produced or provided by the franchisee. Under the Civil Code, the right-holder bears statutory responsibility to the consumer for the quality of goods and services provided by the user under the commercial concession. This obligation cannot be excluded by contract. Its practical counterpart is that Rospatent, when reviewing a licence application that is embedded in a commercial concession structure, will typically expect to see quality control provisions in the agreement. An agreement that is silent on this point may attract a Rospatent request for clarification, adding to the timeline.

The EAEU dimension adds a further layer of complexity for foreign right-holders operating across multiple member states. The Eurasian Economic Union has a unified trademark system administered by the Eurasian Patent Organisation, and a trademark registered at the EAEU level can be licenced across member states — in principle. However, the interaction between an EAEU-level trademark licence and the Russian domestic registration requirement is not always straightforward, and the prevailing approach in Russian practice is to require domestic Rospatent registration even where the underlying trademark is an EAEU mark. Legal teams managing multi-jurisdiction CIS franchise rollouts should verify the current position rather than assume automatic portability.

§ IV. Sub-licensing within the franchise chain: what do international standards assume that Russian law does not?

One of the structural assumptions that foreign franchise systems carry into the Russian market is that a master franchisee can sub-licence the franchisor's IP rights to sub-franchisees as a matter of standard contractual authority. In most common-law jurisdictions, this is correct as a default position, subject to any restrictions in the head licence. Under Russian law, the sub-licence structure requires careful attention.

Under the Civil Code, a licensee may grant sub-licences only if expressly authorised to do so in the licence agreement. This mirrors a common provision in English-law licences, so the requirement itself is familiar to foreign counsel. The divergence arises at the point of registration. Each sub-licence granted under a registered trademark licence must itself be registered with Rospatent. This is not a matter of the parties' agreement — it is a mandatory rule. A sub-licence that is not registered does not take effect under Russian law with respect to third parties and is treated as not having come into effect in the same manner as an unregistered head licence.

The operational consequence for a master franchise structure is that the franchisor — or the master franchisee acting with appropriate authority — must initiate a separate Rospatent registration application for each sub-licence granted. In a rolling franchise network where new franchisee relationships are established periodically, this creates a recurrent administrative obligation that is not present in equivalent structures in most Western European jurisdictions.

International franchise systems, particularly those developed under the UCC-influenced US model or the German-law Vertragshändler framework, typically treat the IP licence as a once-for-the-network set of rights that travels automatically down the franchise chain once the master licence is in place. That assumption is structurally incompatible with the Russian registration requirement, and franchise operating models built on it will produce periods during which individual franchisees are technically operating without valid Russian IP licence coverage — with the attendant risk of a right-holder enforcement action or third-party challenge.

For in-house counsel reviewing a proposed or existing master franchise arrangement in Russia, the sub-licence registration obligation should be assessed at two levels: first, whether the head licence agreement expressly authorises sub-licensing (and in the appropriate terms under Russian law); and second, whether the administrative infrastructure exists to manage the registration pipeline for each new franchisee relationship as the network grows. Absent that infrastructure, the network faces a systemic legal risk that accumulates silently over time.

Under Russian insolvency and corporate law, in a scenario where the right-holder encounters financial difficulty, unregistered sub-licences may be treated as having no effect, which can leave an operational franchise network without IP cover precisely when the relationship comes under stress.

For in-house counsel managing a Russian franchise network or conducting due diligence on a proposed master franchise acquisition, the sub-licence registration position is a key item for legal review. Firms advising clients with Russian franchise assets will often need a confirmed Russian counsel relationship before the regulatory timeline becomes a live issue. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ V. What does this mean for foreign companies structuring or reviewing a Russian franchise?

The comparative picture that emerges from this analysis is not one in which Russian law is simply more or less protective of franchise IP than international standards — it is structurally different in ways that have direct operational implications for foreign right-holders.

The five key divergences that in-house counsel should carry into any review of a Russian franchise IP licence structure are these. First, the commercial concession framework is constituted by the IP rights grant, not by the business-format obligations: the IP licence is not a schedule to the franchise agreement, it is the franchise agreement's legal foundation. Second, trademark licence registration with Rospatent is mandatory and constitutive — the absence of registration means absence of legal effect, not merely limited enforceability. Third, the timeline for Rospatent registration is variable and may extend considerably; operational planning that assumes prompt registration creates legal risk during the gap. Fourth, sub-licences in a master franchise structure require individual Rospatent registration for each sub-licence granted — the network cannot rely on the head licence registration covering downstream relationships. Fifth, the right-holder bears a non-excludable statutory responsibility for the quality of goods and services provided by franchisees, which has implications both for contract drafting and for operational quality control obligations.

Against these divergences, there are structural features of the Russian commercial concession framework that align with — and in some respects exceed — international standards. The mandatory quality control obligation that the Civil Code imposes on right-holders corresponds to the best-practice standard in international franchise law, where the absence of quality control provisions in a trademark licence can lead to the doctrine of naked licencing, with the consequence of trademark abandonment. Russian law makes this obligation non-optional, which protects both the integrity of the trademark and, indirectly, the consumer. The requirement that the scope of rights be clearly defined is consistent with the drafting discipline that experienced international franchise counsel apply as a matter of course.

Foreign companies entering the Russian market through a franchise or commercial concession structure — or reviewing an existing arrangement as part of an acquisition, compliance audit, or renegotiation — should treat the IP licence component as a distinct legal analysis, not as a standard attachment to the commercial framework. The Distribution & Franchising practice at Vetrov & Partners advises on the full spectrum of these matters, from initial structuring through Rospatent registration management and franchise network compliance.

Further analysis of the legislative developments affecting IP licence arrangements in the Russian franchise context is available at Legislative amendment affecting IP licence as component of a Russian franchise. A detailed examination of the IP licence as a component of a Russian franchise is set out in IP licence as component of a Russian franchise.

For foreign companies operating through a Russian commercial concession structure, the regulatory timeline leaves limited margin for delay in addressing unregistered sub-licence positions — a risk that can accumulate quietly across an entire network before coming to the surface in enforcement proceedings or a counterparty dispute.

If your company operates or is planning a Russian franchise structure and you need a focused review of the IP licence component — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: Does a franchise agreement governed by foreign law need to comply with Russian commercial concession rules if the franchise operates in Russia?

A: Yes, in practice. Where a franchise arrangement involves a franchisee conducting business in Russia — using a trademark in the Russian market, operating under a recognised commercial designation, or granting sub-licences to Russian entities — Russian courts will apply Russian law to the IP licence component as a matter of public policy, regardless of any governing-law clause. The commercial concession rules are treated as mandatory norms of Russian law that cannot be displaced by a foreign choice-of-law agreement. Foreign right-holders structuring arrangements with Russian governing-law carve-outs should verify that the IP licence terms satisfy Russian commercial concession requirements as a separate compliance step.

Q: What happens if a trademark licence within a Russian franchise is not registered with Rospatent?

A: An unregistered trademark licence within a Russian franchise structure is treated under the prevailing judicial interpretation as not having come into effect with respect to third parties. In practical terms, this means that a franchisee operating under an unregistered licence cannot rely on the licence as a defence in infringement proceedings brought by a third party, and the right-holder may be exposed to claims that the franchise network's use of the mark was unlicensed. Between the parties, the agreement may still create contractual obligations, but the IP protection that the licence is intended to provide is absent until registration is complete. This underscores the importance of initiating Rospatent registration promptly upon execution of the commercial concession agreement, rather than treating it as an administrative formality to be addressed later.

Q: Is know-how automatically protected within a Russian franchise structure?

A: Know-how protection in a Russian franchise context is not automatic and depends on the right-holder having taken adequate measures to maintain the confidentiality of the information concerned. Russian law requires that protectable know-how — described as a secret of production — be subject to a confidentiality regime, which means physical or contractual measures to restrict access, marking of documents, and appropriate employment or counterparty confidentiality obligations. Franchise operations manuals and training materials that are shared broadly across the franchise network without a structured confidentiality framework may fail to qualify as protectable know-how under Russian law, with the consequence that the associated restrictions on franchisee use may not be enforceable. A structured confidentiality protocol, combined with appropriate franchise agreement terms, is therefore a necessary component of know-how protection within a Russian commercial concession structure.

Q: How does the EAEU trademark system interact with Russian domestic IP licence registration requirements?

A: For franchise networks operating across multiple EAEU member states, the EAEU unified trademark system administered by the Eurasian Patent Organisation offers a single registration covering the member state territories. However, the interaction between an EAEU-level trademark licence and the Russian domestic Rospatent registration requirement remains an area where the prevailing practice in Russia is to require a separate Rospatent registration step for licence agreements used in Russian territory, even where the underlying trademark is registered at the EAEU level. Foreign right-holders expanding franchise networks across EAEU jurisdictions should not assume that a single EAEU-level licence registration produces legal effect in Russia without a domestic registration step. This position should be verified on a current basis, as regulatory practice in this area continues to develop.

Q: Can a Russian franchise agreement exclude the right-holder's statutory quality control obligation?

A: No. The statutory obligation on the right-holder to ensure quality control over goods and services provided by the franchisee under a commercial concession is a mandatory provision of the Civil Code and cannot be excluded or modified by contractual agreement. The practical implication is that the right-holder must both include quality control provisions in the commercial concession agreement — to satisfy Rospatent and to structure the relationship — and maintain an operational quality assurance function in relation to the franchise network. The non-excludable nature of this obligation also means that a consumer who suffers loss as a result of sub-standard goods or services provided by a franchisee may bring a claim directly against the right-holder, in addition to or instead of the franchisee. Foreign right-holders should factor this liability exposure into the risk assessment for Russian franchise entry.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry