Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Corporate & Regulatory

Russian court practice on franchise agreement requirements in Russia under Article 1027 of the Civil Code (commercial concession): 2027 update

Elena Pavlova · October 2026 · 10 min read

Russian courts are refining commercial concession standards under Article 1027 of the Civil Code. What in-house counsel must review now. Make an enquiry.

Over the course of 2026 and into 2027, Russian courts have refined their interpretation of the mandatory requirements that a commercial concession agreement must satisfy under Article 1027 of the Civil Code — the statutory provision that governs what international practitioners commonly refer to as franchise agreements. For foreign companies operating in Russia through distribution or franchise structures, the emerging judicial approach introduces a layer of drafting and registration discipline that earlier contract templates may not reflect. In-house counsel reviewing existing arrangements or preparing new ones will find that the gap between a commercially functional franchise and one that is defensible before a Russian court has narrowed, but that the path through it demands careful attention to form, scope, and the Rospatent registration process.

§ I. What has changed — the before and after in Russian court practice

The statutory framework itself has not been amended. Article 1027 of the Civil Code continues to define a commercial concession agreement as a contract by which the right-holder grants the user the right to exploit, in that user's commercial activity, a complex of exclusive rights belonging to the right-holder — principally the right to a trade mark, service mark, or other means of individualisation — in exchange for remuneration. The written form requirement and the Rospatent registration obligation have remained constant features since the relevant chapters of Part IV of the Civil Code came into force.

What has shifted is how Russian courts, including cassation courts within several federal districts, have treated agreements that fall short of the statutory requirements in specific respects. Three patterns have become sufficiently consistent in the case law to warrant attention from practitioners advising foreign companies.

First, courts have increasingly declined to treat commercial concession arrangements as fully valid and enforceable between the parties where the agreement does not clearly identify the means of individualisation being licensed. A generic reference to the right-holder's "brand" or "know-how" without a specific enumeration of registered trade marks, with their Rospatent registration numbers, has been treated by some courts as failing the identification standard implicit in Article 1027. Earlier practice was more permissive: courts tended to look at the commercial substance of the relationship. The more recent approach, as it has developed through 2026, focuses on formal sufficiency — whether, on the face of the agreement, each licensed right is identified with the precision required for the Rospatent registration that must follow.

Second, the consequences of non-registration have been articulated with greater clarity. A commercial concession agreement that has not been registered with Rospatent has consistently been held unenforceable against third parties — this was not new. What recent court practice has added is a more explicit treatment of the position between the parties themselves in cases where one party seeks to rely on the agreement against the other but registration was never completed. While the prevailing judicial approach has not treated non-registration as automatically voiding the agreement between the parties in all circumstances, courts have shown a willingness to apply the unenforceability principle more broadly where it is the right-holder who failed to initiate registration and seeks to enforce payment obligations.

Third, courts have given increased weight to the question of whether the territory clause in a commercial concession agreement meets the specificity standard. Broad territorial descriptions — "territory of the Russian Federation" without further qualification — have generally been upheld. However, agreements covering territories that extend to other EAEU member states, without making clear which national trade mark registrations underpin the rights granted in each jurisdiction, have faced challenge. For foreign companies whose franchise structures span Russia and other EAEU markets, this is a material drafting point.

If your franchise agreements covering Russia and EAEU markets were drafted before 2026, they may not reflect current court standards — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ II. Who is affected — and why does it matter for foreign companies operating in Russia?

The developments described above are directly relevant to three categories of foreign company.

Existing right-holders operating through master franchise structures. A foreign brand owner that has appointed a master franchisee in Russia and relies on a commercial concession agreement drafted several years ago is likely to find that the agreement's identification of licensed rights is insufficiently specific by current court standards. In practice, this means that if the master franchisee relationship deteriorates — if the right-holder seeks to enforce minimum royalty obligations, or to terminate for breach, or to resist a sub-concession the franchisee has granted without authorisation — a Russian court may scrutinise the agreement's formal adequacy before reaching the substantive dispute. The right-holder's ability to rely on the agreement is diminished where formal requirements are not met.

Foreign companies entering new franchise or distribution arrangements in Russia. For in-house counsel structuring a new commercial concession arrangement, the 2027 court environment means that the template agreement — often adapted from an English-law or US-law franchise document — is unlikely to be fit for purpose without material revision. The essential terms required under Russian law, the Rospatent registration mechanism, and the territory and intellectual-property identification obligations must all be addressed as primary drafting concerns, not as boilerplate additions.

Foreign companies participating in EAEU-spanning franchise structures. Russia's membership of the Eurasian Economic Union means that franchise arrangements extending beyond Russia to Kazakhstan, Belarus, Armenia, or the Kyrgyz Republic will engage intellectual property registration requirements in each member state. Russian courts have recently shown an unwillingness to treat EAEU-wide rights grants as automatically flowing from a Russian trade mark registration. Where the commercial concession agreement is governed by Russian law but covers activities in other EAEU states, the agreement should identify the specific national or EAEU-level trade mark registrations that underpin each territorial grant. This is not a new requirement under the EAEU's intellectual property framework, but it is one that recent Russian court practice has made a live enforcement risk rather than a theoretical one.

A further category worth noting is companies that have restructured their Russian operations since 2022 and have in the process altered the identity of the Russian right-holder entity without updating the registered commercial concession agreement at Rospatent. A change in the right-holder's corporate name, or a transfer of the underlying trade mark to a different group entity, requires a corresponding update to the Rospatent registration. Courts have declined to treat obligations under an agreement registered in the name of a former entity as automatically binding on its successor without a properly registered novation or assignment.

"The practical risk for foreign right-holders is not that Article 1027 has changed — it has not — but that courts are now applying its requirements with a precision that earlier generations of franchise agreements were not drafted to meet." — Elena Pavlova, Associate, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel managing Russian franchise structures, a focused review of existing commercial concession agreements against current court standards is a proportionate step — request our practice review: info@vetrovpartners.com |

§ III. What foreign clients should do now

For foreign companies with existing commercial concession agreements in Russia, the immediate priority is a structured review rather than a wholesale redrafting exercise. The review should address four questions.

First, does the agreement identify each licensed intellectual property right with sufficient specificity — by reference to specific Rospatent registration numbers for trade marks and service marks, and by a clear description of any know-how or commercial information included in the licensed complex? If the agreement uses generic language, the identification section should be amended.

Second, is the Rospatent registration current? This means not only that the original agreement was registered, but that any subsequent amendments — changes to royalty structure, additions of sub-concession rights, territorial extensions — have been recorded. Amendments to a commercial concession agreement take effect against third parties from the date of their Rospatent registration, not from the date the parties sign them.

Third, does the territory clause identify, for each geographic scope beyond Russia, the specific intellectual property registrations that support the right-holder's ability to grant rights in that territory? For EAEU-spanning arrangements, this is a drafting vulnerability that has moved from theoretical to practical risk.

Fourth, has there been any change in the corporate identity of either party since registration — a name change, a merger, a transfer of the underlying trade mark to another group entity? If so, the registration record at Rospatent should be verified and, if necessary, updated.

Companies entering new commercial concession arrangements should treat the Rospatent registration process as a primary transaction step rather than an administrative formality to be completed after signing. Courts have declined to draw a sharp distinction between the agreement coming into effect between the parties and its enforceability in a dispute context where registration was treated as optional or deferred.

For further detail on the formal requirements that apply throughout the life of a commercial concession arrangement in Russia, see Navigating franchise agreement requirements in Russia and the firm's deep-dive analysis at Franchise agreement requirements in Russia under Article 1027. The firm's Distribution & Franchising practice page sets out the full scope of advisory services available to foreign companies operating through franchise and distribution structures in Russia. Where arrangements also engage regulatory or licensing considerations, see the firm's Regulatory & Licensing practice for related guidance. A selection of representative mandates is available at Matters.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What specifically changed in how Russian courts apply Article 1027 of the Civil Code to franchise agreements in 2026–2027?

A: The statutory text of Article 1027 has not been amended. What changed is the courts' interpretive approach. Courts across several federal districts have applied the formal requirements — identification of licensed rights, written form, Rospatent registration — with greater precision than earlier case law reflected. In particular, courts have scrutinised whether licensed intellectual property is identified with enough specificity to satisfy the registration standard, and have articulated the consequences of non-registration more explicitly in disputes between the parties themselves, not only in third-party enforcement contexts. The result is that agreements drafted to an older standard may not withstand challenge in a Russian court dispute today.

Q: Which foreign companies are most affected by this shift in Russian court practice?

A: Three groups carry the most direct exposure. First, foreign brand owners operating through master franchise or sub-franchise structures in Russia whose commercial concession agreements were drafted before 2026 and have not been reviewed against current court standards. Second, foreign companies entering new franchise arrangements whose template agreements are based on English-law or US-law precedents and have not been adapted for Russian requirements. Third, companies with EAEU-spanning franchise structures where the agreement covers activities in Kazakhstan, Belarus, Armenia, or the Kyrgyz Republic but does not specify the national or EAEU-level trade mark registrations underpinning each territorial grant. Companies that have restructured their Russian entities since 2022 without updating Rospatent registration records also face heightened risk.

Q: What should a foreign company do now to protect its position under existing commercial concession agreements in Russia?

A: The recommended first step is a structured review of existing agreements against the four criteria outlined in this article: specificity of IP identification, currency of Rospatent registration, adequacy of territory clause for any EAEU scope, and accuracy of party identity following any corporate changes. Where gaps are identified, the remediation path — amendment and re-registration, or in some cases a fresh agreement — is straightforward in procedural terms, but requires attention to the order of steps: Rospatent registration of an amendment takes effect from the registration date, not the signing date, so timing matters. For companies entering new arrangements, building the Rospatent registration into the transaction timeline from the outset avoids the position of being party to an agreement that, while commercially operative, lacks the formal standing to be relied upon in Russian court proceedings.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry