Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Cassation review of defending a Russian trademark portfolio: a critical analysis

Elizaveta Razina · September 2026 · 7 min read

Russian cassation courts have reshaped trademark portfolio defence for foreign brand owners. What in-house counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.

Foreign companies that have invested in Rospatent filing and built a presence in the Russian market frequently discover the limits of that investment only when a third party challenges a registered mark at the cassation stage. By the time a dispute reaches the Russian IP Court sitting as a cassation instance, the procedural latitude available to the rights holder is narrower than most in-house counsel anticipate — and the substantive outcome turns on questions of evidence and argument that should have been addressed one or two stages earlier. This analysis examines a recent cassation ruling in which the court reviewed the merits of defending a trademark portfolio under Russian law, and draws out the practical implications for multinational companies managing Russian IP assets.

Background

The matter concerned a foreign brand owner holding a portfolio of registered marks in Russia covering several product categories. A domestic company initiated invalidity proceedings before Rospatent's Chamber for Patent Disputes, asserting that the foreign registrant's marks had not been put to genuine commercial use within a three-year period following registration — a ground for cancellation well established under Russian IP legislation.

The Chamber upheld the challenge in respect of two marks from the portfolio, finding the evidence of use insufficient. The foreign rights holder appealed to the first-instance commercial court, which affirmed the Chamber's decision on both marks. On further appeal, the appellate court confirmed the lower court's findings, noting that the documentation submitted — principally marketing materials and distributor agreements — did not demonstrate use in the specific form registered or across the specific categories claimed.

The case reached the Russian IP Court at cassation stage. The rights holder sought to introduce supplementary evidence of use, raised arguments about the adequacy of the lower courts' assessment, and contended that the appellate court had applied an unduly restrictive interpretation of what constitutes genuine commercial use under Russian law.

What did the cassation court decide, and why does the reasoning matter?

The IP Court, sitting as the cassation instance, declined to overturn the appellate decision. Several elements of the court's reasoning carry significance beyond the immediate outcome.

First, the court confirmed that a cassation panel does not re-examine the factual record — it reviews only the legal correctness of how the courts below applied the law. Attempts to introduce new factual arguments or additional evidence at cassation stage are procedurally impermissible and, in practice, counterproductive: the court noted that the scope of genuine use is a question of fact already settled by the courts below, and no error of law had been demonstrated in their assessment.

Second, the court addressed the standard for what use is "genuine" for the purposes of the anti-non-use mechanism. It affirmed that sporadic or token use — even where documented — does not satisfy the requirement if it does not reflect actual commercial exploitation of the mark in the relevant category. The court also confirmed that use by an authorised distributor, without a registered licence or a properly structured consent arrangement, creates evidentiary uncertainty about whether that use is attributable to the rights holder.

Third — and this is the element with the widest practical implication — the court observed that the adequacy of a use maintenance strategy is assessed cumulatively and retrospectively across the relevant look-back period, not by reference to activity at the time proceedings are initiated. Defensive filings of use evidence prepared only after a cancellation challenge has been raised routinely fail this standard.

"The cassation ruling confirms a pattern we have observed across a number of IP Court decisions: the evidential groundwork for defending a trademark portfolio must be laid continuously, not assembled in response to a challenge." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel overseeing Russian IP portfolios, the procedural architecture of cassation review means that the cassation stage offers no corrective opportunity for gaps in the factual record. The evidentiary window closes at first instance.

If your company holds registered marks in Russia and has not reviewed its use maintenance strategy recently, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What should foreign companies do differently in light of this decision?

The ruling reinforces several practices that courts have consistently rewarded — and several that they have consistently penalised — when foreign companies are engaged in defending trademark portfolio positions before Russian tribunals.

On documentation: evidence of use should be contemporaneous, category-specific, and tied directly to the registered form of the mark. Generic marketing collateral, website screenshots without metadata, or distributor invoices referencing a trade name rather than the registered mark have repeatedly been found inadequate. The bar is not impossibly high, but it requires a structured approach rather than ad hoc collection.

On licensing and authorised use: where the mark is used by a distributor, agent, or subsidiary rather than by the registrant directly, the legal basis for that use — and the registrant's control over quality and form — must be formally documented. Unregistered licences and informal consent arrangements create an attribution gap that challenges are specifically designed to exploit.

On portfolio monitoring: under Russian IP legislation, marks become vulnerable to non-use challenges after three years from registration. A portfolio of any material size will typically contain marks at different stages of that cycle. Companies that treat Russian trademark registration as a one-time administrative step, rather than as a recurring compliance obligation, consistently find themselves in a weaker position once cancellation proceedings are initiated. The costs of a structured use maintenance programme are modest relative to the cost of losing a registration — and, at cassation stage, there is no remedy for the loss once it has occurred.

On jurisdictional scope: it is worth noting that Russia's position within the EAEU and CIS frameworks means that some marks covering these territories may require parallel compliance strategies, since use in Russia may not automatically satisfy use requirements in other member states and vice versa. For companies with regional portfolios, this distinction is material.

Foreign companies that recognise these risks early — and act before a challenge is filed rather than after — are in a structurally stronger position than those who first address the question when a Rospatent filing by a third party has already set the timeline. Under Russian IP litigation practice, that timeline moves quickly, and the stages at which meaningful corrective action is available are more limited than most foreign rights holders expect. See our IP Enforcement practice for further context on how Russian courts approach these disputes, and our related analysis of how Russian courts approach defending a Russian trademark portfolio for additional procedural framing.

Our Matters Hub includes illustrative examples of how the firm has acted for foreign rights holders in analogous proceedings before the IP Court and Rospatent.

Discuss your trademark portfolio position in confidence — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this cassation ruling change for foreign trademark holders in Russia?

A: The ruling does not introduce new law, but it confirms and sharpens the standard courts apply when reviewing use maintenance evidence. Specifically, it confirms that cassation review is not a second opportunity to supplement an inadequate evidentiary record from the stages below. For foreign companies, the practical change is one of posture: the work required to sustain a trademark registration against a non-use challenge must be done on an ongoing basis, not assembled reactively once proceedings begin.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Three steps are advisable. First, audit current documentation of commercial use for each registered mark — particularly for marks approaching the three-year threshold — to assess whether the available evidence would satisfy the standard articulated by the IP Court. Second, review the contractual basis for use by distributors or affiliates to ensure that use is legally attributable to the registrant. Third, where the portfolio includes marks used across EAEU or CIS jurisdictions, assess whether the Russian compliance strategy accounts for any divergence in the use requirements of other member states. Early legal review — before a cancellation challenge is initiated — is considerably more cost-effective than a contested cassation proceeding.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry