Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Recent Russian judicial practice on franchise IP protection and enforcement in Russia — commentary

Elizaveta Razina · September 2026 · 7 min read

Russian courts are clarifying franchise IP obligations for foreign brand owners. Key findings for in-house counsel in Russia. Make an enquiry.

In advising foreign brand owners on franchise IP protection in Russia over the past several years, one question surfaces with increasing regularity among in-house counsel: how reliably will a Russian court enforce the trademark and know-how provisions written into a foreign-drafted commercial concession agreement? Recent Russian judicial practice suggests the answer has grown more nuanced — and, in certain respects, more demanding of franchisors — than many foreign legal teams have assumed.

Background

Franchise arrangements in Russia are governed by the commercial concession provisions of the Russian Civil Code, which establish mandatory requirements for the registration of the franchise agreement itself at Rospatent and for the concurrent recordal of any trademark licence granted under it. The intersection of these civil-law requirements with the practical reality of foreign brand ownership — where the franchisor holds international registrations but may not have maintained active Russian trademark filings — has produced a distinct category of franchise ip protection disputes in Russian courts.

The matter under review arose from a dispute between a foreign franchisor and its Russian franchisee, following termination of the commercial concession agreement. The franchisee continued to use the brand's core marks after termination, asserting that deficiencies in the agreement's registration at Rospatent rendered the trademark licence provisions unenforceable and, by extension, that the franchisor lacked standing to bring an infringement claim before a Russian state court. The legal question presented was whether procedural non-compliance by the rights-holder with Russian registration formalities could defeat an otherwise substantiated IP enforcement claim by a foreign brand owner in Russia.

This type of franchise IP protection dispute — where the franchisee invokes registration defects as a shield against post-termination infringement liability — has appeared with greater frequency in the caseload of Russian arbitrazh courts and, on further review, before the IP Court in its appellate capacity.

The decision

The court declined to accept the franchisee's argument in full. It held that while registration of a commercial concession agreement at Rospatent is a condition for the agreement's enforceability against third parties, it does not extinguish the rights-holder's underlying trademark ownership as between the contracting parties themselves. The franchisor's standing to bring an infringement claim was upheld on the basis that the registered trademark rights remained valid and vested in the foreign brand owner, irrespective of the procedural condition attached to the franchise instrument.

The ruling's more significant element, however, was the court's analysis of what constitutes actionable infringement in the post-termination period. The court found that continued use of the brand — including signage, digital assets, and consumer-facing materials — constituted infringement, and that the franchisee's reliance on the registration argument was not a good-faith defence. Compensation was awarded on the basis of a multiple of the licence fee that would have been payable under the agreement, a calculation method that Russian courts have increasingly applied in trademark Russia foreign brand disputes as an alternative to per-unit or market-price methodologies.

"Russian courts are developing a coherent body of doctrine on franchise IP enforcement that foreign in-house counsel should track carefully — the registration conditions and post-termination liability rules do not always operate as foreign practitioners expect." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

A secondary issue addressed in the ruling concerned the scope of know-how protection under the franchise arrangement. The court applied a relatively narrow standard, declining to grant relief in respect of operational materials that the franchisor had not positively identified and recorded as confidential at the outset of the franchise relationship. This aspect of the decision has practical consequences for any foreign company's internal documentation practices before and during a Russian franchise relationship.

For in-house counsel reviewing existing Russian franchise arrangements or evaluating a new franchise programme in Russia, an early review of trademark registration status and agreement recordal at Rospatent is advisable — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What does this ruling mean for foreign brand owners in Russia?

Three practical implications follow from this decision for foreign companies with active or prospective franchise programmes in Russia.

First, the ruling reinforces that trademark registration at Rospatent — and the concurrent recordal of any trademark licence granted under a commercial concession agreement — is not merely a bureaucratic formality. Foreign brand owners that have relied on international registrations without confirming Russian filing status are exposed to a specific category of enforcement difficulty: the registration defect argument may not succeed as a complete defence for the franchisee, as this ruling shows, but it introduces procedural complexity and cost that a properly maintained Russian registration avoids entirely.

Second, the court's treatment of post-termination liability is significant for how foreign companies draft termination provisions and what monitoring procedures they put in place during the notice period and after. Russian courts have shown a willingness to award compensation calculated by reference to the contractual licence fee, which means the financial exposure for an infringing franchisee — and the recovery potential for the franchisor — is directly connected to the fee structure agreed in the commercial concession agreement. In-house counsel should ensure that the fee provisions are drafted to reflect actual market value, not a nominal figure inserted for tax or regulatory reasons.

Third, the know-how dimension of this decision is a reminder that franchise IP protection in Russia extends beyond trademark rights. Operational manuals, training materials, proprietary systems, and recipes or formulations are protectable under Russian civil law — but the protection is conditional on the rights-holder having documented and identified the confidential character of those materials. Foreign companies that do not maintain formal confidential information registers risk finding, as the franchisor did in part here, that Russian courts will not extend protection to materials that were not positively designated at the time of disclosure.

For in-house counsel at multinationals managing a Russian franchise programme, the combination of registration compliance, post-termination monitoring, and know-how documentation is not a one-time exercise. It requires periodic review, particularly when the underlying trademark portfolio changes — through renewal, assignment, or the addition of new marks to the programme — or when an amendment to the commercial concession agreement is executed. Under Russian civil law, amendments that materially affect the scope of rights granted under a commercial concession agreement may require fresh recordal at Rospatent to take effect against third parties, a requirement that is frequently overlooked in amendment drafting.

The firm's IP Enforcement practice has acted for foreign franchisors in Russian termination and post-termination infringement matters. Related guidance is available in our analysis of regulatory developments in Russian franchise IP protection and in our overview of franchise IP considerations for foreign creditors holding Russian assets. Foreign companies managing IP risk across multiple Russian counterparties should also consider the firm's broader cross-border disputes practice where franchise terminations have a litigation dimension. A summary of representative matters is available on our matters page.

If you are reviewing a Russian franchise programme or anticipate a post-termination IP dispute in Russia — discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change for foreign franchisors enforcing IP rights in Russia?

A: The ruling confirms that a franchisor's trademark ownership is not defeated by procedural defects in the registration of the commercial concession agreement at Rospatent, at least as between the contracting parties. What it changes more significantly is the frame for post-termination infringement claims: Russian courts are applying a licence-fee-based compensation methodology that makes the financial outcome of enforcement directly dependent on how the fee provisions were originally drafted. Foreign franchisors with nominal or artificially low fee structures in their Russian agreements should consider whether those provisions remain appropriate in light of this development.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Three steps are advisable. First, verify that the trademark registrations underpinning any Russian franchise programme are in force at Rospatent and that the commercial concession agreement — and any amendments — have been recorded. Second, review the know-how provisions of the agreement: if operational materials, training programmes, or proprietary formulations have not been positively identified as confidential in the agreement or in a schedule to it, that gap should be addressed on the next contractual review. Third, ensure that termination procedures include a structured post-termination audit covering digital assets, signage, and supply chains — Russian courts will require evidence of continued use to support an infringement claim, and that evidence must be collected promptly.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry