Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Russian Supreme Court rules on prior use rights in Russian trademark proceedings: analysis and implications

Elizaveta Razina · January 2026 · 8 min read

Russia's Supreme Court has clarified prior use rights in trademark proceedings, narrowing the defence for foreign companies. Make an enquiry.

Foreign companies that rely on early market presence in Russia to defend against trademark infringement claims may find that recent Supreme Court guidance makes that defence considerably harder to sustain. Prior use rights — the principle that a party who used a designation in good faith before a registered mark's priority date may continue to do so — have long been acknowledged under Russian intellectual property legislation. What the Supreme Court's most recent analysis confirms is that those rights are strictly circumscribed: in scope, in geography, and in the manner of their proof. For in-house counsel managing a Russian subsidiary or monitoring a Russian IP portfolio, the practical effect is a reduction in the margin of comfort that prior use was once thought to provide.

Background

Prior use rights occupy a specific and deliberately narrow position in the Russian IP framework. Under the civil law governing intellectual property, a person who, before the priority date of a third party's registered trademark, used in good faith an identical or confusingly similar designation for goods or services may — in principle — continue that use. The right does not cancel or challenge the registration. It does not permit the prior user to register the designation. It operates solely as a defence against a registered rights-holder's infringement claim, and only within the boundaries established at the time the prior use began.

The doctrine matters acutely for foreign companies whose Russian market entry pre-dates a local bad-faith applicant's filing. In a recurring pattern encountered in Russian IP enforcement proceedings, a Russian entity registers a mark that resembles a foreign brand, then asserts infringement against the foreign company's local subsidiary or distributor. The foreign company's response has often rested, in part, on prior use — pointing to commercial activity in Russia predating the registration's priority date as evidence of a pre-existing entitlement.

The difficulty is that the evidentiary threshold for establishing prior use has never been uniformly applied across Russian courts. The Supreme Court's intervention addresses that inconsistency — but in a direction that narrows rather than broadens the available protection. The firm's wider analysis of how prior use rights arise and are pleaded in practice is set out in the related article on prior use rights in Russian trademark proceedings.

The decision

In a decision handed down in the latter part of the period under review, the Supreme Court considered a matter in which a foreign-origin brand, commercialised through a Russian distributor, sought to invoke the prior use defence against a registered trademark held by a domestic company. The court below had accepted the defence on the basis of sales records and commercial correspondence predating the priority date. The Supreme Court set that finding aside.

The court held that demonstrating commercial activity before the priority date is necessary but not sufficient to establish prior use rights under Russian intellectual property law. Three additional conditions must each be independently satisfied: first, the use must have been in good faith — meaning the prior user could not have known, or had no reason to know, of the registered rights-holder's preparatory steps toward registration; second, the designation used must be identical or closely comparable in its distinctive elements to the registered mark, assessed at the time of the alleged prior use rather than at the time of litigation; and third — and this is where the Supreme Court's reasoning is most consequential — the scope of protection afforded by the prior use right is fixed by the actual commercial footprint that existed before the priority date. Any expansion of use after that date, whether into new product categories, additional Russian regions, or new distribution channels, falls outside the protection and is actionable by the registered rights-holder.

The court's reasoning also addressed the standard of evidence. Documentary evidence of commercial activity was, in the court's view, insufficient on its own. The prior user must additionally demonstrate that the designation was perceived by the relevant public, within the relevant geographic market, as indicating origin from the prior user — not merely that the goods or services bearing that designation were present in the market.

"The ruling crystallises a long-standing tension in Russian IP practice: prior use is a viable defence in principle, but Russian courts will scrutinise the evidentiary record with considerable rigour — and the scope of protection will be fixed at the moment the right arose, not the moment it is asserted." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

Foreign-facing matters involving this issue are becoming more common in Russian IP enforcement proceedings. Firms instructing Russian counsel for the first time on a prior use question should review the firm's practical guide to prior use rights in Russia before engagement.

For in-house counsel who need to assess how this ruling affects a live IP position in Russia — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign companies

The immediate practical consequence is that a prior use argument, if it was previously treated as a reliable fallback in Russian trademark infringement proceedings, must now be re-evaluated with greater precision. The Supreme Court's formulation of the scope-fixation principle means that foreign companies whose Russian operations have grown since the priority date of a competing registration will find that growth working against them: the very expansion that demonstrates market success simultaneously excludes those expanded activities from the prior use protection.

For in-house counsel, this creates a specific audit requirement. If a Russian subsidiary or licensed distributor has extended its use of a brand into product lines, regional markets, or sales channels that were not established before the priority date of a competing registration, those extended activities are exposed — and the prior use defence will not cover them. Companies that have relied on prior use arguments in correspondence with Russian counterparties or in pending proceedings should revisit that reliance with Russian IP counsel in light of this analysis.

The good-faith element adds a further layer of complexity for foreign companies with global brand programmes. Where a foreign parent is aware — or arguably should be aware, through monitoring of national trademark registers — of a competing registration filed in Russia, that awareness may be attributed to its Russian subsidiary for the purposes of the good-faith assessment. Russian courts have not applied this attribution principle uniformly, and it remains an area of genuine uncertainty. The prevailing approach suggests, however, that global companies with active trademark monitoring programmes carry a higher evidential burden when asserting that prior use was in good faith.

Foreign companies holding Russian trademarks or managing cross-border IP portfolios may wish to review their Rospatent filing position and any outstanding opposition or cancellation proceedings in light of this ruling. A prior use argument that was previously presented as a primary defence may need to be repositioned as a secondary or supporting one, while a more robust challenge — invalidation of the competing registration on substantive grounds — is advanced in parallel. The firm's IP Enforcement practice advises on both routes, and on the interaction between invalidation proceedings before the IP Court and infringement defences in the arbitrazh courts. Companies with matters currently in progress should treat this as a prompt for counsel review.

The risk that foreign companies who have not registered their marks with Rospatent — and who are relying on prior use as their primary protection — now face a materially weakened position is real and not theoretical. In matters the firm has handled involving bad-faith registration by Russian parties, the prior use defence has been most effective when paired with an invalidation claim; on its own, it is increasingly insufficient. Counsel should plan accordingly.

If your company holds Russian trademarks or is responding to an infringement claim based on a Russian registration — discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The Supreme Court's decision establishes that demonstrating commercial activity before a competing registration's priority date is not, by itself, sufficient to sustain a prior use defence under Russian intellectual property law. Courts must additionally be satisfied that the use was in good faith, that the designation's distinctive elements correspond to those of the registered mark as assessed at the time of prior use, and — most significantly — that the scope of prior use protection is fixed by the commercial footprint that existed before the priority date. Any expansion of use after that date is not protected. The decision resolves a circuit-level inconsistency in favour of a stricter evidentiary standard and a narrower conception of the right's scope.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign companies that have relied on prior use arguments in Russian trademark proceedings, or that have treated prior use as a backstop against competing Russian registrations, should undertake an immediate assessment of their position. That assessment should address three questions: whether the commercial activity predating the competing registration's priority date was genuinely in good faith; whether the scope of current operations exceeds the footprint established before the priority date; and whether an invalidation claim against the competing registration is available and should be advanced in parallel or as a primary route. Where prior use was being advanced as a standalone defence, Russian IP counsel should be instructed to review whether that position remains viable or needs to be restructured.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry