A landmark Russian court ruling tightened the non-use defence for foreign trademark owners. What in-house counsel needs to know now. Make an enquiry.
Foreign trademark owners who rely on cross-border use of their marks — or on modest domestic activity — to defend against cancellation proceedings in Russia now face a significantly higher evidential bar. In a decision handed down in early 2026, the Russian IP Court considered what constitutes genuine use of a registered trademark sufficient to defeat a non-use cancellation claim brought by a third-party competitor. The court's reasoning, and its rejection of the registrant's evidence, carries immediate implications for in-house counsel managing Russian trademark portfolios on behalf of multinational groups.
Under Russian trademark law, a registered mark may be cancelled at the initiative of any interested party if the registrant cannot demonstrate genuine use of the mark on the Russian market for a continuous period — generally assessed over the five years preceding the claim. The mechanism is well-established: a claimant brings cancellation proceedings before the IP Court, the burden of proving use shifts to the registrant, and the court assesses the sufficiency of the evidence produced.
The case that prompted this comment arose in a sector where foreign brands are heavily represented. A third-party Russian company sought cancellation of a mark registered in the name of a foreign corporate registrant, arguing that the mark had not been used in Russia in the relevant classes for the requisite period. The foreign registrant was a subsidiary of a multinational group with broader European operations.
What made this matter noteworthy was the nature of the defence. The registrant produced evidence that included: website materials in the Russian language, a limited number of invoices for goods supplied to affiliated entities in Russia, and references to the group's distribution arrangements. The IP Court considered each category of evidence in turn. It found that the evidence was insufficient to establish genuine use of the mark as required, and ordered cancellation of the registration in the relevant classes.
The IP Court's analysis centred on two questions: whether the use demonstrated was genuine rather than token, and whether it was use in the course of trade on the Russian market specifically. On the first question, the court declined to treat internal group transactions — supplies between affiliated entities at transfer prices — as equivalent to commercial use directed at the Russian market. The volume and frequency of those transactions, the court found, did not reflect normal commercialisation of the mark.
On the second question, the court addressed the registrant's website materials with some care. It acknowledged that a Russian-language website accessible in Russia can in principle constitute evidence of use in appropriate circumstances. However, it held that website presence alone, without corroboration from actual trade activity — such as sales to unaffiliated third parties, distributor agreements, or consumer-facing marketing — fell short of what the law requires.
"This ruling reflects a pattern we have observed across several recent IP Court decisions: the court is applying genuine scrutiny to use evidence, and the threshold for what counts as genuine commercial use in Russia has become noticeably more demanding." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners
The court also addressed the possibility of partial cancellation. Where a mark is registered across multiple classes or covers a range of goods and services, the court may cancel the registration only in respect of those classes where use has not been demonstrated, preserving it in classes where evidence is adequate. In this matter, partial cancellation was ordered: the registration survived in one class where the evidence was found to be sufficient, but was cancelled in the remaining classes. This outcome — selective rather than total cancellation — is itself significant, as it confirms the court's approach of granular class-by-class assessment rather than a binary determination.
For in-house counsel reviewing the sufficiency of use evidence held on file for Russian trademark registrations — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
For multinationals with Russian trademark registrations — particularly where those registrations are held by a local subsidiary or a foreign parent entity with limited direct Russian trading activity — this decision is a practical prompt to audit existing use evidence.
Three issues emerge from the court's reasoning that in-house counsel should address directly.
First, intra-group transactions are unlikely to be sufficient on their own. The court's scepticism about affiliated-entity supplies is consistent with the broader principle that trademark use must reflect genuine commercial activity on the relevant market. Where a multinational's Russian sales flow principally through a related distributor or subsidiary, the evidence of use must clearly document those transactions and demonstrate they are commercial in nature.
Second, digital presence requires trade-activity corroboration. A Russian-language website or e-commerce listing is now likely to be treated as supporting evidence rather than primary evidence of use. In-house counsel should ensure that online materials are backed by records of actual transactions — invoices, delivery documents, payment records — involving third-party customers.
Third, the class-level assessment matters. Registrations that cover a broad range of classes as a matter of portfolio strategy, without active use across all of them, carry meaningful cancellation risk. A targeted competitor can seek partial cancellation of the weaker classes while the core registration survives — limiting the mark's scope of protection in precisely the areas where enforcement is most commercially relevant.
The practical implication is that use evidence should be assembled and maintained proactively, class by class, and reviewed at regular intervals — not compiled reactively when a cancellation claim arrives. The IP Enforcement practice at Vetrov & Partners advises foreign registrants on use-evidence frameworks as part of portfolio management.
For further context on Rospatent's guidance on this area, see our related analysis: Rospatent issues guidance on trademark cancellation: what registrants need to know and Trademark cancellation on grounds of non-use: a foreign owner's guide.
Our Matters section includes further examples of the firm's work in IP enforcement and trademark cancellation proceedings.
If your company holds Russian trademark registrations with limited recent use evidence — discuss your matter in confidence: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Q: What does this ruling change about the standard for proving trademark use in Russia?
A: The ruling reinforces and sharpens the existing requirement that use must be genuine and directed at the Russian market. What the IP Court made more explicit is that intra-group transactions and website presence, standing alone, are not sufficient to discharge the burden of proof. The decision does not introduce a new legal standard, but it signals that courts will scrutinise the quality and commercial reality of use evidence rather than accepting it at face value. For foreign registrants, this means the evidentiary bar for defending a non-use cancellation claim in Russia is meaningfully higher than a straightforward reading of the statutory framework might suggest.
Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?
A: The immediate priority is a class-by-class review of existing Russian trademark registrations, with a focus on identifying any classes where active, documented use involving third-party commercial transactions cannot be demonstrated. Where gaps exist, companies should consider whether use can be established or enhanced within the relevant period, whether the registration in weaker classes is commercially necessary, or whether a proactive filing strategy is needed. Use-evidence files should be maintained on an ongoing basis rather than assembled only when a cancellation claim is filed. In-house counsel with responsibility for Russian IP portfolios should treat this ruling as a prompt for systematic portfolio hygiene rather than a one-off reactive exercise.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry