Novosibirsk · Russian-qualified counsel Recognised by Pravo-300 · Best Lawyers · Kommersant
Asset Tracing & Recovery

Russian judicial practice on IP Court proceedings for trademark disputes in Russia against state-related entities — commentary

Elizaveta Razina · February 2026 · 7 min read

IP Court proceedings vs state-related entities in Russia pose distinct challenges. What foreign trademark owners need to know now. Make an enquiry.

Foreign trademark owners whose marks are contested by state-related entities in Russia face a set of procedural and substantive pressures that differ materially from disputes with private counterparties. Russian IP Court proceedings in this category have produced a body of rulings that reshape how in-house counsel should approach both pre-litigation strategy and the proceedings themselves. The decisions reviewed here reflect patterns observed across recent IP Court practice and carry direct implications for foreign companies maintaining registered portfolios in Russia under IP enforcement in Russia.

Background

The Russian IP Court — the specialised court within the Russian commercial court system — handles disputes over the validity of intellectual property rights as a court of first instance, and acts on cassation review of IP-related commercial disputes. Trademark disputes brought against state-related entities, or in which a state-related entity asserts rights adverse to a foreign owner, present a particular configuration of legal and procedural considerations.

In the cases informing this commentary, the factual pattern recurs in broadly consistent form. A foreign company holding a registered Russian trademark discovers that a state-related entity — typically a federal or regional unitary enterprise, a state corporation, or a body operating under a state mandate — has either filed a cancellation action on grounds of non-use, applied to register a confusingly similar designation, or raised a priority challenge rooted in Soviet-era or early post-Soviet use. The commercial context is often the defence sector, natural resources, or transport infrastructure — sectors in which state-related entities have historically operated under brand identifiers predating modern trademark registration requirements.

The legal question before the IP Court in each instance is, in formal terms, identical to that arising in a private-party dispute: whether the contested mark meets the statutory conditions for registration or retention. In practice, the evidentiary and procedural dynamics shift when one party is state-related. The court's approach to documentary evidence of prior use, the weight accorded to historical administrative records, and the standard applied in assessing likelihood of confusion each bear examination. The firm's IP practice has reviewed this pattern across matters involving trademark proceedings before the IP Court, and the observations below draw on that experience.

The decision

The IP Court has, across the period under review, maintained that state-related status does not confer procedural immunity or substantive advantage in trademark proceedings. This is the formal starting position, and it holds in most circumstances. However, the court's handling of certain categories of evidence tends to produce outcomes that foreign owners should understand before formulating their litigation posture.

First, the IP Court has given significant weight to historical use evidence produced by state-related entities — including pre-1991 administrative documentation, production marks affixed to goods under Soviet ministerial directives, and post-privatisation records from successor entities. Foreign owners challenging such evidence on authenticity or relevance grounds have faced a high evidential threshold. The court does not automatically discount evidence from prior administrative periods, even where the chain of title from the Soviet-era user to the current state-related claimant is not comprehensively documented. In-house counsel should not assume that gaps in succession evidence will be treated as fatal to the counterparty's claim.

Second, where a state-related entity asserts that a foreign owner's mark causes confusion with a designation historically associated with state supply chains or public-sector procurement, the court has applied a broadened conception of the relevant consumer base. Goods and services directed at public sector procurement are not assessed against a narrow commercial consumer; the court considers familiarity with the designation among procurement officials and institutional buyers. This has, in several cases, expanded the field of relevant goods and services in ways that disadvantage foreign owners asserting a narrower market.

Third, the court has been notably consistent in one respect: it does not accept political or national-interest framing as a substantive ground. Arguments that the foreign owner's mark should be cancelled or subordinated on non-IP grounds have been rejected at the pleading stage. The IP Court applies standard trademark analysis. This is a material point for foreign counsel assessing the integrity of the forum.

"The IP Court's refusal to accept national-interest framing as a substantive ground represents an important structural constraint on proceedings against foreign trademark owners — one that in-house counsel should document and rely upon at every stage." — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners

For in-house counsel managing a Russian trademark portfolio that may be exposed to challenges from state-related entities, the evidentiary picture described above makes early documentary preparation the most material risk-control lever available.

If your Russian trademark portfolio faces a challenge from a state-related entity, or if you are assessing exposure ahead of a potential dispute, make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |

What this means for foreign clients

The rulings reviewed here do not indicate that the IP Court is systematically hostile to foreign trademark owners in proceedings against state-related entities. The formal equality of the parties is observed. What they do indicate is that the evidentiary and analytical framework contains specific pressure points that require deliberate preparation — and that waiting until proceedings are filed to address them is, in practice, too late.

Foreign companies operating in sectors where state-related entities are active should conduct a priority and use audit of their Russian marks before any dispute arises. This means assembling contemporaneous evidence of use in Russia — licensed use by Russian distributors and subsidiaries, advertising and promotional materials, import and customs records — in a form that can be produced before the IP Court without reconstruction. Under Russian IP enforcement practice, use evidence that post-dates the filing of a cancellation action carries materially less weight than evidence generated and retained in the ordinary course of business.

Where a state-related entity has filed a competing application or asserted prior rights, the window for protective action at Rospatent — before the matter escalates to IP Court proceedings — is narrow. Rospatent examination and opposition procedures run on statutory timelines, and delay at the administrative stage forecloses procedural options that are not available in the same form before the court. The related legislative context for these procedures is examined in our analysis of legislative amendments affecting IP Court proceedings in Russia.

The cross-EAEU dimension also warrants attention. State-related entities frequently hold corresponding registrations in other EAEU member states — particularly Belarus and Kazakhstan — and a challenge in Russia may be connected to parallel filings across the bloc. A coordinated assessment of EAEU exposure is advisable where the counterparty's designation spans multiple member states. For an overview of the broader procedural landscape for trademark disputes in this context, see our practice briefing on IP Court proceedings for trademark disputes in Russia.

Foreign companies whose Russian trademarks are commercially significant should treat state-related counterparties in this sector as a distinct risk category — not because the court system will favour them, but because their evidence base and institutional resources create asymmetries that well-prepared counsel can address, and unprepared counsel typically cannot.

To discuss your firm's Russian trademark exposure or to request a portfolio review, contact Elizaveta Razina at info@vetrovpartners.com |

Frequently asked questions

Q: What does this ruling change?

A: The IP Court rulings reviewed in this commentary do not introduce new law. What they clarify is the evidential and analytical approach the court applies when one party is a state-related entity. Specifically, they confirm that historical use documentation — including pre-1991 and early post-Soviet records — will be assessed on its merits rather than dismissed on procedural grounds, and that the relevant consumer base may be interpreted more broadly in public-sector procurement contexts. They also confirm, consistently, that political or national-interest framing is not accepted as a substantive ground. For foreign trademark owners, the practical change is in the level of preparation required before any dispute is filed, not in the formal legal framework.

Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?

A: Foreign companies holding Russian trademarks in sectors where state-related entities are active should take three immediate steps. First, audit the use evidence currently available for each commercially significant mark registered in Russia — prioritising records generated in the ordinary course of business over the past three to five years. Second, identify any Rospatent filings or opposition proceedings involving state-related entities as applicants or opponents, and assess whether the administrative timetable permits protective action before escalation to IP Court proceedings. Third, consider whether corresponding EAEU registrations held by the same or connected state-related entities create exposure in Belarus, Kazakhstan, or other member states. These steps are best taken under the guidance of experienced Russian IP counsel, given the evidentiary specificity that IP Court proceedings require.

Practitioner note

This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.

Facing a matter like this?

Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.

Make an enquiry