Russian arbitrazh courts are developing a distinct body of practice on parallel import disputes at first instance. What in-house counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.
In the years following Russia's 2022 shift to a national exhaustion regime for intellectual property, parallel import disputes under Russian law have moved from an abstract policy question to live litigation in arbitrazh courts across the country. For multinational companies whose goods — or goods bearing their marks — are now entering Russia through non-authorised channels, the pattern of first instance decisions issued since that shift offers the clearest available signal of how Russian courts approach these disputes in practice.
Russia's pivot away from international exhaustion was effected swiftly by government resolution in spring 2022, following the withdrawal of major foreign brands from the Russian market. Under the new framework, the importation and resale of genuine branded goods without the rights holder's consent became permissible for a wide range of product categories — a departure from the position that Russian courts and Rospatent had upheld for the preceding decade.
The practical consequence was a wave of commercial activity: importers, re-sellers, and distributors began sourcing goods from EAEU member states and third countries, relabelling where required, and placing products into Russian retail channels without consulting the original brand owner. Rights holders — including in-house legal teams at multinationals — faced the immediate question of whether any legal tools remained available to them under Russian IP legislation and, if so, at what stage of the dispute those tools were most effective.
It is at the first instance stage before Russian arbitrazh courts that these questions have been resolved most concretely. The case discussed here is representative of a pattern the firm has observed across multiple disputes: a foreign rights holder bringing an infringement or compensation claim against a parallel importer, with the first instance court applying the post-2022 framework in a manner that reveals both the residual scope for rights-holder protection and the points at which Russian courts are unwilling to intervene.
In a decision handed down by a Russian arbitrazh court at first instance in the post-2022 period, the rights holder — a foreign trademark owner whose goods had been imported and sold in Russia without authorisation — brought a claim seeking compensation and an injunction to restrain further sales. The importer defended on the basis that the goods were genuine, sourced through a recognised supply chain outside Russia, and fell within the categories permissible under the revised exhaustion rules.
The court's analysis proceeded through three distinct lines of inquiry. First, it examined the authenticity of the goods: were these genuine products bearing the claimant's mark, or counterfeits? This threshold question was dispositive of a significant part of the claim — the court confirmed that the national exhaustion framework affords no protection to counterfeit goods, and claims in respect of counterfeits survive the 2022 reform intact. Second, the court turned to the category question: did the goods fall within the government-approved list of products eligible for parallel importation? On the facts, they did. Third, and most significantly for rights holders monitoring this area, the court examined whether the importation caused demonstrable harm to the quality, safety, or consumer presentation of the goods — a ground that Russian IP legislation preserves as a basis for rights-holder intervention even within the parallel import regime.
The court held that where goods are genuine, fall within an approved category, and have not been interfered with in a way that affects their quality or safety, the rights holder's compensation claim does not succeed at first instance. The injunction was declined on corresponding grounds.
"[In this line of first instance decisions, Russian arbitrazh courts are doing something precise: they are drawing the residual perimeter of rights-holder protection within the parallel import regime, and the perimeter is narrower than many rights holders assumed.]" — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners
For in-house counsel assessing the firm's current exposure to parallel import litigation in Russia, an early-stage review of product category coverage and quality-interference arguments is the most productive starting point. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
The first instance pattern has several practical implications for in-house teams managing Russian IP enforcement portfolios.
The authenticity and category analysis now forms the threshold of any parallel import claim in Russia. Foreign companies whose goods are being imported through non-authorised channels must establish, before proceedings begin, that the goods in question are either not genuine or do not fall within the approved category list. Where the goods are genuine and the category is covered, the first instance court is unlikely to grant relief on infringement or compensation grounds alone.
The quality and safety ground, however, remains viable and has been upheld at first instance where the importer modified packaging, removed safety or language markings required by Russian technical regulations, or otherwise altered the consumer presentation of the product. For rights holders, this ground is the most structurally resilient within the current regime, and it is the one that first instance courts have been most willing to engage with on the merits. Companies that have documented their product specifications, mandatory labelling requirements, and authorised-channel quality controls are better positioned to advance this argument credibly.
A further implication concerns the timing of Rospatent engagement. Filing with Rospatent — whether to register a mark, record a licence, or update the customs register — remains relevant to procedural standing in Russian IP litigation, including parallel import disputes. Courts at first instance have declined to engage with rights-holder claims where the claimant's Russian IP registration position was unclear or outdated. In-house teams should treat Rospatent filing status as a prerequisite to any enforcement strategy, not a parallel workstream.
For companies facing live parallel import disputes or considering first instance proceedings in Russia, the procedural window matters. Under the general limitation framework applicable to IP claims in Russian civil and commercial courts, the period for bringing compensation claims is finite. Rights holders who delay while monitoring the regulatory position risk losing the ability to bring claims in respect of past infringement even if the legal landscape later shifts in their favour.
If your company is navigating a parallel import dispute in a Russian arbitrazh court at first instance, or reviewing its IP enforcement position under the post-2022 framework, we are available to advise. Make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Q: What did this first instance decision change about how Russian courts approach parallel import disputes?
A: The decision — consistent with a broader pattern in post-2022 Russian arbitrazh court practice — clarified that the national exhaustion framework does not extinguish all rights-holder tools. Courts at first instance are applying a structured three-stage analysis: authenticity of the goods, category eligibility under the approved list, and quality or safety interference. Rights holders retain viable grounds where goods are counterfeit or where importers have modified packaging, labelling, or product presentation. The decision did not expand rights-holder protection, but it confirmed the boundaries of the residual protection that survives the 2022 reform — which is itself practically significant for in-house teams recalibrating their Russian enforcement strategy.
Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?
A: Three steps are worth prioritising. First, audit the product category coverage: confirm whether the goods in question fall within the government-approved list and whether that list has been amended since the initial 2022 resolution — the list has been updated on multiple occasions and its scope varies by sector. Second, review and document quality and safety specifications: the ground most likely to succeed at Russian first instance is quality or safety interference, and courts require concrete evidence of the modification. Third, verify Rospatent registration and customs-register status: standing issues have caused rights-holder claims to fail on procedural grounds at first instance before the merits were reached. Engaging Russian IP counsel before proceedings are issued — rather than after — is the most efficient use of the pre-litigation period.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry