Russian courts are extending trade dress and get-up protection against privately held copyists. What in-house counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.
Foreign companies that rely on trade dress and get-up as competitive assets in Russia face a specific and often underestimated risk: a privately held Russian company replicating their product presentation with sufficient variation to avoid obvious trade mark infringement while capturing the same commercial impression. Russian courts have, in a line of decisions that has grown more consistent over recent years, begun to address this gap — recognising that the overall appearance of a product or its packaging can be independently protectable, even without a registered figurative or three-dimensional trade mark. Understanding where that protection begins and ends is now a practical concern for any in-house counsel managing a Russian IP portfolio.
Trade dress and get-up protection in Russia sits at the intersection of several legal instruments. Russian civil legislation provides protection for registered trade marks — including three-dimensional marks and marks in a specific colour combination — but the protection of overall commercial presentation that falls short of a registrable sign has historically required claimants to rely on unfair competition provisions enforced by the Federal Antimonopoly Service (FAS Russia) or, increasingly, on the general prohibition against the misappropriation of another's business reputation and the slavish imitation of commercial image that Russian courts have read into broader civil liability doctrine.
The matter giving rise to this commentary involved a foreign consumer goods company with well-established packaging across several product lines — specific colour gradients, a distinctive layout structure, and a proprietary label design — that had been in continuous commercial use in Russia for more than a decade. A privately held Russian manufacturer introduced a competing product line whose packaging reproduced the overall visual impression of the foreign company's goods at the level that a typical consumer, exercising ordinary attention, would be likely to confuse the two. The Russian manufacturer had not registered any of the individual elements as trade marks. The foreign company brought proceedings before the relevant commercial court, combining a trade mark infringement claim in respect of registered elements with an unfair competition claim in respect of the get-up as a whole.
The commercial court of first instance upheld both limbs of the claim. On the trade mark infringement limb, the analysis was conventional: the court applied the standard likelihood of confusion assessment, comparing the registered marks against the infringing signs and finding confusing similarity. The more significant aspect of the ruling was the court's treatment of the get-up claim. The court held that the overall visual presentation of a product — including the combination of colour, layout, typographic hierarchy, and decorative elements — can constitute a protected commercial image capable of giving rise to an unfair competition finding, provided the claimant demonstrates prior use, acquired distinctiveness in the Russian market, and a causal link between the imitation and the likelihood of consumer confusion.
The IP Court, hearing the matter on appeal, affirmed this analysis and clarified a point of particular practical significance: the absence of individual registered rights in each design element does not prevent the court from evaluating the cumulative impression of those elements as a protectable whole. The court distinguished between the protection of individual graphic elements — which requires registration — and the protection of the total visual identity of a product as it appears to the relevant consumer. The latter, the IP Court confirmed, can be protected under the unfair competition framework without a complete portfolio of registered rights.
The privately held Russian respondent's primary defence — that each individual element of the packaging was either functional, generic, or used across the industry — was rejected on the evidence. The court found that the combination and arrangement of those elements, taken together, had acquired secondary meaning in the Russian market through the foreign company's sustained commercial presence.
"[The IP Court's confirmation that cumulative get-up can be protected independently of individual element registration is a material shift — one that gives foreign brand owners a meaningful cause of action even where their registration strategy has gaps.]" — Elizaveta Razina, Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners
For in-house counsel reviewing trade dress exposure across a Russian product portfolio — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
For in-house counsel, the ruling has implications in two directions. First, it strengthens the enforcement position of foreign companies whose trade dress has acquired distinctiveness in Russia through sustained market presence. Where a privately held Russian company is engaged in get-up imitation that does not replicate individual registered marks directly, proceedings before the commercial courts — combining a trade mark claim on registered elements with an unfair competition claim on overall presentation — are more viable than they were under earlier, more cautious judicial interpretations.
Second, and this is where the practical risk is most acute: the same analytical framework can be turned against foreign companies that themselves enter a market sector where a Russian competitor has established a distinctive commercial image. Foreign companies launching new product lines or rebranding existing ones in Russia should conduct get-up clearance analysis — not only a trade mark search — before committing to a visual identity. The gap between registrable marks and protectable get-up, which courts are now actively bridging, cuts in both directions.
The decision also underscores the value of maintaining systematic evidence of Russian market presence: sales volumes, advertising expenditure, consumer surveys, and media coverage — all of which fed into the secondary meaning analysis in this matter. Companies whose commercial use in Russia is real but poorly documented will find that evidential burden more difficult to discharge.
In the firm's IP enforcement practice [/practices/ip-enforcement/], we have seen the unfair competition route become more reliable as a complement to registered rights enforcement in exactly the type of dispute this ruling addresses. Separately, the IP Court's clarification of cumulative get-up protection is consistent with the analytical approach discussed in our related commentary on Russian Supreme Court clarification on trade dress [/insights/ip-lu-010-russian-supreme-court-clarification-on-trade-/] and in our practical guide to navigating trade dress and get-up protection [/insights/ip-pb-010-navigating-trade-dress-and-get-up-protection-/].
Companies that delay reviewing their Russian get-up documentation risk finding that, when enforcement action is needed, the evidential record required to satisfy the secondary meaning threshold is simply not available.
To discuss a trade dress or get-up enforcement matter in Russia — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
Q: What does this ruling change for foreign trademark owners enforcing trade dress in Russia?
A: The ruling confirms that Russian courts — including the IP Court on appeal — will assess the cumulative visual impression of a product's presentation as a protectable commercial image under the unfair competition framework, independently of whether each individual element is the subject of a registered trade mark. For foreign brand owners, this means that enforcement action against privately held Russian companies engaged in get-up imitation is viable even where the registration portfolio does not cover every design component. The key requirements are demonstrated prior use in the Russian market, acquired distinctiveness through that use, and evidence of consumer confusion likelihood arising from the imitation.
Q: What should foreign companies do in light of this decision?
A: Three steps are advisable. First, audit the Russian registration portfolio against the full visual identity actually in use — and identify elements of commercial presentation that rely on use-based protection rather than registration. Second, assemble and maintain systematic evidence of Russian market presence: this is the foundation of any secondary meaning argument, and courts apply a rigorous evidential standard. Third, conduct get-up clearance before launching or rebranding in Russia, since the same framework that protects established foreign brands also exposes entrants who inadvertently replicate a locally distinctive Russian competitor's commercial image. Legal advice specific to the product category and market sector involved is advisable at each stage.
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry