Russian trademark proceedings under Article 1515 allow prior use as a defence. Here is what in-house counsel needs to know. Make an enquiry.
When a foreign company's product or brand is accused of trademark infringement in Russia and the claimant seeks compensation under Russian trademark legislation, a prior use rights defence involves a defined sequence of procedural steps. The defence is available where the defendant can demonstrate that its use of the designation in Russia preceded the claimant's registration date — but the evidential and procedural burden sits entirely with the defendant.
The core procedural sequence is as follows.
First, establish and document the date of first use. The defendant must identify the earliest verifiable instance of the designation's use in Russia — whether on goods, packaging, invoices, promotional materials, or at trade exhibitions — and assemble dated, contemporaneous evidence. Russian courts give significant weight to third-party corroborated evidence: notarised documents, customs declarations, and dated advertising records from independent sources carry more weight than internal company records alone.
Second, assess whether a challenge to the trademark registration itself is warranted. In many prior use situations, the stronger strategic position is not to defend the infringement claim in isolation, but to file a separate application at Rospatent — or, where applicable, directly before the IP Court — seeking cancellation of the claimant's trademark on grounds of bad faith registration or, where the mark has not been put to genuine use, non-use. Cancellation proceedings and infringement proceedings may run in parallel; a successful cancellation neutralises the compensation claim.
Third, present the prior use defence formally within the state commercial court proceedings. The defendant files its written position setting out the chronology of use, the geographic and commercial scope of that use, and the evidentiary basis. The IP Court, as the appellate instance for intellectual property disputes, reviews both factual and legal questions and may re-examine the compensation quantum where prior use affects the liability finding.
One structural caution: Russian trademark legislation does not codify a "prior use right" in the same explicit terms as patent law does. The defence is constructed through the general framework of rights priority, challenge to the claimant's title, and, where relevant, principles of bad faith. Courts in different circuits have treated the scope of the defence with some variation — in-house counsel should not assume that documented prior use will automatically defeat a compensation claim without a carefully constructed legal argument.
For detailed analysis of the prior use framework, see Prior Use Rights in Russian Trademark Proceedings and A Practical Guide to Prior Use Rights in Russia. For the broader IP enforcement context, visit the IP Enforcement practice page.
If your company is facing a compensation claim under Russian trademark legislation and prior use may be relevant — make an enquiry: info@vetrovpartners.com |
— Elizaveta Razina Senior Lawyer, Practice Lead — IP Enforcement, Vetrov & Partners vetrovpartners.com/razina/
Elizaveta Razina leads the firm's intellectual property practice, representing foreign trademark owners in infringement proceedings before Russian state courts and the IP Court. She has been with the firm since 2012 and holds a degree from Novosibirsk State University (2013).
This briefing is general information and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on a specific matter, write in confidence to info@vetrovpartners.com.
Our team advises foreign clients on exactly these questions across Russia and the EAEU region. Initial 30-minute consultation — complimentary.
Make an enquiry